Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

There was a problem loading this video. This could be due to a temporary network issue or the video might be unavailable.

"And then you let people work-" "But then that would, again, create an incentive for people to come across." PoliticsJOE's Ava Santina Evans and The Times' Sebastian Payne debate how the government should handle illegal immigration. #Newsnight

BBC Newsnight

703,383 subscribers

22,194 views • 16 days ago •via X (Twitter)

News & Politics Health & Wellness #Newsnight

Anya Rossi• Live Now

Private livecam show

21 Comments

ADalrymple16 days ago

This isn't rocket science. Stop incentivising it and send them home. Clearing the back log not the issue. Dear god, what is wrong with these people?

Weasel Words 🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇮🇪16 days ago

☝️These people are everything that is wrong with Britain - They need to go.

thecommoner16 days ago

An entire panel of redundant garble. Who in their right mind is advocating for illegal sub-Saharan Africans to be handed paid work, bar know-nothing chaos-merchants like @AvaSantina? What the fuck are you talking about? Incentivising illegal migration even more? Go fuck yourself.

Daniel16 days ago

Oh this is all so tedious. DEPORT THE LOT and TURN THE BOATS BACK. Turn them back night and day. Use the Royal Navy, the Coastguard and fishing vessels if need be.

J C Mullankuzhy16 days ago

Isn’t illegal immigration already coming down? So why debate past issues as the present? Isn’t it a deliberate policy of fostering racism? Why is no expert panellist condemning the intimidatory racism that has been unleashed as a consequence?

Desmond Ward16 days ago

Both fkn clowns, we don't want these illegal immigrants in our country, they don't make our communities better or safer, it's totally the opposite, you'll only see them from your uber or gated ivory towers #Newsnight

dreams of widnes16 days ago

@AvaSantina No fucking way is that slimy oaf 37 years old

Sockpuppetaccounts15 days ago

How the fuck is he 37?

Holden Mutevera16 days ago

@AvaSantina who wld purport to be against exploitation of working class yet is complicit in maintaining wage slavery thinks spewing the smarmy line abt how hard working ppl from abroad are is consolation for letting them be wage slaves here : leftists are duplicitous scum

Andrew Sinclair15 days ago

“If you let people work” to do what……? They are a burden.

Kathy Gray15 days ago

Your show and the people you have on it are utterly stupid "oh the numbers have come down, oh the tories were worse" wtf, there should be no one breaking into Britain pathetic pathetic pathetic The Trump administration must be laughing so hard at this government

jez15 days ago

Ffs 🤦

Walsinghams ghost15 days ago

Close the fucking border and put them on the ferry. If not, put them in a military transport aircraft and static line the bastards out the side door.

dreams of widnes16 days ago

@AvaSantina Look at @SebastianEPayne there acting like a weasel. Fucking hell how old is he? 64???

Dinghy Busters16 days ago

"And then you let people work" Illiterates in a country with 99% literacy..

Edwin G15 days ago

No incentives. Stop being such white saviour mugs, for the illegal trade.

MR B.E 🇬🇧15 days ago

No, you deport them. We don’t want them and they weren’t invited. Why on earth would we want illegal migrants working when there’s a lack of job vacancies

Kathy Gray15 days ago

Can you also explain why Harry is getting tax payer security when he is supposed to be a private citizen? Lets see if you have the nerve to ask this question. At least @insiderlauren brings us the truth when you msm are to scared to ask the real questions

Happyalways16 days ago

Britain is screwed because people think someone in a suit is smart. Just listen to these people and you’ll understand they are the reason the UK is £3 Trillion in debt, Manchester Arena happened & Ms Whyte is dead. It’s like watching Rhodesia turn into Zimbabwe in 4K 🤦🏻‍♂️😢

Mat P16 days ago

As if these savages have any interest in coming here to work.

Upures the cat16 days ago

In case Labour isn't aware, it's policies are slowing the economy down. Who wants to hire people when it's so expensive to do so?

