Alec Torelli | Poker & Decision Making's banner
Alec Torelli | Poker & Decision Making's profile picture

Alec Torelli | Poker & Decision Making

@AlecTorelli • 17,499 subscribers

Poker pro & coach | speaker & author. Lessons from poker on decision making and risk. Founder @ConsciousPoker Code "ALEC" on @phenompokerapp

Shorts

I see the protests in France are trending. Since I just spent 10 days there during the heart of them, I figured I'd chime in with what's actually going on. The news and clickbait accounts on X will show you the outlier events: burning buildings, raging violence and everything that triggers you. I was in the heart of Aix en Provence during the biggest protest day and filmed the center where it was happening. (See below) This is right the University, across from the church, dead center of town. The students are dancing, singing, kicking soccer balls and have comically barricaded the entrance doors to force the school to close. I visited many cities in France during the protest period, and saw zero violence or malpractice of any kind. More broadly, I spent more than a month this year in France across 3 trips and 10+ cities, including Paris, Bordeaux, Aix en Provence, Nice, Antibes, Biarritz, and others, and it's incredibly safe, charming, peaceful and beautiful. Every city I visited is nicer than almost every American city, and there's zero comparison. So much that it wouldn't even be insulting to France to try, because nobody who has spent significant time in both countries would take this comparison seriously. I spoke with the students at length about their views. I also spoke with waiters, drivers, merchants, staff and whoever. They were all civil, well articulated and genuinely wanted to see change. We can disagree about their reasoning, logic or whatever, and it's true that France has fiscal problems, but to chalk up the France protests to raging extremist violence from "pick your favorite group to blame", is a laughable misrepresentation of what's actually going on. If you exclusively watch the news and believe the top 1% extreme situations, you have likely been psyoped.

I see the protests in France are trending. Since I just spent 10 days there during the heart of them, I figured I'd chime in with what's actually going on. The news and clickbait accounts on X will show you the outlier events: burning buildings, raging violence and everything that triggers you. I was in the heart of Aix en Provence during the biggest protest day and filmed the center where it was happening. (See below) This is right the University, across from the church, dead center of town. The students are dancing, singing, kicking soccer balls and have comically barricaded the entrance doors to force the school to close. I visited many cities in France during the protest period, and saw zero violence or malpractice of any kind. More broadly, I spent more than a month this year in France across 3 trips and 10+ cities, including Paris, Bordeaux, Aix en Provence, Nice, Antibes, Biarritz, and others, and it's incredibly safe, charming, peaceful and beautiful. Every city I visited is nicer than almost every American city, and there's zero comparison. So much that it wouldn't even be insulting to France to try, because nobody who has spent significant time in both countries would take this comparison seriously. I spoke with the students at length about their views. I also spoke with waiters, drivers, merchants, staff and whoever. They were all civil, well articulated and genuinely wanted to see change. We can disagree about their reasoning, logic or whatever, and it's true that France has fiscal problems, but to chalk up the France protests to raging extremist violence from "pick your favorite group to blame", is a laughable misrepresentation of what's actually going on. If you exclusively watch the news and believe the top 1% extreme situations, you have likely been psyoped.

833,019 次观看

Videos

AlecTorelli's profile picture

I spent 2.5 hours watching this debate between Saifedean Ammous, Jason Hickel and Pavlina R Tcherneva. This 60 second clip is the crux of Saif’s argument. I kept waiting for a clear answer to one basic question: why does the money supply have to grow in the first place? Tcherneva says production is financed by credit, which requires money creation. She mentioned we need an “elastic” money supply as a fixed one risks defaults. Saif’s response was cogent: why can’t credit come from existing capital? Why can’t the threat of an ill managed bank and a subsequent bank run actually reduce the likelihood that banks mismanaged capital? I remain unconvinced anyone gave a compelling answer. In Hickel’s defense, he pushed back several times on being lumped in with “central bank propaganda” and agreed with Saif that inflation is a problem. I’ve watched several of his interviews and find his ideas compelling. Where they agreed: bailing out banks is wrong, the money system is undemocratic, and spending on public services beats spending on war. The overlap ends there. They disagree largely on how to fix the issue. An analogy. Think about The Ring in Lord of the Rings. Saif basically says the mere existence of The Ring is the problem, because it always ends up in the hands of people who abuse it. His argument is simple. Centrally controlled money gives a select few enormous power over the economy. The central bankers sit above all laws and will use their power to fund wars, debase the currency and enrich themselves. Power corrupts, so the best way to ensure fairness is to remove it entirely. Throw it in the fire! Hickel agrees money isn’t being used properly, but thinks we should fix the system rather than scrap it. According to Hickel, the root problem is capitalism, not money, and the fix is democratic control of finance and production. He says tax the rich to pull excess demand out of the economy, and guide bank credit toward things society needs, like health care, public transport and clean energy. In other words, The Ring can be used for good if we build better rules around it. Those specific proposals deserved to be tested. On this central theme, I was left with more questions than answers. - Can taxing the rich really offset the demand? Can we make rules for how money is used at a society level without succumbing to regulatory capture? The debate drifted elsewhere before anyone dug in. Hickel didn’t explain how this would work in practice, nor did Saif properly address the mechanics of why it wouldn’t work. (Rather, he mainly pointed back to the inevitability of central planning leading to corruption). What do you guys think? - Alec ♠️ P.S. I’d love to continue this conversation if they are open to it in a future interview. I'll read up on anything they present ahead of time, take diligent notes and aim to address the root of the debate. I believe this is one of the most pressing issues of our time, and I’d be honored to help make society work better for everyone.

Alec Torelli | Poker & Decision Making

13,978 次观看 • 5 天前

没有更多内容可加载