Skip navigation
Andy Burnham has pledged that Labour’s next manifesto will include a commitment to change the voting…
0:00 / 0:21

Andy Burnham has pledged that Labour’s next manifesto will include a commitment to change the voting…

James Melville 🚜

@JamesMelville598K followers

Visit on X
312 likesDownloadOriginal post

52,217 views

Andy Burnham has pledged that Labour’s next manifesto will include a commitment to change the voting system to proportional representation. I agree with this. First Past the Post is a ridiculous voting system. A system that discards votes and can put a government in power on less than 35% of the vote has no real legitimacy in a serious democracy.

33 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Baroness Foster DBE #FreeIran🦁❤️'s profile picture

    @jfoster2019

    Unbelievable… A ridiculous idea … he’s clearly got the @LibDems lined up for a ‘coalition’ Govt.. The worst thing we ever did @Conservatives was to go into coalition with the @LibDems for 5 years in 2010 …

    20 likes

  • John Olooney's profile picture

    @OlooneyJohn

    There is no democracy, these are all powerless puppets.

    14 likes

  • Christopher Lupine's profile picture

    @LupineLives

    All it does is force popular parties to concede ground to less popular parties to get into power Everywhere that does this is a mess

    11 likes

  • kennedy2324 🇬🇧's profile picture

    @kennedy2324

    It condemns us to left wing politics for the foreseeable future.

    8 likes

  • Robin Faustino-Stirling's profile picture

    @Glazertwalker

    PR just introduced another raft of absurdities. FPTP is the best of a whole bunch of worse options.

    6 likes

  • Denny Wright's profile picture

    @DennyTWright

    So you get a government where the majority of MPs get ignored a coalition emerges where not one manifesto pledge has to be honoured and the electorate can’t hold them to account!

    5 likes

  • Tim's profile picture

    @TimRegency

    Um, isn’t he in government already? Are we still fooled by ‘free beer tomorrow’?

    3 likes

  • MinistryofWit's profile picture

    @MinistryofWit

    Why not now? He's using it as a vote grab.

    3 likes

  • H147Dan's profile picture

    @Dan900H

    In Wales they gone full PR and it's ridiculous. It's a stitch up between @Plaid_Cymru + @WelshLabour to gerrymander seats. We now have multi member (huge) constituencies, so which which one of the 6 members represents me? PR is worse than FPTP.

    2 likes

  • Jack Smith's profile picture

    @JackAlbion22

    Meanwhile, 17.4 million people voted to leave the European Union, and apparently that democratic mandate can simply be ignored. This bozo would die of shock if anything he said ever collided with reality.

    2 likes

  • Robert's profile picture

    @RDC2713

    Yes, a man that got less than 0% of a vote lecturing about unfairness

    2 likes

  • Roger Elphick's profile picture

    @RogerElphi897

    2 sides. with FPTP at least you know where the blame lies. PR generally means a coalition. Weak government.

    1 like

  • Grumpy Cat's profile picture

    @GrumpyCatqlxz

    No it’ll mean we can’t get people out of power or make any meaningful changes ever,

    1 like

  • Neale Turner's profile picture

    @NealeTurner1

    Can’t wait for his manifesto, he won’t get in

    1 like

  • Peter 🇬🇧🇺🇸 🇮🇱Defund the BBC's profile picture

    @Peternoyes4

    Look at France & Germany proportional representation nothing gets agreed

    1 like

  • Yazzie Edwardo's profile picture

    @EdwardoYazzie

    Yes it’s the only point I agree with him on. But… he never mentioned .. Taxation. Defence . Immigration.

    1 like

  • Thomas Austin 🇪🇺#FBPD's profile picture

    @EUtopean

    Those who believe all that they hear will surely eat all they see.

    1 like

  • Stephen I’Anson's profile picture

    @stephenianson19

    And a system of PR, although it sounds fairer is going to require a botched together Government where deals are done behind closed doors and very little of any consequence gets done. At least in FPTP a rubbish Government can be kicked out after 5 years.

    1 like

  • Wayne❤⚽⛳🍺🐶😺's profile picture

    @winnie4672

    Election, please.

    1 like

  • IfyouIgnoreThis 🎗️'s profile picture

    @ifyouignorethis

    Great. Now we’ll never be able to get rid of unpopular governments or politicians. Troublesome MPs? They can be rid of quite easily as well.

    1 like