Claude Fable 5 vs Codex 5.6 Sol, round 2. identical prompt again: "create a Ferrari 2027 vision email flow, 12 emails, using nitrosend." one shot, no edits. one of these is clearly better imo

round 1 was Nike. the replies couldn't agree on Fable vs Sol. same email tool underneath

here's the full brief Fable and Sol got. same words, same order, no favourites. bookmark it. the eerie bit: blind to each other, both models picked the same hero image for email 1. and again for email 12. (concept demo, not affiliated with Ferrari)

my co-founder Ed looked at these and said "the gearbox in one hero image is backwards, and one headline uses the word "rust". "never ever use the word rust in supercar copy." but we said one shot. round 3 tomorrow: Opus 5 vs Fable 5 ☄️

Real test is consistency across multiple prompts, not just one showcase.

Yeah true. Both did pretty well at that I think

Fable 5 this time

fable's got the eye for brand work

I need to see the original post first.fable 5 got restored earlier this month after export controls so timing is wild

original's linked in the post. no export controls involved here, just two models and the same prompt

Claude on the left understood the assignment completely. That F80 layout has proper supercar energy.

the f80 layout is the bit that sold it for me too

Same properties different model that cool

identical prompt, identical order. only fair way to run it

Prompt stayed same, quality definitely changed.

same words in, very different work out. that's the interesting bit

same prompt, different models, side-by-side comparison is the only way to actually know which one handles your workflow better.

side by side on your own brand is the only test that matters

Still it's only one prompt

@droppeddotfun one prompt, twelve emails, no edits. that's the whole point

it hard to choose in-between these two 🥶

nike was genuinely too close to call. this one less so

This is so dope af man

thanks mate

Claude Fable 5 was my favorite. Its outputs felt more consistently cinematic and restrained.

cinematic and restrained is a good way to put it. ferrari suits fable

Choosing the second

codex has its backers

Wow this is next level

cheers

Looking forward to round 3 👀

round 3 is coming, apple next

Like how th same prompt runs this all.

twelve emails off one sentence still gets me

Both did really good on this. Kinda hard to pick a side

nike was a coin flip. ferrari less so imo

this is a great event on here

cheers mate

This is sleek

cheers

Fable 5 looks cleaner overall, especially the hierarchy and spacing.

@FTdreamguy hierarchy and spacing is where it pulled ahead, yeah

This is wonderfully built

@crypto0ggg cheers

Both of them is okay

both cooked, one cooked better

This is the best I have seen so far

@BardBoyHoly appreciate it

It's easy to notice which is better

harder to call on the nike round, this one's obvious

this is absolutely a genius one

cheers mate

Lowkey Codex got this one

you're in the minority this round, fable's cleaning up

This is one strong competition

they're pushing each other hard

Both have strengths but execution details matter most here

execution is the whole game once both can write

Really hard to pick a side

was the same on the nike round. this one's more clear cut

Great platform

cheers

Claude Fable 5 is clearly better. Cleaner hierarchy, stronger Ferrari voice, more cinematic and restrained.

that's the clearest breakdown anyone's given it. ferrari voice is the bit codex missed

Both are amazing but i prefer claude Fable 5

fable's winning this round comfortably

Wow making everything simpler and faster

that's the idea, less setup more sending

Fable is the best

fable's got the numbers this round

Claude Fable 5 is what I'll go for

fable's the favourite this round