Related Videos

J-Cal’s Simple Immigration Fix: Fine the Business Owners, Stop the Incentive to Come @jason: “The people causing this problem are the business owners.” “They are providing the incentive to come here.” “This is actually what Steven Miller should do, because this would go after the people who are causing the immigration problem.” “We can solve almost all of the immigration issues, with the exception of maybe criminal gangs, just by doing basic surveillance and asking these businesses to show the pay stubs of the people working for them, and ICE has been doing this.” “You pick the #1 employer of illegal aliens, 2.5 million people working construction.” “You start with the largest construction sites, and then you work backwards.” “Then you start with the largest restaurants and hotel chains and work backwards.” “According to this LA Times survey, 75% of immigrants come here for better job opportunities.” “People coming to America illegally are coming here for economic reasons. They're not coming here to commit crimes. They're not coming here to get benefits.” “That is way down the list. That is a small percentage.”

J-Cal’s Simple Immigration Fix: Fine the Business Owners, Stop the Incentive to Come @jason: “The people causing this problem are the business owners.” “They are providing the incentive to come here.” “This is actually what Steven Miller should do, because this would go after the people who are causing the immigration problem.” “We can solve almost all of the immigration issues, with the exception of maybe criminal gangs, just by doing basic surveillance and asking these businesses to show the pay stubs of the people working for them, and ICE has been doing this.” “You pick the #1 employer of illegal aliens, 2.5 million people working construction.” “You start with the largest construction sites, and then you work backwards.” “Then you start with the largest restaurants and hotel chains and work backwards.” “According to this LA Times survey, 75% of immigrants come here for better job opportunities.” “People coming to America illegally are coming here for economic reasons. They're not coming here to commit crimes. They're not coming here to get benefits.” “That is way down the list. That is a small percentage.”

The All-In Podcast

42,651 views • 7 months ago

Joe Rogan: "In the UK, you need a digital ID to combat—ready for it—illegal immigration." "You let the illegal immigrants in on purpose... and now you're using it as a justification for digital ID." "It's the best way to control people." "Bring in a bunch of people that the people that live there don't want there, and let them duke it out, and then start instituting tighter and tighter restrictions and control."

Joe Rogan: "In the UK, you need a digital ID to combat—ready for it—illegal immigration." "You let the illegal immigrants in on purpose... and now you're using it as a justification for digital ID." "It's the best way to control people." "Bring in a bunch of people that the people that live there don't want there, and let them duke it out, and then start instituting tighter and tighter restrictions and control."

Wide Awake Media

1,119,596 views • 1 year ago

🚨🇺🇸ELON: END BENEFITS FOR ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS, AND THEY WILL LEAVE "Basically, if you pay people, at a standard of living that is above 90% of Earth, then you have a very powerful incentive for 90% of Earth to come here and to stay here. But if you end the illegal alien fraud, that you turn off that magnet, then they leave. And then they stop coming, and the ones that are here, many of them will simply leave." Source: Joe Rogan Show, Camus

🚨🇺🇸ELON: END BENEFITS FOR ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS, AND THEY WILL LEAVE "Basically, if you pay people, at a standard of living that is above 90% of Earth, then you have a very powerful incentive for 90% of Earth to come here and to stay here. But if you end the illegal alien fraud, that you turn off that magnet, then they leave. And then they stop coming, and the ones that are here, many of them will simply leave." Source: Joe Rogan Show, Camus

Mario Nawfal

2,338,596 views • 1 year ago

Gov. Pritzker Compares Trump’s Illegal Immigration Crackdown to How the Holocaust Started “Before the Holocaust took place, people were accused of being immigrants … and then it was othering people. And that led to a lot worse things.”

Gov. Pritzker Compares Trump’s Illegal Immigration Crackdown to How the Holocaust Started “Before the Holocaust took place, people were accused of being immigrants … and then it was othering people. And that led to a lot worse things.”

