Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

Go Home

A visualization showing how gravity curves spacetime [🎞️ Daniel Ibarra]

414,486 views • 4 months ago •via X (Twitter)

31 Comments

s🎸W👀t's profile picture
s🎸W👀t4 months ago

Pretty good... Butt this is the best visualization of space/time/gravity I've seen.👇

samir's profile picture
samir4 months ago

cool! i was working on a similar simulation this weekend

v.f. labs inc's profile picture
v.f. labs inc4 months ago

space is an observation time is an observation so curving it makes no sense oh, and gravity is an observation what makes more logical sense? all matter are patterns within the same fabric of reality, and the rate of change is c.

CatDog99's profile picture
CatDog994 months ago

A good visual, but I still don't know what space-time actually is. Nobody really does. What's it made of? What exactly is bending or "curving"?

Peter Fischer ☧'s profile picture
Peter Fischer ☧4 months ago

Gravity curves spacetime? I think the current understanding is mass curves spacetime, and that curvature of spacetime creates a semblance of gravity. In other words, there is no “gravitational force” that pulls. Rather the spacetime curvature creates that appears to be a pull as smaller objects move down hill along the curvature. No?

アドルは御坂美琴の彼氏's profile picture
アドルは御坂美琴の彼氏4 months ago

重力が時空を歪めるって言う人いるけど、そもそも時空の歪みが重力の正体だから同じ事を2回言ってる 頭痛が痛いと同じ

John Galt's profile picture
John Galt4 months ago

What you talking about? The earth is obviously flat 🤔 Well, why the fuck not? Literally nothing else they’ve told us has been true.

Sagacity Sweet Science's profile picture
Sagacity Sweet Science4 months ago

Unfortunately, gravity cannot curve spacetime as gravity and “spacetime” are both 100% emergent. ;) Happy hunting!

John Smith's profile picture
John Smith4 months ago

It’s not a grid, it’s waves.

Infinite Space Mechanic.'s profile picture
Infinite Space Mechanic.4 months ago

You do know we are in space now... Show me the curve....of space, just like sunlight it comes from mass! We are on a planet flying through a void... Space and time... spacetime... is a place not a curve.... ONLY MASS CURVES! space doesn't do a thing... time is just one second per second. Where there's no mass, then there's no curvature. No matter where you go, space is right next too you! Go in the closet and turn off the lights.. fill the closet with gold.. it's still a closet... without a bend in sight! You can't get nothing from nothing... mass is rare and not in every place. Mass is first order before light!

Cuddlefish's profile picture
Cuddlefish4 months ago

I’m glad someone finally made a 3d model rather than using a flat surface but… this is still incorrect and wouldn’t make sense without using gravity to explain gravity. It’s really just the opposite with mass DISPLACING spacetime, not drawing it in. Gravity is warp effect.

Jaime Bernal's profile picture
Jaime Bernal4 months ago

Very cool! Now shouldn't we see the lines bend further out so as to show why the moon keeps orbiting earth?

Greg Stone's profile picture
Greg Stone4 months ago

Spacetime is a math model. What is gravity? What is curvature? Math calculations? Time is simply the change of configuration of space and matter. It does not exist as a dimension, only a notation of change. The spacetime idea has caused so much confusion.

ryan's profile picture
ryan4 months ago

i like it

Breezy's profile picture
Breezy4 months ago

?

Cajun Statham's profile picture
Cajun Statham4 months ago

How do you illustrate curves with squares

Kapattı gitti's profile picture
Kapattı gitti4 months ago

Time doesn't exist. The mathematics of the universe is change. Time is a human invention, a means of observing change.

Douglas Benndorf Rodrigues's profile picture
Douglas Benndorf Rodrigues4 months ago

This video only shows the spatial aspect of the curvature. The temporal aspect, which is what actually causes the gravitational attraction effect, is not shown. In any case, it's a good video and helps beginners understand it.

Sovereign Australia Party's profile picture
Sovereign Australia Party4 months ago

exactly how does space bend, or curve, or have any effect due to matter. Tesla was right to question it, so should you.

TheRealVerbz (Jason Verbelli)'s profile picture
TheRealVerbz (Jason Verbelli)4 months ago

This is an erroneous animation. Gravity is not some mythical curvature of space time. No space-time As Einstein himself wrote in a letter to Erwin Finley-Freundlich in August of 1913: "Wenn die Lichtgeschwindigkeit auch nur ein bißchen von der Geschwindigkeit der Lichtquelle abhängig ist, dann ist meine ganze Relativitätstheorie und Gravitationstheorie falsch." "If the velocity of light is even a little bit dependent upon the velocity of the light source, then my ENTIRE theory of Relativity and theory of Gravitation is false." It turns out, the velocity of light is indeed dependent upon the velocity of the light source. Book 2 of 4 - GRAVITY Gravity is Not Electric Gravity is Not Space-Time Curvature: Want Real Free Energy/UFOs? Gaia Episode on John Searl with Insider Jason Verbelli Cancelling Inertia... Up to a Point!

Defectus's profile picture
Defectus4 months ago

It's electromagnetism... not gravity. Gravity is a myth, a legend, an effect brought on by electromagnetic forces. A dance they've been doing for 100 years.

BTW...'s profile picture
BTW...4 months ago

Frank Wilczek.

Orphix🇪🇪's profile picture
Orphix🇪🇪4 months ago

I feel like we are missing a big piece of this puzzle. It all makes sense but at the same time we dont understand any of it.

Finanza da Bere's profile picture
Finanza da Bere4 months ago

Terra e Luna che si muovono nel "Bulk"?

SciTrendX's profile picture
SciTrendX4 months ago

There's something deeply humbling about this image. For thousands of years humans looked up at the planets moving across the sky and assumed invisible forces were pushing and pulling them. Einstein showed us the truth was stranger and more beautiful that massive objects don't reach out and grab each other. They simply reshape the space between them, and everything else follows. Gravity isn't a force. It's the shape of the universe responding to what's inside it.

GOD BLESS US ALL's profile picture
GOD BLESS US ALL4 months ago

S t u p i d i t y…

Witness's profile picture
Witness4 months ago

Why the curves are concave?

Ty's profile picture
Ty4 months ago

Theoretically a moon can have a moon 🌕

Gene TC's profile picture
Gene TC4 months ago

dumb simulation

G.M Kukes's profile picture
G.M Kukes4 months ago

Not right. Objects take the place of space, and technically push space out...Denser object, puuh/clean space better, resulting in more space pushed out, which in turn will push more space out. When you see light behind galaxies, no image will ever show light crating those lines

Thadeus III's profile picture
Thadeus III4 months ago

You should be able to replicate orbit in space ising a bowling ball and a piece of popcorn. But it doesn’t work does it?

Related Videos