正在加载视频...

视频加载失败

A brief intro to Clean Code Second Edition

264,515 次观看 • 10 个月前 •via X (Twitter)

46 条评论

Vogelbeobachter 的头像
Vogelbeobachter6 个月前

No one cares about your totalitarian shit. Get over it.

Vogelbeobachter 的头像
Vogelbeobachter6 个月前

Converting subjective heuristics into moral absolutes is the blueprint of a technical autocrat. Learn the difference between a guide and a law, Bob.

Anthony 的头像
Anthony10 个月前

My copy just came in the mail yesterday. Really enjoying it so far.

Prahlad Yeri 的头像
Prahlad Yeri10 个月前

Why do most programming authors and podcasters avoid PHP as if it's a deprecated disease that still runs half the internet 😀

Ralf Anders 的头像
Ralf Anders1 个月前

It’s a book every AI should read.

Uncle Bob Martin 的头像
Uncle Bob Martin1 个月前

If only they could retain what they read. Unfortunately, for now, that’s up to the humans. And perhaps it always will be.

Theron James 的头像
Theron James5 个月前

Excited to read! Next we need an agent skill for agentic clean code.

Uncle Bob Martin 的头像
Uncle Bob Martin5 个月前

I don’t think that’s an agent skill. I think it requires humans in the loop.

Theron James 的头像
Theron James5 个月前

I think the human’s role is critical. The question is where in the stack that human discipline lives. If code is the artifact, then yes, humans in the loop on code quality. But if the durable artifact is the spec and verification layer and code is a compilation target agents regenerate, then the human discipline is in spec precision, not code cleanliness. The agent skill is in structuring code for agent consumption between regenerations. Wrote this up here:

Alessandro Giannone 的头像
Alessandro Giannone10 个月前

Hold on, you did a full rewrite? The sequence of words that makes good software engineers shudder.

Uncle Bob Martin 的头像
Uncle Bob Martin10 个月前

<grin>. I’d say it’s an 85+% rewrite. But never fear, the first edition is still running and you can run the two in parallel for awhile while you gradually phase the first edition out.

Bunker 的头像
Bunker10 个月前

does this book contain any sort of proof / measure system to show that 'clean' code actually improves things or we all should believe You because your hairs are white?

Uncle Bob Martin 的头像
Uncle Bob Martin10 个月前

When you find, or write, a book that offers such a proof, please let us all know. In the mean time you might want to pay attention to those of us who have been coding for many decades. Or not. Your choice.

ZHONG XINA 的头像
ZHONG XINA10 个月前

@DarthBunker chatgpt makes coders over confident

Uncle Bob Martin 的头像
Uncle Bob Martin10 个月前

@DarthBunker Coders. Not programmers.

Andreas K. Weber 的头像
Andreas K. Weber6 个月前

Didn‘t know that you will ship a new version of clean code. It was one of my first books and it defined how I approached technology in general. I‘m glad to see you having so much fun and also produce so much valuable insights to bridge old world vs new world.

nisten 的头像
nisten10 个月前

Yo uncle Bob, if I wanna do type-checking at test-time in C, how do I go about that workflow bro?

𝕰𝖒𝖕𝖗𝖊𝖘𝖘 𝕶𝖆𝖗𝖊𝖓 ᴺᴱᴼ 的头像
𝕰𝖒𝖕𝖗𝖊𝖘𝖘 𝕶𝖆𝖗𝖊𝖓 ᴺᴱᴼ10 个月前

A message from Shangri-La: “You may not let Uncle Bob hack the racquetball!”

Uncle Bob Martin 的头像
Uncle Bob Martin10 个月前

I used to be a lot better at this.

Curtis Harrison 的头像
Curtis Harrison3 个月前

@koishiterukaren You're awesome!!! That juggling makes me happy. I'm curious if you've tried the recent xai Build CLI with GROK. I guess it just released in May and looks like an upgrade is coming any day now. I got a $30/first 3 months deal so I'm going to start playing around with it...

Uncle Bob Martin 的头像
Uncle Bob Martin3 个月前

@koishiterukaren I've tried it. Codex is still a bit better, but I expect that to change.