Chief Nerd

954,731 views • 11 months ago

"The big one here is Brexit... it’s very difficult to get people to work in your venue." PoliticsJOE’s Ava Evans on the factors impacting music venues and nightclubs. #Newsnight

"The big one here is Brexit... it’s very difficult to get people to work in your venue." PoliticsJOE’s Ava Evans on the factors impacting music venues and nightclubs. #Newsnight

BBC Newsnight

382,744 views • 1 month ago

Gawain Towler(ex Reform Comms): I don't believe it's a Nazi salute Ava Santina Evans(JOE): We've been told for the last 5 years that we should be frightened of the pronouns people use, then someone actually does a Nazis salute from behind the presidential podium.. #PoliticsLive

Gawain Towler(ex Reform Comms): I don't believe it's a Nazi salute Ava Santina Evans(JOE): We've been told for the last 5 years that we should be frightened of the pronouns people use, then someone actually does a Nazis salute from behind the presidential podium.. #PoliticsLive

Haggis_UK 🇬🇧 🇪🇺

150,312 views • 1 year ago

VP JD Vance and Joe Rogan on Democrats using illegal immigration to shift electoral power in their favor and increase their congressional representation: ROGAN: "They just opened the border and not just encouraged people to come across, but facilitated it." "And then you realize that has a direct impact on congressional seats because of the census, which is also nuts." VANCE: "It should only count citizens, but it doesn't, and that actually steals congressional representation away from areas that have lower illegal immigration. Which is its own problem."

VP JD Vance and Joe Rogan on Democrats using illegal immigration to shift electoral power in their favor and increase their congressional representation: ROGAN: "They just opened the border and not just encouraged people to come across, but facilitated it." "And then you realize that has a direct impact on congressional seats because of the census, which is also nuts." VANCE: "It should only count citizens, but it doesn't, and that actually steals congressional representation away from areas that have lower illegal immigration. Which is its own problem."

Trump War Room

46,009 views • 2 months ago

“If Ukraine can come to the table then I think the pressure upon the Kremlin is now apparent” Sebastian Gorka, President Trump’s Senior Director for Counter Terrorism, tells Victoria Derbyshire that the Russian people will want to see Putin bring an end to the war #Newsnight

“If Ukraine can come to the table then I think the pressure upon the Kremlin is now apparent” Sebastian Gorka, President Trump’s Senior Director for Counter Terrorism, tells Victoria Derbyshire that the Russian people will want to see Putin bring an end to the war #Newsnight

BBC Newsnight

24,673 views • 1 year ago

White people are the ones who let illegal immigrants into SA, then they blame the government for having open borders when farmers are attacked. Home affairs and immigration officers searching for undocumented foreigners and immigrants, Tang Restaurant in Sandton, Ziyakhala Manje

White people are the ones who let illegal immigrants into SA, then they blame the government for having open borders when farmers are attacked. Home affairs and immigration officers searching for undocumented foreigners and immigrants, Tang Restaurant in Sandton, Ziyakhala Manje

Judaeda Blanco

188,987 views • 2 years ago

Elon Musk is himself an immigrant, so claims that he opposes immigration miss the point. His view is simple: welcome newcomers who work, contribute, respect the law, and treat their adopted country and its people with decency. "Let me explain the fundamental incentive behind insecure borders. When a welfare state provides substantial benefits to anyone who arrives, it creates a powerful economic incentive for people living below that standard to come to Europe. If people can achieve a higher standard of living in Europe than where they are elsewhere in the world, they will come. It is a basic and powerful incentive structure. I am in favor of immigration. It would be hypocritical for me not to be, since I am an immigrant to the United States. I support immigration when people are going to be productive members of society, are honest, and do not mistreat people in the country they enter."

Elon Musk is himself an immigrant, so claims that he opposes immigration miss the point. His view is simple: welcome newcomers who work, contribute, respect the law, and treat their adopted country and its people with decency. "Let me explain the fundamental incentive behind insecure borders. When a welfare state provides substantial benefits to anyone who arrives, it creates a powerful economic incentive for people living below that standard to come to Europe. If people can achieve a higher standard of living in Europe than where they are elsewhere in the world, they will come. It is a basic and powerful incentive structure. I am in favor of immigration. It would be hypocritical for me not to be, since I am an immigrant to the United States. I support immigration when people are going to be productive members of society, are honest, and do not mistreat people in the country they enter."

