Loading video...
Video Failed to Load
Debunking 5 myths about Islam
11,875 views • 8 months ago •via X (Twitter)
31 Comments

Claim 2.

Aisha was 6. Shouting won't erase it. Get that in your freaking head

Stop with your clown show. You're not even a real Muzzie, just a ridiculous figure. Everyone is already laughing at you.

(Another exposure of your lies.) (P. 1) @CanyonMimbs Your video purporting to debunk five media lies about Islam is itself misleading, as it selectively interprets Islamic sources while ignoring textual, historical, and scholarly evidence that substantiates these conceptions as rooted in traditional Islamic teachings and practices. This approach commits the fallacy of cherry-picking, presenting apologetic explanations that downplay or contextualize problematic elements without addressing their normative implications in classical jurisprudence and history. We will refute each claim using primary Islamic texts, scholarly analyses, and historical critiques, including from early Church Fathers who engaged Islam, to demonstrate that these are not mere media fabrications but reflect authentic aspects of Islamic doctrine and application. First, the assertion that Islam does not permit child marriage is false, as evidenced by Muhammad's marriage to Aisha at age six, consummated at nine, per authoritative hadith. Sahih al-Bukhari (7:62:64) narrates Aisha saying, "The Prophet married me when I was six years old, and consummated the marriage with me when I was nine years old." Sahih Muslim (8:3309) confirms this timeline. Your video's claim of Aisha's maturity overlooks that classical scholars like al-Tabari interpreted her age literally, and fiqh texts permit marriage to prepubescent girls with guardian consent (Reliance of the Traveller o1.0 (1991, rev. 1994)). Scholarly works affirm this: Nehls examines how such traditions influenced child marriage practices in Muslim societies, noting its persistence despite modern reforms (Nehls, The Prophet Muhammad: A Christian Perspective 89 (2006, repr. 2018)). Brown traces the historical acceptance of child marriage in Islamic law, rooted in prophetic precedent, with minimal age restrictions until recent fatwas (Brown, Muhammad: A Very Short Introduction 45 (2011)). Church Fathers interacting with Islam, such as John of Damascus, critiqued Muhammad's marital practices as inconsistent with divine morality, implying ethical flaws (Sahas, John of Damascus on Islam: The "Heresy of the Ishmaelites" 89 (1972, repr. 2014)). Janosik analyzes how early apologists used such examples to highlight contrasts with Christian ethics (Janosik, John of Damascus, First Apologist to the Muslims: The Trinity and Christian Apologetics in the Early Islamic Period 112 (2016)). If puberty equates to maturity, as your video suggests, it ignores psychological and ethical concerns raised in modern studies, like Warraich's examination of child marriage in Pakistan under sharia (Warraich, Child Marriage in Pakistan: A Study of Socio-Legal Dimensions 67 (2005)).

Islam is from Satan him self a cult

you are utterly terrible at this. your miserable propaganda doesn’t fly. as i said, you must be paid well to spew your propaganda rubbish. Allah is not God and salvation is through Jesus only. no eternal seXXX club in jannah.

Taqqiya. The story of Aisha marrying Muhammad at 6 yo comes from muslims, is not a western invention. Anyway, some migrants want to rape minors using as defence that it's part of their culture and that they didn't know it's illegal in the West.

Then why are some sects of Muslims doing the very thing you are refuting?

Muhammed was a nonce he married a kids and so you all love Gary glitter.

Shut up. Idiot. Don't teach us. we know better than you. Go drink camels urine.

Is This the proving of all the Myths about islam ?

The hadiths explicitly state she was 6 when she was married

The 1889 Johnstown Flood (one of the worst floods in US history, killing thousands): Sultan Abdul Hamid II was the first state to provide aid without being asked, sending 200 Ottoman liras (money) plus food aid.

Keep dreaming, kid ....

Islam is garbage. Read my bio 😂

So basically he cherry picks the positive verses out of context. He can't explain what an innocent means in islam. If you mock a Mohammed companion you are not innocent.These are just false English translations. This guy is literally doing fallacy but ignoring the real argumen

HE LIES to deceive. Let's as Aisha herself shall we. A'isha (Allah be pleased with her) reported: “Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) married me when I was six years old, and I was admitted to his house at the age of nine.” (Sahih Muslim 3309)

Says a moron who’s too blind to see Muslims marry kids everyday

This is islam

The age of ayesha is an unsettled debate.

Claim 1. In Islam, the waiting period is, a mandatory time for a woman to wait before remarrying after divorce or widowhood, primarily to confirm paternity, allow for reconciliation, and provide mourning time. "What about the waiting period of those who do not have menstruation because they are too young" "Those who have yet not menstruated, because of their young age" "The same for the young, you have not reached their years of menstruation"

muuhammed said god would cut his aorta if he lied Quran 69:44-46 . guess how he described the feeling of when he died?`as if someone cut his aorta. Sahih Bukhari 4428. how can anyone believe him after this?

You are terrible at this give yourself a break 😭😂🤣😅

If a Muslims lips are moving it means they are lying 🤣

There’s a reason you guys have to keep repeating over and over and over and over again Islam is a religion of peace. I suppose if you say it enough times, maybe you’ll believe it.

So Bukhari is wrong about Aisha was 9?

Please Answer my question on Islam that no one has ever been able to answer: Is AI short for Artificial Islam? This: 57 Islamic countries yet none has equality of men women & infidels under their laws: please please name just 1 that treats women & infidels as the same as men under their Islamic law?! Tell me I am wrong?

YOU'RE A LIAR! SATAN IS THE FATHER OF LIES!

He says that's all you need to know. Don't worry about the 14th hadiths that say she was nine when they consummated and the zero that say she was older than that. Just worry about backhand calculations based off assumptions from other texts that aren't as reliable. Not the 14 plus sahih Hadiths that are clear as shif and require no assumptions.

that the Prophet (ﷺ) married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old. Hisham said: I have been informed that `Aisha remained with the Prophet (ﷺ) for nine years (i.e. till his death). When Muslims say "come of age" they mean the girl has had her first period and is now considered an adult?! At the time of the marriage and its consummation, Muhammad was in his 50s (50 or 53). The Quran permits sexual relations with female captives ("those whom your right hands possess") as spoils of war, but also encourages freeing them, emphasizes marriage as superior, and mandates humane treatment, though it doesn't abolish slavery itself, leaving rules for concubinage and marriage to later Islamic jurisprudence, generally treating these women as property with limited rights, but also offering paths to freedom.

"Past the age of maturity - and that's all you need to know" what is the maturity? menstruation? which can appear as early as age 8 and the average of 12?
