正在加载视频...

视频加载失败

加载此视频时出现问题。这可能是由于临时网络问题，或视频可能不可用。

As the Herby-Jonung-Hanke book "Did Lockdowns Work?" found: Lockdowns had a tiny effect on mortality, almost no health benefits, but imposed massive economic costs. Lockdowns were the worst policy blunder since World War II. My latest interview with James Connor:

Steve Hanke

852,177 subscribers

15,778 次观看 • 1 年前 •via X (Twitter)

新闻政治科学技术

Anya Rossi• Live Now

Private livecam show

5 条评论

James Connor 的头像

James Connor1 年前

Lockdowns were disastrous not only from an economic point a view but also from a psychological point of view but of course the powers that be never want to address this. In addition, lockdowns and free handouts created a generation of lazy people.

的头像

1 年前

@JamesConnor1999 never again….

Freedom Fighter 的头像

Freedom Fighter1 年前

@JamesConnor1999 Thanks, Prof! You are worth your weight in gold dross! 😂

Lost in a Lost World 的头像

Lost in a Lost World1 年前

@HNIJohnMiller @JamesConnor1999 I don't know about anybody else but I had just lost everything I own in Hurricane Irma 3 years prior to the lockdown. It took me 3 years to cobble my life back together and covid finished me off. So it was a financial Devastation for me personally. I kind of gave up.

Roger Horton 的头像

Roger Horton1 年前

@JamesConnor1999 Well said SH. I live in Victoria Australia which suffered the worst / longest shutdowns imposed anywhere by the labour Gov’t led by Dan Andrews. We are consequently severely indebted and suffer years of future draconian taxes levies etc due to their chronic mismanagement.

相关视频

Dr. Jay Bhattacharya reveals a STUNNING contrast from the COVID pandemic: Sweden never locked down and has had negative excess mortality since 2020. Meanwhile, he says the U.S. and Canada saw excess mortality rise and are still living with the devastating consequences of lockdowns. “Since 2020, Sweden has negative excess mortality.” “They reduced mortality rates during the pandemic.” “Whereas Canada and the United States, we have positive excess mortality relative to what we would’ve expected.” “The Swedish kids, they suffered no learning loss.” “My kids were out of school for two years in California.” “The harms from lockdowns we’re still seeing to this day.” “High levels of suicidality, rates of overdoses, and depression.” “A lot of the economic fights that we’ve been having in the last couple years are lingering effects.” “I think a lot of the harms could’ve been avoided had we followed the Swedish strategy.” David Leis🇨🇦Leaders on the Frontier, TV, Podcast

Dr. Jay Bhattacharya reveals a STUNNING contrast from the COVID pandemic: Sweden never locked down and has had negative excess mortality since 2020. Meanwhile, he says the U.S. and Canada saw excess mortality rise and are still living with the devastating consequences of lockdowns. “Since 2020, Sweden has negative excess mortality.” “They reduced mortality rates during the pandemic.” “Whereas Canada and the United States, we have positive excess mortality relative to what we would’ve expected.” “The Swedish kids, they suffered no learning loss.” “My kids were out of school for two years in California.” “The harms from lockdowns we’re still seeing to this day.” “High levels of suicidality, rates of overdoses, and depression.” “A lot of the economic fights that we’ve been having in the last couple years are lingering effects.” “I think a lot of the harms could’ve been avoided had we followed the Swedish strategy.” David Leis🇨🇦Leaders on the Frontier, TV, Podcast

MAHA Action

119,690 次观看 • 9 天前

Andrew Bridgen (Andrew Bridgen) was one of the only members of the UK Parliament who spoke out during COVID. I wanted to know what he was actually up against when he did. During the lockdowns, he was watching more people commit suicide in a month than he would normally see in a year. He went to his government. He said you're killing my people. They told him there was no link between suicides and lockdowns. A million people under 25 in the UK came out of those lockdowns on waiting lists for mental health support. But there's no link... He told me himself - they were just lying. At the same time, his government was being pressured to authorize experimental vaccines for children as young as six months old. No healthy child that age had died anywhere in the world. They were at no risk. And Andrew stood up in the House of Commons and said what I've believed for a long time: any society willing to sacrifice its children to protect adults has lost its way. Just like he said, I expect to make sacrifices for my children. I don't expect them to make sacrifices for me.

