Loading video...
Video Failed to Load
Debunking Dave Ramsey's Financial Advice
216,845 views • 3 months ago •via X (Twitter)
35 Comments

To be fair, Dave’s advice was great 25 years ago. It just hasn’t kept up with the times. For instance, my son’s ‘hoopty’ cost $12k.

Ramsey's advice is 3-6 month emergency fund. The 1K number is a safety-net for those who have nothing, BEFORE paying off debt. Read the Baby Steps again. Love your work, but this is pedantic as hell. You guys directionally say the same things.

Isn't it 1000 to start and as you snowball out of debt you then save 3-6 months worth for emergency?

This is false. He says 3-6 months. If you are going to go at the King you better get it right

This is a dishonest representation of what Ramsey teaches

I always heard three months emergency fund. Can’t recall from who now. The amount being based on current spend (mortgage, bills, etc) instead of static value.

We need a Dave Ramsey Caleb Hammer debate ! It would be 🔥🔥🔥🔥

I hear you, but following a Dave Ramsey plan is still much better than having no plan at all. We can pick apart every financial expert’s advice, but I’d rather someone “risk” sticking with Dave’s approach and handle any emergency over $1,000 when it actually happens than keep putting more on credit.

Most people starting Ramsay's stuff has 0 dollars saved. 1000 is massively better than 0. Simple as.

I have to agree with you. I stuck to Dave Ramey’s $1000 emergency and then my car needed a $3000 car transmission rebuild. The $1000 paid for my rental car for that week, but I had to borrow the $3000. From now on I will always keep $3000 as my baby emergency fund.

I dont like it when mom and dad fight

Show us the financial models that prove that you can’t maintain a nest egg averaging 12% by taking out and average 6-7% Y’all are taking some things too literally. I have an employee who religiously follows Dave Ramsey’s show and is doing awesome financially but he has a credit card. He has a 30 year mortgage. I doubt he has any Mutual Finds. He’s probably not meeting each and every requirement of the baby steps. But he’s close. And it’s working for him. Debt is dumb, cash is king, keep investing simple.

Caleb, I agree to some extent. You're missing goal completion gratification. If you can get $1000 in your emergency fund as a first step. You've changed your habits to actually do it. Now on to add more or start working on your debt; smallest first for the same reason.

The 1000 is for an emergency only… the idiots that stop saving after that have no one to blame but themselves for being so clueless

$1000 won't even cover a broken tooth even if you have medium dental insurance.

These are really nibbling around the edges. Sure, bump up the emergency fund. They're not fundamental disagreements. You're basically promoting the same thing: Live within your means.

He can disagree with Dave Ramsey plan, but he also has to understand that DR numbers he recommends are on a minimum scale. He teaches how to have discipline with saving and prioritizing, which most people struggle with. Caleb knows this

Approximately 60% of Americans live paycheck to paycheck and cannot cover a $1,000 emergency. Dave Ramsey’s Baby Step 1 is to save a $1,000 cash emergency fund. It is a starting point—not the final goal. Its purpose is to create a small buffer so every extra dollar can be thrown at debt (everything except the mortgage) as aggressively as possible. This requires: •Pausing all investments •Following a strict, written budget •Working extra hours The $1,000 fund is only for true emergencies. If you are budgeting tightly and directing all available income toward debt, most unexpected expenses can be handled without touching it. Once consumer debt is eliminated, Baby Steps 3 & 4 call for building a fully funded emergency fund of 3–6 months of expenses and beginning to invest 15% of income for retirement. Income is the primary driver of wealth. When it is constantly drained by debt payments and lifestyle spending, wealth remains out of reach. Eliminating debt and maintaining disciplined budgeting free up cash flow. The more cash flow you can invest, the faster wealth compounds. Simple math with achievable results. Just ask the thousands of people who followed the program.

There could always be an emergency that is bigger than your emergency fund. Secondly, no one is in a worse off position because they had a small emergency fund. They either saved and had a larger emergency fund or paid off debt. At worst its merely moving the shells around.

This is a misrepresentation of Dave’s plan. It starts at $1000 initially and then later moves to a 3-6 month emergency. You are missing the psychological point which is for the person to stay hungry in getting out of debt.

Debunking any financial advice is retarded. Mainly because we are individuals. Different needs, habitations, obligations etc. Although you do good work. Carry on.

For a family of 4 in 2026, $1k won’t cut it. One month of essentials typically runs $7k–$10k+ depending on location and lifestyle.

I usually have a 22 month emergency fund. Just in case. Then if that goes, I usually have a backup 500,000 in a separate account. Guys this is easy. Just save all your money. Eating is stupid anyways.

At least more than 3% of Dave's show is actually financial advice and not pearl clutching and screaming "KLARNA!!!"

I’ve read Total Money Makeover multiple times. Dave Ramsey saved me from financial disaster. It’s fine if you want to alter his steps slightly, but overall his principles are solid

I just buy $gme

Ramsey has great financial advice for people absolutely terrible with money, but poor advice for anyone decent or good with money. #Truth

Ohhh financial advisor fight!! 🍿🍿🍿

Yeah, like we’re going to listen to you over Dave Ramsey.

Hes retiring because his bramd doesn't work anymore

The studies show that Dave's advice is faster at wealth building.

But yet, there’s real world people that call into his show everyday and say his philosophy has changed their lives. Of course it won’t have a 100% success rate. But it works way more often than it doesn’t.

It’s because Dave is a delusional boomer who was handed everything and thinks he earned it.

$1,000 was good in 2008 Not today.

Emergency fund baby step one is $1000. Later it gets 6 months of monthly bills or so. Dave sets easily attainable goals so you can hit higher numbers later. They give the same advice but Caleb is more aggressive in a good way.
