11th place - JULIE ANDREWS (41,479 votes)

12th place - CHRISTOPHER PLUMMER (38,626 votes)

13th place - NELSON EDDY (31,454 votes)

14th place - DOUGLAS FAIRBANKS JR (20,470 votes)

15th place - VINCENT PRICE (11,485 votes)

16th place - TYRONE POWER (10,460 votes)

17th place - INGRID BERGMAN WITH HER JOAN OF ARC HAIR SLICKED BACK (9,570 votes)

18th place - BUSTER KEATON (9,036 votes)

19th place - DIRK BOGARDE (8,584 votes)

20th place - DAVID FARRAR (8,518 votes)

21st place - JOAN "MOUSTACHE" FONTAINE (7,262 votes)

22nd place - RICHARD WIDMARK (6,028 votes)

23rd place - MARCELLO MASTROIANNI (5058 votes)

24th place - ROGER LIVESEY (4483 votes)

25th place - CARY GRANT (4464 votes)

26th place - HENRY FONDA (4417 votes)

27th place - TALLULAH BANKHEAD (3786 votes)

28th place - ANTON WALBROOK (3467 votes)

29th place - JACK LEMMON (3090 votes)

30th place - CHARLES BOYER (3042 votes)

31st place - MARLENE DIETRICH (2934 votes)

32nd place - MONTGOMERY CLIFT (2930 votes)

33rd place - PETER FALK (2880 votes)

35th place - ORSON WELLES (2743 votes)

36th place - SKIPPY THE DOG (2645 votes)

37th place - PETER LORRE (2484 votes)

38th place - MELVYN DOUGLAS (2392 votes)

39th place - STAN LAUREL (2384 votes)

40th place - FARLEY GRANGER (2346 votes)

41st place - RONALD COLMAN (2253 votes)

42nd place - JAMES CAGNEY (2247 votes)

43rd place - JIMMY STEWART (2137 votes)

44th place - BARBARA STANWYCK (2125 votes)

45th place - DANNY KAYE (2104 votes)

46th place - ROCK HUDSON (1947 votes)

gonna go quickly grab a cup of coffee before the top 10 because it's nearly 3 AM where i live but oh my god these reactions 😭 PLEASE JUST HOLD ON LOVELIES WE'RE NEARLY THERE

okay i'm back 🚨 TOP 10 !!!!

10th place - JOSEPH COTTEN (51,560 votes)

9th place - GLENN FORD (54,579 votes)

8th place - OMAR SHARIF (79,285 votes)

7th place- JAMES MASON (80,241 votes)

6th place - GRETA GARBO (95,809 votes)

5th place - VIVIEN LEIGH IN DRAG (98,853 votes)

4th place - FRANCHOT TONE (104,396 votes)

we're down to the final three 😭 !!!!

🥉 GREGORY PECK (193,162 votes)

🥈 RUDOLPH VALENTINO (403,031 votes)

AND 2026'S OLD HOLLYWOOD DILF NUMBER ONE IS !!!

🥇 SIDNEY POITIER (564,866 votes)

here are the rest of the nominees and their voting tally in case anyone's interested to know

anyways, the past week has been really fun !! all of the alliances & campaigning plus everyone dedicating so much of their energy and time to this just kept reminding me what an incredibly beautiful community this is. thank you again 🫶🏽 see you in feb for the milf awards !!