Andrew Bridgen (Andrew Bridgen) was one of the only members of the UK Parliament who spoke out during COVID. I wanted to know what he was actually up against when he did. During the lockdowns, he was watching more people commit suicide in a month than he would normally see in a year. He went to his government. He said you're killing my people. They told him there was no link between suicides and lockdowns. A million people under 25 in the UK came out of those lockdowns on waiting lists for mental health support. But there's no link... He told me himself - they were just lying. At the same time, his government was being pressured to authorize experimental vaccines for children as young as six months old. No healthy child that age had died anywhere in the world. They were at no risk. And Andrew stood up in the House of Commons and said what I've believed for a long time: any society willing to sacrifice its children to protect adults has lost its way. Just like he said, I expect to make sacrifices for my children. I don't expect them to make sacrifices for me.

Del Bigtree

26,949 次观看 • 1 个月前

WATCH: The contentious Dana Bash-RFKJR interview was doomed from the start. Watch as Dana Bash opens the interview by dishonestly framing Anthony Fauci as a Trump appointee: DANA BASH: Washington was also gripped this week by a blast from the past, as former top trump health official doctor Anthony Fauci repeatedly pleaded the fifth at a congressional hearing over his handling of the covid pandemic, all while the U.S. Faces health challenges from disease outbreaks to rising health care costs. Here with me now is the Health and Human Services Secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Thank you for being here. ROBERT F. KENNEDY. Jr.: Thanks for having me. BASH: Appreciate it. You have been placing nearly all the blame on the COVID pandemic and the way that the U.S. responded to it squarely with Dr. Fauci. But, of course, he worked for President Trump. Does President Trump also deserve some of the blame? KENNEDY: Well President Trump, as you recall, wanted to end the lockdowns. I think the thing that did the most damage to our country was the lockdowns, lockdowns that shut down 3.5 million businesses in our country with no due process, no just compensation, all of our churches, closed our schools, and our children are still paying the price for that. And yet we had the worst outcome of any country in the world. BASH: How so? KENNEDY: We have the highest death rate from COVID of any nation on Earth. BASH: Well, let me just say, because I have heard you say that before on the death rate from COVID. That's not accurate, because public health experts say that there is a combination of factors that went into that, higher rates of chronic illnesses, which I know you would agree with, gaps to our health care system, and misinformation about vaccines. KENNEDY: Yes, you just said what I said was inaccurate. What I said was accurate. We had the highest death rate from COVID of any... (CROSSTALK) BASH: Well, there are other countries that had higher, but go ahead. KENNEDY: You can argue about why we had that. But you -- nobody can tell you. I mean, we have -- as you say, we have the highest chronic disease burden in the world. And Anthony Fauci was mismanaging the COVID pandemic and was doing it under the Biden administration. President Trump wanted to end the lockdowns. And, in fact, in Anthony Fauci's diaries, he talks about how President Trump is calling him every day, trying to get him to reopen the country.

WATCH: The contentious Dana Bash-RFKJR interview was doomed from the start. Watch as Dana Bash opens the interview by dishonestly framing Anthony Fauci as a Trump appointee: DANA BASH: Washington was also gripped this week by a blast from the past, as former top trump health official doctor Anthony Fauci repeatedly pleaded the fifth at a congressional hearing over his handling of the covid pandemic, all while the U.S. Faces health challenges from disease outbreaks to rising health care costs. Here with me now is the Health and Human Services Secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Thank you for being here. ROBERT F. KENNEDY. Jr.: Thanks for having me. BASH: Appreciate it. You have been placing nearly all the blame on the COVID pandemic and the way that the U.S. responded to it squarely with Dr. Fauci. But, of course, he worked for President Trump. Does President Trump also deserve some of the blame? KENNEDY: Well President Trump, as you recall, wanted to end the lockdowns. I think the thing that did the most damage to our country was the lockdowns, lockdowns that shut down 3.5 million businesses in our country with no due process, no just compensation, all of our churches, closed our schools, and our children are still paying the price for that. And yet we had the worst outcome of any country in the world. BASH: How so? KENNEDY: We have the highest death rate from COVID of any nation on Earth. BASH: Well, let me just say, because I have heard you say that before on the death rate from COVID. That's not accurate, because public health experts say that there is a combination of factors that went into that, higher rates of chronic illnesses, which I know you would agree with, gaps to our health care system, and misinformation about vaccines. KENNEDY: Yes, you just said what I said was inaccurate. What I said was accurate. We had the highest death rate from COVID of any... (CROSSTALK) BASH: Well, there are other countries that had higher, but go ahead. KENNEDY: You can argue about why we had that. But you -- nobody can tell you. I mean, we have -- as you say, we have the highest chronic disease burden in the world. And Anthony Fauci was mismanaging the COVID pandemic and was doing it under the Biden administration. President Trump wanted to end the lockdowns. And, in fact, in Anthony Fauci's diaries, he talks about how President Trump is calling him every day, trying to get him to reopen the country.