Stewart Anderson 的头像
Stewart Anderson10 个月前

Bob, I love you're advice. TDD & SOLID changed my whole career. But, to be honest - your lawn looks like $%^

memoz 的头像
memoz7 个月前

You updated the SRP meaning in the CA book and you were complaining about this, maybe you can write it more explicitly in the new edition 👍🏻

𝕸𝖊𝖗𝖑◬𝖓𝖎 的头像
𝕸𝖊𝖗𝖑◬𝖓𝖎4 个月前

Gm...I like the emphasis on mentioning that even not agreeing all the times , you had a nice debate 😂 Nowadays everyone considers a good debate has and attack or an offense witch is kind of meeehh and unproductive... signs of maturity is knowing you can have good conversation with someone you not always agree on!

Uncle Bob Martin 的头像
Uncle Bob Martin4 个月前

Civilization depends upon civil debate. Funny how that works out. Currently, our civilization is headed towards a disaster. The only way to prevent that is civil discourse.

𝕸𝖊𝖗𝖑◬𝖓𝖎 的头像
𝕸𝖊𝖗𝖑◬𝖓𝖎4 个月前

Im in my middle age crisis right now … but seems the norm now is not being inconvenient wich perpetuates the wrong doing from the ones that can exploit doubt. …Thats a great balcony view!…can’t wait to get to my mountain house has a full time job 😂

Rick Lourenco 的头像
Rick Lourenco7 个月前

Any plans to do a second edition of the Courses as well?

Nephew Tom 的头像
Nephew Tom9 个月前

I bought first version in 2011. How much of C does have the 2nd edition? Btw, have you read Hacker's Delight?

Aiden 的头像
Aiden6 个月前

been writing context docs for claude code with wireframes and intent sections alongside tests. agent output quality jumps massively when it knows what done looks like, not just what the steps are

Dean Peters☕ 的头像
Dean Peters☕7 个月前

It'd be nice if some of these coding tools wrote clean code. Well, maybe not. One way to stay employed is to put one's shingle out that they can tame even the most convoluted Claude Code incarnations and Codex crapola. Hmmm.

Gleiton Franco 的头像
Gleiton Franco9 个月前

The world if everybody used Clean Code ;-)

david barros 的头像
david barros4 个月前

Hello mr martin. I seem to recall in one of your videos a tale of a debugger called sword I searched to see what it was like without any success. can you help me with more info to find it?

sofia z, 的头像
sofia z,27 天前

Great point!

David Stevens 的头像
David Stevens1 个月前

maybe release this with an agent harness as well?

Adam Lenaro 的头像
Adam Lenaro15 天前

I would say this screen shot shows a perfect representation of the current industry. And why I no longer like to code for other people.

Harry Ashton 的头像
Harry Ashton4 个月前

The way that smile vanishes at the end haha

Nohokthen 的头像
Nohokthen3 个月前

I feel I’m gonna buy the book and feed it to my agents

Mark Witucke 的头像
Mark Witucke8 个月前

Hello Uncle Bob, Sorry if this is not the appropriate place to ask. I was curious about your opinion of Ceruzzi's History... May yr 2026 be interesting, vital and fun. Yours MW btw *Buy Clean Code*

Taha 的头像
Taha27 天前

Go mentioned!

victor 的头像
victor6 个月前

.agents/skills/cleancode2.md

Arcanist 的头像
Arcanist1 个月前

I've heard so much about the first edition from my seniors, you have a great reputation in the industry. Thank you for sharing your knowledge with us all these years. Excited to grab this one and dive in! 🙏

Monday Promise 的头像
Monday Promise3 个月前

I have been living with Parkinson’s disease for the past 8 years. During that time, I tried various treatments and therapies, but none brought lasting relief. Everything changed when my neurologist recommended that I undergo EarthCure Herbal Clinic ( )

paradox 的头像
paradox10 个月前

i swear i’m not lying. I watched a video with the black ops 1 menu music playing and it glitched out. It was playing through this whole video too. now that was awesome,

Big Rusty Balls 的头像
Big Rusty Balls10 个月前

The wait is over. Thanks, Uncle Bob.

Yura Zakaryan 的头像
Yura Zakaryan7 个月前

.

Sentient Ham Sandwich 的头像
Sentient Ham Sandwich19 天前

The book has its uses

相关视频