正在加载视频...

视频加载失败

Debunking the “plastic keys” myth.

123,158 次观看 • 7 个月前 •via X (Twitter)

28 条评论

ZoroastrianCultureIsNot4Sale 的头像
ZoroastrianCultureIsNot4Sale7 个月前

Keys to heaven being a Christian myth is what always struck me, too. That and the insane versions of this story such as Iranian children given the key being ordered to clear minefields.

The Persian 的头像
The Persian7 个月前

I also grew up hearing this and immediately called BS. Not one specimen or even photo of these alleged millions of keys. My theory is that soldiers were gifted the prayer book 'Mafātīḥ al-Jinān' (lit. Keys to the Heavens) and some idiot heard about this and took it literally.

mgan79 的头像
mgan797 个月前

I hate BS like this because Iran–Iraq War, the Iranian govts role in it, and how they sent child soldiers out to die would be as atrocious either way Also…it's completely true they told soldiers of all ages that they'd die as martyrs and go to heaven—so why the need for the BS?

Educated 的头像
Educated7 个月前

"To bolster their courage, their commander gave them each a golden plastic key said to open the door to paradise." - Pierre Razoux, Historian and author of Iran-Iraq War (p. 346). Your uncle isn't the oracle. Do your research. History isn't a game of anecdotes.

Mirza Adel F. Hei'atlary 的头像
Mirza Adel F. Hei'atlary7 个月前

I haven't seen a single sane artist who painted in that unique "garbage de liberale" style.

Nari X̌ā-i Bāδ J̌īnǰičaken 的头像
Nari X̌ā-i Bāδ J̌īnǰičaken7 个月前

Thank you for discrediting that cringeworthy novel.

AlphaRuh. 的头像
AlphaRuh.7 个月前

They were indeed given actual keys, that's actually witnessed by Iraqi veterans which are people I personally know. I'm not saying this because I hate Iran or Iranians, I respect them and the government, but the first generation of the Islamic Republic had indeed such practices.

roxana Menila 的头像
roxana Menila7 个月前

Trying to whitewash the mullahs' barbarism? Those plastic keys sent thousands of children into minefields while the clerics stayed safe. Calling it a myth is pure regime-washing. We will never forget the slaughter of Iran's youth. History is coming for you. #IranRevolution2026

TheNarrator 的头像
TheNarrator7 个月前

somebody wrote about "indigenous orientalism" gosh who was it? ... oh yeah! Seyed Mohammad Marandi

Iran’s Amazing 的头像
Iran’s Amazing7 个月前

I am so grateful to you for this video. Thank you so much. I was first told this by Nader Talabzadeh. I met him one day, and he spent a few hours going through all the crap I had heard from everyone I knew growing up in America. He explained to me the stories behind these myths. I am forever grateful for his time. Now yours. Here is this film, The Messiah- an Islamic account of Jesus-what he thought was a culmination, at the time he was working on this, of his life's work that he was so proud of:

HellHeight 的头像
HellHeight7 个月前

VERY IMPORTANT!!! The Artesh and Basij/Sepah are different things!!! The Army didn't use child soldiers!

Phantom of Ferdowsi 卐 的头像
Phantom of Ferdowsi 卐7 个月前

Wow, this hit hard as I was pushed into believing this garbage in my teenage years. Thank you.

بنده‌ی خدا 的头像
بنده‌ی خدا7 个月前

Thank you, you exposed this shit propagandist

Krsj 的头像
Krsj7 个月前

More subliminally the purpose of myths like these is to tell western audiences “they don’t value their lives, so you don’t have to either.” It’s why so much anti Muslim propaganda in the 2000s focused on the idea of 72 virgins. It’s ok if we kill people who want to die.

Abbas Ghadimi 的头像
Abbas Ghadimi7 个月前

The key claim pre-dates Satrapi's comic. I knew an Iranian guy who was in Iran's special forces during the Iran-Iraq War. He confirmed Iran using children to set off mines, but no mention of keys. Met an Afghan refugee who heard the Iran key claim in Afghanistan in the 90s.

NinaSwe 🇮🇷🇮🇱🇺🇦🇺🇸🇸🇪 的头像
NinaSwe 🇮🇷🇮🇱🇺🇦🇺🇸🇸🇪7 个月前

For all the children who were kidnapped while playing soccer after school to join the war. Lord, hear my prayers. Jesus, protect the ones who are doing Your holy work. Free the children of Cyrus from that prison of agony and pain. You are my safety and shelter. Amen.

gooner accelerationist 的头像
gooner accelerationist7 个月前

Pretty relevant read.

Ari 的头像
Ari7 个月前

The keys did exist, I have heard it from my family who are Iran-Iraq war. It was not plastic

Khosrow Parviz 𐭥𐭮𐭫𐭥 𐭠𐭯𐭥𐭫𐭥𐭩𐭦 的头像
Khosrow Parviz 𐭥𐭮𐭫𐭥 𐭠𐭯𐭥𐭫𐭥𐭩𐭦7 个月前

You’re a troll. Cosplaying as a 14th century mystic poet, and you have the audacity to mock real Iranians?

Nahal Batmanghelidj 的头像
Nahal Batmanghelidj7 个月前

You’re a click-bait influencer and nothing more. It just occurred to me.

Sesostris 的头像
Sesostris5 个月前

The children were indoctrinated and used to detonate bombs. They were told they would go straight to heaven. Its evil with or without the keys. Thos documentary features interviews with child soldiers at the time and former child soldiers.

Internalized Statephobia 的头像
Internalized Statephobia7 个月前

so you, the Persian culture expert and explainer, are telling me that the Arabic phrase Mafatih al-Jinan has no cultural significance in Iran? Or that child soldiers *weren't* used as cannon fodder during that war?

roxana Menila 的头像
roxana Menila7 个月前

"Debunking" the mullahs' bloodlust? Whether it was physical keys or brutal brainwashing, thousands of Iranian children were sent into minefields as human waves. Erasing history won't wash the blood off the IRGC. The axis of filth is collapsing. #IranRevolution2026 #IRGCterrorists

roxana Menila 的头像
roxana Menila7 个月前

"Debunking" or just more regime-washing? The IRGC and mullahs sent thousands of children into minefields as human shields. Whether physical keys or brainwashing, the blood is on your hands. Your propaganda won't save the axis of filth. #IranRevolution2026 #IRGCterrorists

Daniel Biverd 的头像
Daniel Biverd7 个月前

Even if it is invented (but an absence of evidence is not an evidence of absence) suggesting it is "white" propaganda aimed at mentally disarming Iranians is quite ridiculous.

. 的头像
.7 个月前

تو همه جا باید گوه بخوری مرتیکه حروم زاده

Sonny Kuroshiro 🇮🇷🦁 的头像
Sonny Kuroshiro 🇮🇷🦁7 个月前

Dude you still talk about bullshit, just stop, you embarassed yourself

Abdul kaseem 的头像
Abdul kaseem7 个月前

@Khameinism It’s funny because my father who served in the Artesh would say that everyone in the regular army was secular and that it was the IRGC and Basij that would be doing the human wave assaults etc. I’ve had multiple family serve in that war, no one mentioned “golden keys” lmao

相关视频