Jorge Bonilla

63,407 次观看 • 1 个月前

$🚨 GLOBAL RESET BEGINS: ARGENTINA WALKS AWAY FROM THE WHO Javier Milei has just made a decisive move. Argentina is WITHDRAWING from the World Health Organization — following the path set by Donald Trump. This isn’t symbolic. It’s a direct rejection of supranational control over national health policy. For years, critics have warned that institutions like the WHO were shifting from advisory bodies into policy-driving authorities, influencing lockdowns, mandates, and cross-border health frameworks with little democratic accountability. Milei has now drawn a line: National sovereignty over global compliance. And the implications are significant. If more countries follow, the entire model of centralized global health governance begins to fracture. The real question is no longer if this trend grows — but who follows next. Because in a world of rising crises, nations are being forced to choose: Independent decision-making… or external control.$

🚨 GLOBAL RESET BEGINS: ARGENTINA WALKS AWAY FROM THE WHO Javier Milei has just made a decisive move. Argentina is WITHDRAWING from the World Health Organization — following the path set by Donald Trump. This isn’t symbolic. It’s a direct rejection of supranational control over national health policy. For years, critics have warned that institutions like the WHO were shifting from advisory bodies into policy-driving authorities, influencing lockdowns, mandates, and cross-border health frameworks with little democratic accountability. Milei has now drawn a line: National sovereignty over global compliance. And the implications are significant. If more countries follow, the entire model of centralized global health governance begins to fracture. The real question is no longer if this trend grows — but who follows next. Because in a world of rising crises, nations are being forced to choose: Independent decision-making… or external control.

Jim Ferguson

37,933 次观看 • 5 个月前

The WHO sent a delegation to China to document how lockdowns were being used to stop the spread of COVID. Jeffrey Tucker says it quickly turned into a propaganda tour, with the delegation being wined and dined before producing a report praising China’s lockdown model. He says that report became the turning point that helped set Western lockdowns in motion. And according to Anthony Fauci’s own diaries, Fauci was behind the push to send the delegation. “They wined and dined them for quite a long time, up to about a week.” “Xi Jinping’s message of this tour was, ‘We are much better at managing infectious disease than you. With our system of government, which is a one-party state and totalitarian dictatorial rule, we have vast advantages over you people in the West with your human rights and freedom and democracy.’” “Now, this is 100% propaganda.” “Their lockdowns achieved nothing in terms of stopping the spread.” “The CCP invited all these useful idiots from abroad to come in and observe the magnificence.” “They put out a report on February 24th… celebrating the glories of the CCP and the China model for controlling infectious disease.” “This report is extremely crucial in causing the rest of the world to copy what they believed that the CCP did.” “That’s what kicked in motion the lockdowns in the US, and the UK, and all over Europe.” “In Fauci’s first meeting with Donald Trump in the Oval Office… Fauci had one request for him.” “When you talk to Xi Jinping, make sure that he’s okay with a delegation from the World Health Organization coming to Wuhan to observe his genius at managing infectious disease.” “Well, they didn’t look at the data. What they did was go on a propaganda tour.” Jeffrey A Tucker Brownstone Institute

