vivian 🍉 | afk!'s banner
vivian 🍉 | afk!'s profile picture

vivian 🍉 | afk!

@fanathaliw91,225 subscribers

Shorts

the real insider:

the real insider:

29,413 Aufrufe

POV: when u come across a boy whose page is full of his lover

POV: when u come across a boy whose page is full of his lover

29,068 Aufrufe

😉💅 👁️👅👁️

😉💅 👁️👅👁️

20,623 Aufrufe

Videos

fanathaliw9's profile picture

"tops/semes" have been doing cute performances long before this lineup existed. this isn't some new strategy exclusive to the current roster. cute stages, especially to girl group songs, have been part of idol culture for years because they're popular and trendy, not because they're inherently "feminine." yes, marketing exists. no one is denying that. but marketing alone isn't evidence that a company is intentionally pushing a "fem × masc" dynamic or heteronormativity. those are conclusions that need evidence, not assumptions based on one performance. (why would we even based gender expression on performances?!?) people also keep treating every cute stage as if it automatically means the artists have no agency. unless there's actual evidence they're being forced, claiming they're uncomfortable is still speculation. ironically, that becomes another form of gender policing because u're deciding how they should express themselves based on the role they play. and what if they're genuinely comfortable and PROUD with those performances? like they work hard for it for months, imagine reading tweets insisting you're secretly being forced or that you should perform differently because you're the "top." that's still reducing people to seme/uke stereotypes instead of letting them express themselves however they want. if the goal is to challenge gender stereotypes, then replacing one expectation with is the same thing. freedom of expression means no one should have to prove their authenticity by performing more masculinity or more femininity or have to perform BOTH. whether it's for marketing or not, it's never the artists' fault. we shouldn't make assumptions that could end up hurting them, especially without evidence. at the end of the day, these are just stage performances not a measure of someone's gender expression, identity, or personal comfort. CREDITS : midorialien nx, arfo N. on yt

vivian 🍉 | afk!

25,345 Aufrufe • vor 1 Monat

Keine weiteren Inhalte verfügbar