Loading video...
Video Failed to Load
Claude Fable 5.2 Medium vs High vs Extra High vs Max 🛩️ Does effort really matter? Now it's Fable 5.2's turn. Same model. Same prompt. Only the setting changes. Medium: $61.90 · 1h 49m 39s High: $77.90 · 1h 48m 45s Extra High: $209.50 · 3h 02m 54s Max:... show more
77,607 views • 4 days ago •via X (Twitter)
37 Comments

Great test, one thing tho, did you run each setting more than once? with a single run, two High runs can differ as much as High vs Max. would love to see 3 runs each before calling a winner

One run per setting here 👌 Fair point: repeated runs would give a better picture of consistency before declaring an overall winner. Follow me and turn on notifications so you don’t miss what’s next. I post every day!

Appreciate it. the cost data alone is gold, most people never share the bill

I would pick extra high for realism and cost

Extra High’s cliff detail looks great, and its estimated cost was $78.75 below Max.

xhigh quality looks great, I like the outcome more than max one

I can see why 👌 Extra High’s cliffs and lighting look great, and its estimated cost was $78.75 lower than Max.

The results are random so...

One run per setting, so some randomness is fair 😄 The bill isn’t random, though: it climbed at every step. Extra High is still my go-to for quality, time and cost. Follow me and turn on notifications so you don’t miss what’s next. I post every day!

What about ultra code?

Ultra was in my previous three effort comparisons. I swapped it for Medium here after followers asked for a more affordable everyday setting. Follow me and turn on notifications so you don’t miss what’s next. I post every day!

I've been running Max for 2 days

Two days on Max takes commitment 😂 In this test it came in $78.75 above Extra High, so keep an eye on your usage. Follow me and turn on notifications so you don’t miss what’s next. I post every day!

I had two Fable resets and two weekly resets; it's almost up. I run Fable 5.2 locally on Max as a team Captain and Opus 5.5 as the engineer in the cloud, and Fable takes on the hard tasks and instructs and checks the engineer for more routine execution.

Extra high seems better better

That’s my pick too 😄 Extra High is my go-to for the best balance of quality, time, and cost. Follow me and turn on notifications so you don’t miss what’s next. I post every day!

Curious about your film test: AA has Fable 5.2 max at 56 for $44.22/task, versus Kimi K3.1 Pro at 49 rounded for $2.94. Different task, but would you run the same film prompt on a Chinese model as a baseline?

Good suggestion 👌 I’ve tested Kimi and DeepSeek on other scenes. Running this exact prompt would make a useful comparison of quality, cost and time. Follow me and turn on notifications so you don’t miss what’s next. I post every day!

i'd go with Extra High unless the quality jump from there to Max is obvious in the final film

Agreed 👌 Max added $78.75 in estimated cost and nearly 17 minutes here. I’d want a clear improvement in the finished film to justify that.

Thank you!

🫡

I had the same experience, medium is also really good, better than high for me, even in your test, the water on medium is way better than high

Yeah, I’d pick Medium over High for the water in this one too. Funny what you notice when you stop looking at the labels 👀

Looks good

Thanks mate!

it can, especially on harder tasks. At nearly five times Medium’s cost in your run, I’d want Max’s extra reasoning to show up in what it actually solves.

Agreed 👌 For this film, the extra effort needs to show in the scene details, animation and how closely it follows the brief. Follow me and turn on notifications so you don’t miss what’s next. I post every day!

@VulcanBench

holy, man that looks cool af

Thanks man 🙌 I love seeing how differently each setting handles the same scene. Follow me and turn on notifications so you don’t miss what’s next. I post every day!

So either use max or medium eh

Extra High is still my go-to 😄 For me, it’s the best balance of quality, time, and cost. Follow me and turn on notifications so you don’t miss what’s next. I post every day!

Two years ago, I wouldn't have believed that a neural network did it

It still amazes me that I can direct an agent to build these scenes without knowing how to code 👀 Follow me and turn on notifications so you don’t miss what’s next. I post every day!

the real cliff is high to extra high, not max. +$130 and an extra hour, then only ~$79 more for max. if max is clearly the best, extra high ends up the worst value of the four

That $131.60 jump is steep 👌 Some viewers prefer Extra High to Max, though, so the value ranking depends on which result you actually want. Follow me and turn on notifications so you don’t miss what’s next. I post every day!