The WHO sent a delegation to China to document how lockdowns were being used to stop the spread of COVID. Jeffrey Tucker says it quickly turned into a propaganda tour, with the delegation being wined and dined before producing a report praising China’s lockdown model. He says that report became the turning point that helped set Western lockdowns in motion. And according to Anthony Fauci’s own diaries, Fauci was behind the push to send the delegation. “They wined and dined them for quite a long time, up to about a week.” “Xi Jinping’s message of this tour was, ‘We are much better at managing infectious disease than you. With our system of government, which is a one-party state and totalitarian dictatorial rule, we have vast advantages over you people in the West with your human rights and freedom and democracy.’” “Now, this is 100% propaganda.” “Their lockdowns achieved nothing in terms of stopping the spread.” “The CCP invited all these useful idiots from abroad to come in and observe the magnificence.” “They put out a report on February 24th… celebrating the glories of the CCP and the China model for controlling infectious disease.” “This report is extremely crucial in causing the rest of the world to copy what they believed that the CCP did.” “That’s what kicked in motion the lockdowns in the US, and the UK, and all over Europe.” “In Fauci’s first meeting with Donald Trump in the Oval Office… Fauci had one request for him.” “When you talk to Xi Jinping, make sure that he’s okay with a delegation from the World Health Organization coming to Wuhan to observe his genius at managing infectious disease.” “Well, they didn’t look at the data. What they did was go on a propaganda tour.” Jeffrey A Tucker Brownstone Institute

Jan Jekielek

47,625 次观看 • 22 天前

MUST-WATCH: Prof. Stefan Homburg explains, with surgical precision, why there was no pandemic starting in 2020. "There were no more severe respiratory ilnesses than usual in 2020 and 2021. Corona came, influenza disappeared." "Age-standardised mortality was not higher in 2020 than usual. Mortality only increased since 2021 [just after the "vaccine" roll-out started]." "The idea of a 'pandemic' arose exclusively from new types of mass testing... [which] led the public to believe that there were more sick people and deaths than usual, which was not true." "One must also ask whether the measures [masks, lockdowns etc] were really intended to prevent infection, which they clearly did not, or rather served the purpose of breaking down vaccine hesitancy." Credit: Stefan Homburg

MUST-WATCH: Prof. Stefan Homburg explains, with surgical precision, why there was no pandemic starting in 2020. "There were no more severe respiratory ilnesses than usual in 2020 and 2021. Corona came, influenza disappeared." "Age-standardised mortality was not higher in 2020 than usual. Mortality only increased since 2021 [just after the "vaccine" roll-out started]." "The idea of a 'pandemic' arose exclusively from new types of mass testing... [which] led the public to believe that there were more sick people and deaths than usual, which was not true." "One must also ask whether the measures [masks, lockdowns etc] were really intended to prevent infection, which they clearly did not, or rather served the purpose of breaking down vaccine hesitancy." Credit: Stefan Homburg

Wide Awake Media

780,472 次观看 • 2 年前

Exclusive. Alert!! :Former Senior WHO advisor: "Covid was a PCR manufactured fake non pandemic" A Top former senior advisor to the World Health Organisation (WHO) states Lockdowns didn't work, masks didn't work and that the pandemic was manufactured and fake.. In a stunning revelation, Dr. Paul Alexander has torn away the veil, exposing what is now viewed as a colossal deception—a deception that members of our governments not only tolerated but were actively complicit in. This bombshell disclosure sends shockwaves through the corridors of power, challenging the very foundations of trust and accountability. If the pandemic was as real and severe as they said this would have caused massive mortality at the height of the pandemic. In fact every country that had high vaccination rates now have massive amounts of Excess Deaths and the governments are attempting a huge coverup by massaging the data and refusing to discuss it. Vaccinated people are shedding spike proteins which is making the unvaccinated unwell. If in close contact taking Nattokinase with spike support can reduce the effects of spike protein in the body and prevent the effects. #nattokinase #SpikeShedding use CODE:JIM10

Exclusive. Alert!! :Former Senior WHO advisor: "Covid was a PCR manufactured fake non pandemic" A Top former senior advisor to the World Health Organisation (WHO) states Lockdowns didn't work, masks didn't work and that the pandemic was manufactured and fake.. In a stunning revelation, Dr. Paul Alexander has torn away the veil, exposing what is now viewed as a colossal deception—a deception that members of our governments not only tolerated but were actively complicit in. This bombshell disclosure sends shockwaves through the corridors of power, challenging the very foundations of trust and accountability. If the pandemic was as real and severe as they said this would have caused massive mortality at the height of the pandemic. In fact every country that had high vaccination rates now have massive amounts of Excess Deaths and the governments are attempting a huge coverup by massaging the data and refusing to discuss it. Vaccinated people are shedding spike proteins which is making the unvaccinated unwell. If in close contact taking Nattokinase with spike support can reduce the effects of spike protein in the body and prevent the effects. #nattokinase #SpikeShedding use CODE:JIM10