Doge Tipping

11,268 views • 2 months ago

“I wasn’t necessarily happy to live next door to an asylum seeker hotel, but I wasn’t going to demonise every Black and brown person in this country because I live next door to an asylum seeker hotel.” Ava Santina Evans, Political Editor of PoliticsJOE, tells #Newsnight that the debate over small boats is becoming “dangerous”, with “words like invasion”.

“I wasn’t necessarily happy to live next door to an asylum seeker hotel, but I wasn’t going to demonise every Black and brown person in this country because I live next door to an asylum seeker hotel.” Ava Santina Evans, Political Editor of PoliticsJOE, tells #Newsnight that the debate over small boats is becoming “dangerous”, with “words like invasion”.

BBC Newsnight

65,162 views • 16 days ago

In an article for The Spectator Rod Liddle suggests that 'Zionist' is becoming a socially acceptable way of saying 'Jew'. But Ava-Santina Evans argues that 'Zionist' has simply become shorthand for describing someone that supports the Israeli government, adding that activists on the left are failing to listen to Jewish voices within its movement while they claim the goalposts are being moved for how they can criticise Israel. Angus Colwell | Ava-Santina | Rachel Johnson

In an article for The Spectator Rod Liddle suggests that 'Zionist' is becoming a socially acceptable way of saying 'Jew'. But Ava-Santina Evans argues that 'Zionist' has simply become shorthand for describing someone that supports the Israeli government, adding that activists on the left are failing to listen to Jewish voices within its movement while they claim the goalposts are being moved for how they can criticise Israel. Angus Colwell | Ava-Santina | Rachel Johnson

The Spectator

17,665 views • 6 months ago

Rex84 (Readiness Exercise 1984) was a classified Continuity of Government program that would use illegal immigration as pretext for the president to declare an emergency, suspend the Constitution, and round people up including American citizens and detain them in FEMA camps.

Rex84 (Readiness Exercise 1984) was a classified Continuity of Government program that would use illegal immigration as pretext for the president to declare an emergency, suspend the Constitution, and round people up including American citizens and detain them in FEMA camps.

Truthstream Media

17,820 views • 1 year ago

“Incentive doesn’t disappear in a socialist or a communist society. It just changes and evolves…There is no real incentive in capitalism because the incentive is survival. When you get into communism, the incentive is for the common good.” It’s incredible to me that people who spend all day long complaining about how selfish and exploitative the “top 1%” is and then additionally how immoral and selfish 50% of the country who votes republican is and how so many are living in poverty and so few will help…then turn around and pretend that people are going to be intrinsically incentivized en masse to work for free for “the common good.” Never mind the issue of who actually gets to decide what constitutes “the common good” and how scary that can be (see: our response to COVID), they’re completely ignoring the fundamental sinfulness and selfishness of human nature. They take this Pollyannaish view of a world they claim to hate that includes people they claim to hate—and then pretend we’re going to magically create utopia here on earth, completely disregarding the reality of human nature.

“Incentive doesn’t disappear in a socialist or a communist society. It just changes and evolves…There is no real incentive in capitalism because the incentive is survival. When you get into communism, the incentive is for the common good.” It’s incredible to me that people who spend all day long complaining about how selfish and exploitative the “top 1%” is and then additionally how immoral and selfish 50% of the country who votes republican is and how so many are living in poverty and so few will help…then turn around and pretend that people are going to be intrinsically incentivized en masse to work for free for “the common good.” Never mind the issue of who actually gets to decide what constitutes “the common good” and how scary that can be (see: our response to COVID), they’re completely ignoring the fundamental sinfulness and selfishness of human nature. They take this Pollyannaish view of a world they claim to hate that includes people they claim to hate—and then pretend we’re going to magically create utopia here on earth, completely disregarding the reality of human nature.

Natalie Jean Beisner

347,656 views • 1 year ago