Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

Go Home

Chris Manning says Yann LeCun sees language as a low bandwidth communication channel compared to vision. But the gap between a chimp and a human wasn’t produced by superior eyes. What took off for humans was language. Not just for communication, but as a cognitive tool.

118,405 views • 4 months ago •via X (Twitter)

0 Comments

No comments available

Comments from the original post will appear here

Related Videos

Elon Musk just put an expiration date on human language. Not because talking is slow. Because it’s lossy. Musk: “Our brain spends a lot of effort compressing a complex concept into words.” Language isn’t communication. It’s failed compression. You have a complete thought. You crush it into words. The other person catches fragments and rebuilds a guess. The rest never arrives. Every person who has ever loved you loved a compressed version of you. Not for lack of trying. The channel wouldn’t carry the rest. We don’t communicate. We approximate and hope the gap doesn’t matter. Musk: “You would be able to communicate very quickly and with far more precision.” Neuralink doesn’t improve communication. It replaces it. No compression. No loss. Thought moving at the speed it happens. Not describing the painting. Transmitting the seeing of it. Musk: “You wouldn’t need to talk.” Five to ten years until speech becomes optional. Talking survives for tone, for intimacy, for the pleasure of it. For information, it’s obsolete. A lifetime of memory in a second. Full schematics, not summaries. The entire structure of a thought, intact. Not better communication. Telepathy with an engineering spec. Musk: “Ideally, we are a symbiosis with artificial intelligence.” Symbiosis means the humans who don’t merge at high bandwidth don’t just fall behind. They stop being legible to the intelligence that matters. We’re already cyborgs running terrible hardware. Your phone extends your mind. Your thumbs are the bandwidth. Terabytes of thought throttled down to a few words a second. Neuralink doesn’t optimize that constraint. It detonates it. Five to ten years. Not science fiction. A deployment window. From language as default to neural link as standard. From crushing thoughts into words to sending them whole. From humans using AI to humans running at its speed. Every mind that has ever existed ran alone. That was never the human condition. It was a bandwidth limit. Solitude was never philosophy. It was hardware. Every thought you’ve ever had arrived somewhere smaller than it started. That’s not a flaw in you. It’s the width of the channel every human has ever been issued. The channel is the thing that changes. Not soon. But not in some other lifetime either, in this one, on a clock Musk just put a number on.

Dustin

137,425 views • 28 days ago