Jim Ferguson

340,338 次观看 • 2 年前

One line from Thomas Sowell completely rewired how Konstantin Kisin sees the world: “There are no solutions, only trade-offs.” Kisin says we’ve lost the ability to think like this. We treat every big issue — climate change, the NHS, COVID lockdowns, free speech — as if it has a perfect fix. But every policy, every choice, comes with real costs. Locking down might save some lives but costs others. More free speech means some people will get offended. Trying to “solve” complex problems usually just moves the pain around. The brutal truth? Most of our loud political shouting matches are childish because they pretend one side can magically eliminate problems that are eternal. Once you internalize “no solutions, only trade-offs,” a lot of the noise starts sounding ridiculous. What’s a trade-off you’ve had to accept recently — in politics, health, career, or relationships — that made you realise there really are no pure wins?

One line from Thomas Sowell completely rewired how Konstantin Kisin sees the world: “There are no solutions, only trade-offs.” Kisin says we’ve lost the ability to think like this. We treat every big issue — climate change, the NHS, COVID lockdowns, free speech — as if it has a perfect fix. But every policy, every choice, comes with real costs. Locking down might save some lives but costs others. More free speech means some people will get offended. Trying to “solve” complex problems usually just moves the pain around. The brutal truth? Most of our loud political shouting matches are childish because they pretend one side can magically eliminate problems that are eternal. Once you internalize “no solutions, only trade-offs,” a lot of the noise starts sounding ridiculous. What’s a trade-off you’ve had to accept recently — in politics, health, career, or relationships — that made you realise there really are no pure wins?

Camus

196,400 次观看 • 5 个月前

Here’s my energetic take on ‘Animal Farm,’ and how it differs greatly from the book since it is not neutral and adds a second communist revolution, and blatantly say communism is the answer as the final resolution. The book it is based on was neither pro nor against capitalism, but the movie displays capitalism solely as greed, with no benefits to the providers of goods or services. How much money did Andy Serkis, a member of the a Socialists Workers party and the producer of this film spend on influencer campaigns!?!?!?

Here’s my energetic take on ‘Animal Farm,’ and how it differs greatly from the book since it is not neutral and adds a second communist revolution, and blatantly say communism is the answer as the final resolution. The book it is based on was neither pro nor against capitalism, but the movie displays capitalism solely as greed, with no benefits to the providers of goods or services. How much money did Andy Serkis, a member of the a Socialists Workers party and the producer of this film spend on influencer campaigns!?!?!?

Angela Rose

30,891 次观看 • 4 个月前

Do people know that in early 2020 Tucker Carlson personally went to Mar-a-Lago to warn Trump about COVID and push for urgent action? Soon after, COVID was framed as a national emergency, power flowed to public-health bureaucracies, and the country entered the era of lockdowns, school closures, and sweeping executive authority. Tucker now denounces all of it, but conveniently skips the part where his intervention, potentially helped light the fuse. Tucker has also said he visited Trump last year during the 12-day war with Iran, this time urging him not to intervene and warning it could trigger World War III. Trump didn’t appear to take his advice on that one.

Do people know that in early 2020 Tucker Carlson personally went to Mar-a-Lago to warn Trump about COVID and push for urgent action? Soon after, COVID was framed as a national emergency, power flowed to public-health bureaucracies, and the country entered the era of lockdowns, school closures, and sweeping executive authority. Tucker now denounces all of it, but conveniently skips the part where his intervention, potentially helped light the fuse. Tucker has also said he visited Trump last year during the 12-day war with Iran, this time urging him not to intervene and warning it could trigger World War III. Trump didn’t appear to take his advice on that one.

