Пропустить навигацию
A visualization showing how gravity curves spacetime
0:00 / 1:03

A visualization showing how gravity curves spacetime

Massimo

@Rainmaker19734,4 млн подписчиков

Открыть в X
2 162 отметки «Нравится»СкачатьОригинальный пост

166 893 просмотра

A visualization showing how gravity curves spacetime [🎞️ Daniel Ibarra]

33 комментария

Комментарии из оригинального поста в X (Twitter)

  • Фото профиля TheRealVerbz (Jason Verbelli)

    @TheRealVerbz

    Complete nonsense. There is no space time to curve. The idea of space-time was invented by Einstein. It ruined the world for 120 years. Catastrophic failure. No space-time As Einstein himself wrote in a letter to Erwin Finley-Freundlich in August of 1913: "Wenn die Lichtgeschwindigkeit auch nur ein bißchen von der Geschwindigkeit der Lichtquelle abhängig ist, dann ist meine ganze Relativitätstheorie und Gravitationstheorie falsch." "If the velocity of light is even a little bit dependent upon the velocity of the light source, then my entire theory of Relativity and theory of Gravitation is false." It turns out the velocity of light is indeed dependent upon the velocity of the light source. Here is exactly why. Doppler Effect Misnomer 2: Doppler Effect Misnomer 3: Michaelson-Morley's Interferometer Experiments: The Fallacy of Fringe Shifts: How Light Actually Behaves (And More!) - Thread The 4th Law of Thermodynamics: Gravity is Not Electric.
Gravity is Not Space-Time Curvature:

    8 отметок «Нравится»

  • Фото профиля Don Manogadon

    @manogadon

    Nice 3D representation. GR has been proven beyond all doubt. It took me a few years but I have slowly got my head around it, even the math. One question still bakes my noodle. How the FUCK did Einstein know? I mean it is so counterintuitive. What was the giveaway?

    6 отметок «Нравится»

  • Фото профиля Yovo

    @YovoYovchev1

    Mass bends spacetime and gravity is the bended spacesetime itself. Think of it as a track and we fall when there is a bending and we float when it’s not bended. Literally earth’s crust prevents us from falling to the core of the planet. There is no attraction but free fall

    5 отметок «Нравится»

  • Фото профиля Paul Blanchard

    @dadblanchard42

    Gravity does NOT bend space-time. Gravity is the RESULT of the warping of space-time by mass.

    2 отметки «Нравится»

  • Фото профиля Bob Thibadeau

    @BobThibadeau

    very nice. Now, if you just add in relativity so we can move the rest frame and speed up parts of the system.

    1 отметка «Нравится»

  • Фото профиля Yours Truly

    @AmaniJeanc57865

    Whoa, this actually makes the whole “gravity bending spacetime” idea way easier to picture ,Mind officially blown.

    1 отметка «Нравится»

  • Фото профиля Barrak

    @BarrakAli

    Einstein told us gravity isn't a force but a curve in spacetime, and this visualization finally makes that click visually. The universe bends reality itself around mass. Mind blowing.

    1 отметка «Нравится»

  • Фото профиля dav

    @dav8119

    c'est point du tout comme ça :)

    1 отметка «Нравится»

  • Фото профиля Nichole Huntsman 🇺🇸

    @HuntsmanNichole

    Except that the grid is not the correct geometry. It's much more refined.

    1 отметка «Нравится»

  • Фото профиля hewaterGG

    @HeTaiyi3567

    This visualization is absolutely stunning! Daniel Ibarra nailed it. The rubber sheet analogy never sat right with me either - this 3D representation finally makes gravity curves intuitive. Science meets art 🤯

    1 отметка «Нравится»

  • Фото профиля Matthew Schlueb

    @SCHLUEBarch

    Still searching for an answer to how gravity exists in the first place - what physical properties cause mass to be drawn toward mass? Curvature of spacetime might model the interaction nicely, but it does not explain what energizes the attraction of gravity.

    1 отметка «Нравится»

  • Фото профиля as ewe wi§h/ÊWEtōP@

    @hooyahdeepsea69

    ,@grok gravyteez=gött

    1 отметка «Нравится»

  • Фото профиля VT

    @watimreading

    I wonder how einstein would have reacted to seeing his equations visualized like this. he described gravity as geometry but never had the tools to actually show it

    1 отметка «Нравится»

  • Фото профиля politically corect

    @chumblenet

    I always had an issue with the 'rubber sheet and two heavy balls' gravity demonstration since it had to use gravity to demonstrate it! This clears things up! Thanks.

    1 отметка «Нравится»

  • Фото профиля Marie Veverka

    @MarieVeverka

    Cool!

  • Фото профиля Tim Samuelson

    @timsamm

    And likely light particles as well. They could be surfing on the plane of space/time as they follow the path of least resistance.

  • Фото профиля S Palade

    @spalade

    looks nice, Just that earth also moves thru spacetime...

  • Фото профиля Ara

    @Arabasement

    Thanks 🤗so much for putting this up it help me work out a new way of looking at how black holes are formed! My new napkin theory is that black holes are anchor points ? Imagine space isn’t empty it’s like a giant membrane sheet, stretched tight, or fog like full of invisible threads. Drop a marble on it? It sags, threads pull back gravity. Small planet? Gentle dip, easy tug. But pile on a star, a galaxy’s worth? Threads stretch harder, start to groan. Hit a breaking point like 100 million suns and snap! The sheet tears, threads knot up into a black hole. As we see in big galaxies, the black hole is always at the centre of the galaxy. That knot ? It glues everything tight stars whip around way faster than they should, no dark matter needed. Dwarfs? Barely a dent. On space no tear, no knot, orbits stay loose. When two knots collide? Ripples—LIGO hears ’em. And for you physics guys , he is an equation for you. I was. Thinking up. Just rough. G = κ · (M / r²) · [1 + (M / M_crit)^3] M_crit ≈ 10⁸ solar masses where the ‘snap’ happens. Fits JWST’s black hole poor dwarfs, fast orbits around supermassive cores. Thoughts?

  • Фото профиля Jason Wilson

    @JWCbnFbrMotorId

    Awesome 👏 @grok check this out, you should learn this simulate and add it to your data set

  • Фото профиля Ilshad Khabibullin

    @astoon

    Maybe a better visualization would be where both objects move in space/time, and space/time is curving in a way that their trajectories are intersecting...