Barstool Pizza Review - Pizza Pie Cafe (Orem, UT)

The fact you gave this a 5.9 tells me you’ve softened up on a once-tough scoring system.

Those first few seconds was the perfect summary of Utah County 😂. Love it!

He actually went there 😭 why did your team let you go there

Lol 5.9? Way too high. Why did you go there 🤣

How Dave felt about those kids

The Mormon Family of 8 holding Dave up is epic Utah Aura! 🤣💀🤣

thought bro popped out 5 kiddos after one day in Utah.

Wow I thought it would get a score in the 3s

The mountain view should have pushed it to a 6.9

5.9 is higher then I thought it would be. I was think 4.3 if he was being honestly. It wanted to be nice since its for kids.

Dave got the true Utah Mormon family experience on this one lol

I am SHOCKED it got above a 5 😂😂😂😂 Also shocked you went! Tons of people were joking about telling you to go, because it’s the most mid pizza in Utah, but I’m glad you gave it a fair shake! Pizza, pasta, salad buffet, lots of fun with the kids.

You always say one bite and then proceed to take ten….

BRO when are you going to eat my fucking pizza?

Nico’s Pizzeria 712 Lucy’s Slab Big daddy’s Can’t believe portnoy went to PPC. I haven’t been to one of those since HS when we would have pizza eating contests. Should’ve gone to one in SLC.

Surprising! I would’ve thought high 4’s

Do you feel bad with a low score after the meeting the Nice owners? 😂😂. Seemed like a nice guy.

Their dessert pizzas might be better than their actual pizza honestly

That is the worst pizza you could ever have in Utah.

Why did you go there?? 7-11 has better pizza man.

Woof, sorry you had to experience that.

I don’t know if I can trust you now… I have that pizza I’d give it at most a 3/10

That’s the first time I’ve seen Dave eat an entire slice!

Dave be like

In Utah Buffets are huge and everyone has 10 kids! I have 3 and somebody that’s all my first time there lol

5.9 was generous.

Hahaha

The most impressive part - biting into a red sauce while dressed all in white. Didn't spill a drop of tomato sauce. 10-10.

Come back to Utahhhhh

OH NO

Now I know something is fishy. How on Earth does this place get a 5.9 when pie hole gets a 3.8 or whatever.

Them walking out with a million kids was the perfect start to a Utah video🤣🤣🤣

I was very surprised to see you go here knowing it is buffet style and would more than likely be in the 5s. Awesome for poor college kids but not a great pizza spot.

Dave, there is no way you gave them a 5.9!