Nathan Livingstone (MilkBarTV)

40,128 次观看 • 7 个月前

FULL INTERVIEW HERE ON X: "After tabulating, calculating, and quantifying all of the various dimensions of the costs of the [pandemic] lockdown policies, we found that lockdowns are about 30 to 35 times more costly than what they could possibly have delivered in benefits… in terms of human life." This was Gigi Foster's (of Australians for Science and Freedom) stunning revelation to me in June of 2022, based on the results of her own research. I had been well aware that lockdown policies had signficant collateral damage associated with them. Indeed, this was the reason why common-sense public health policy for years had been to avoid them at all costs—until, that is, this was all thrown out the window in early 2020. But I hadn't been ready to accept a 35X differential. The bottom line, according to Gigi, who as a professor at the University of New South Wales is a behavioural economics expert and as such does these sorts of calculations routinely, was always: "How many people would you be willing to kill in order to save one from COVID? That is essentially the trade-off." From skipped cancer screenings to impeded speech development in toddlers to growing social inequality, when we add it all up, what price did we pay? Join me and Gigi to learn the truth in American Thought Leaders 🇺🇸 with @JanJekielek Episode #637, Gigi Foster: Did Our Pandemic Policies Kill More People Than They Saved?, and check out my channel on Box 📦 Club Leader 2.0—I'll post links in the thread below👇

FULL INTERVIEW HERE ON X: "After tabulating, calculating, and quantifying all of the various dimensions of the costs of the [pandemic] lockdown policies, we found that lockdowns are about 30 to 35 times more costly than what they could possibly have delivered in benefits… in terms of human life." This was Gigi Foster's (of Australians for Science and Freedom) stunning revelation to me in June of 2022, based on the results of her own research. I had been well aware that lockdown policies had signficant collateral damage associated with them. Indeed, this was the reason why common-sense public health policy for years had been to avoid them at all costs—until, that is, this was all thrown out the window in early 2020. But I hadn't been ready to accept a 35X differential. The bottom line, according to Gigi, who as a professor at the University of New South Wales is a behavioural economics expert and as such does these sorts of calculations routinely, was always: "How many people would you be willing to kill in order to save one from COVID? That is essentially the trade-off." From skipped cancer screenings to impeded speech development in toddlers to growing social inequality, when we add it all up, what price did we pay? Join me and Gigi to learn the truth in American Thought Leaders 🇺🇸 with @JanJekielek Episode #637, Gigi Foster: Did Our Pandemic Policies Kill More People Than They Saved?, and check out my channel on Box 📦 Club Leader 2.0—I'll post links in the thread below👇

Jan Jekielek

124,953 次观看 • 2 年前

Victor Davis Hanson dropped some serious truth bombs about President Trump's foreign policy approach! He explained that Trump isn't some isolationist refusing to engage or a nation-builder wasting blood and treasure - he's a straight-up Jacksonian who picks his fights wisely with massive benefits outweighing any costs. The man nailed it perfectly - no one better as a friend and no one worse as an enemy when you cross the line, and that's exactly how Trump rolls on the world stage!

Victor Davis Hanson dropped some serious truth bombs about President Trump's foreign policy approach! He explained that Trump isn't some isolationist refusing to engage or a nation-builder wasting blood and treasure - he's a straight-up Jacksonian who picks his fights wisely with massive benefits outweighing any costs. The man nailed it perfectly - no one better as a friend and no one worse as an enemy when you cross the line, and that's exactly how Trump rolls on the world stage!

Bill Mitchell

26,366 次观看 • 6 个月前

Here’s me early in the scamdemic, denouncing lockdowns, already aware the only people at risk were the elderly & those with comorbidities while most people were panicking, obeying & shaming others. Elon Musk also stood up early against the insanity. Where are YOUR receipts? This is a supercut featuring comments from a video I posted to YouTube on 30th April 2020. People went BERSERK, as expected. Fear-induced brain damage is no joke. Maybe you fell victim to it yourself. As for the cowards who had a platform yet said nothing despite knowing what was happening was wrong—here's a mirror🪞. Take a looooooong look.

Here’s me early in the scamdemic, denouncing lockdowns, already aware the only people at risk were the elderly & those with comorbidities while most people were panicking, obeying & shaming others. Elon Musk also stood up early against the insanity. Where are YOUR receipts? This is a supercut featuring comments from a video I posted to YouTube on 30th April 2020. People went BERSERK, as expected. Fear-induced brain damage is no joke. Maybe you fell victim to it yourself. As for the cowards who had a platform yet said nothing despite knowing what was happening was wrong—here's a mirror🪞. Take a looooooong look.

stevenmarkryan

325,579 次观看 • 3 年前