Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

Go Home

Defending MAHA and its pseudoscience is an exercise in motivated reasoning and mental gymnastics, not scientific thinking.

56,101 views • 9 months ago •via X (Twitter)

51 Comments

Observer2952's profile picture
Observer29529 months ago

You cannot reason with people who cannot reason.

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

👍

Carmen Mannella PhD's profile picture
Carmen Mannella PhD9 months ago

Sad. It’s not just that they don’t know the facts. They don’t know what science is. How it works.

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

Exactly.

Robert B Hamilton's profile picture
Robert B Hamilton9 months ago

I would have found it to be a challenging exercise to maintain proper objectivity when responding to the young man. It probably could be pointed out that if a person in that position implements incorrect policy based on medical misinformation it could have a significant negative impact on public health. Moreover if done in a way that presents the appearance of scientific misconduct then it erodes public trust, a critical prerequisite to effectively performing the duties of such a leadership role. But I suspect that a word salad like that would not have much impact 🥲

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

Well said.

Sam's profile picture
Sam9 months ago

These people are lost.

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

Truly.

Graeme's profile picture
Graeme9 months ago

People defending RFK are up the the ‘fool me 245 times……’ of this saying

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

Lol. Yes.

Nils Stenström 🇸🇪🇺🇦's profile picture
Nils Stenström 🇸🇪🇺🇦9 months ago

Sometimes it's deeply sad to watch a sane, intellectual, well-read American debate a member of the MAGA cult. I guess you can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason themselves into; to them, the debate is never about truth, always about loyalty.

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

👍

Pat Pitsel's profile picture
Pat Pitsel9 months ago

I think this fits the kid.

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

Lol

Ali Land 🏴‍☠️'s profile picture
Ali Land 🏴‍☠️9 months ago

Dr.Mike has a lot of gentle patience! 🫣

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

💯

Carol, FIGHT MAGA FASCISM's profile picture
Carol, FIGHT MAGA FASCISM9 months ago

MAGA still claims Dr. Fauci lied about covid and masks when what he said about science finding new info was true. The hypocrisy knows no bounds with MAGA/MAHA.

BlowAkissGoodbye's profile picture
BlowAkissGoodbye9 months ago

i love Dr.Mike

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

🙌

❤️Deep Green Design's profile picture
❤️Deep Green Design9 months ago

Is it the worms?

Kaleonahe 🌈's profile picture
Kaleonahe 🌈9 months ago

Bobby Kennedy is turning in his grave.

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

👍

Charlotte✨🐛🦋's profile picture
Charlotte✨🐛🦋9 months ago

Dr. Mike has the patience of a saint.

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

💯

Loezzie 🐝🐝's profile picture
Loezzie 🐝🐝9 months ago

🤯

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

🫠

Stuart Rome's profile picture
Stuart Rome9 months ago

The contortions. Oof.

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

🥴

Missy the Muse...'s profile picture
Missy the Muse...9 months ago

When do you ever think scientifically? Im still waiting on this published study of isolation & purification Bun-Heed.

breathe's profile picture
breathe9 months ago

One doctor and one mental gymnast having a debate

Leanne Livingston's profile picture
Leanne Livingston9 months ago

I defend MAHA on one simple thing. Millions of Parents have lost Faith in the Trustworthiness of the Medical Industry. They Trust Bobby Kennedy who brought in People like @NIHDirector_Jay who are trying to rebuild that Trust. I'm good with that. I do Trust Jay

Xavier's profile picture
Xavier9 months ago

MAGA people believe anything this administration tells them...

Joshua Pelican's profile picture
Joshua Pelican9 months ago

Every time I see maga folk trying to justify something, a voice inside my head says "they can't be this stupid".

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

Familiar. 🫠

John's profile picture
John9 months ago

Trust the TV doctor making millions off the gullible

Shawn Ferdinand's profile picture
Shawn Ferdinand9 months ago

I have no idea how that doctor deals with that MAGA clown

Fearl's profile picture
Fearl9 months ago

It's like the movie Liar Liar, but they can only lie.

Al0y's profile picture
Al0y9 months ago

That's the collision of saintly patience and worrying bad faith or self-delusion

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

The bad-faith and self-delusion are familiar. 👍

RC's profile picture
RC9 months ago

Can’t change the mind of a cultist. Admitting being fooled would be too embarrassing, so it’s self-preservation at this point.

Tom11880's profile picture
Tom118809 months ago

There is no common ground to debate on with people that actively deny reality itself.

Max Kissass, U.S. Dept. of Ignorance's profile picture
Max Kissass, U.S. Dept. of Ignorance9 months ago

"According to the new nutrition food pyramid, it's now OK to eat meat, but you have to get it from the side of the road." -- Paula Poundstone

The Crystal Brian's profile picture
The Crystal Brian9 months ago

Even Tylenol says that pregnant women should not take their product.

Deb 👀 🇦🇺's profile picture
Deb 👀 🇦🇺9 months ago

I think it’s a deliberate depopulation agenda getting people not to vaccinate their kids now in Florida when children start suffering then these people need to be held accountable

Auroria Twittoria EN's profile picture
Auroria Twittoria EN9 months ago

Another public-nudging pharmaceutical propaganda account on X. Actually what MAHA does is removing the improperly tested hence unscientifically introduced childhood vaccines from the programme.

Cassandra Helm's profile picture
Cassandra Helm9 months ago

Sorry no - big pharma, big food, big ag are all corrupt industries. They are not holy institutions, they are businesses and they are manufacturing faulty/toxic products. In the case of big Pharma there are no consequences for its most profitable sector. It should be criminal.

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

😆

donovanbokd's profile picture
donovanbokd9 months ago

Sounds to me that the dean of harvard was the one who gave him the statistics. He report what a “credible source” gave him. Maybe the dean of harvard shiuld be fired.

Magatroller🇨🇦's profile picture
Magatroller🇨🇦9 months ago

The fuck your feelings crowd is backing a dude with “feelings” about things

gimpEguy's profile picture
gimpEguy9 months ago

This isn't even a debate about health for the MAHA group, it's politics just in another front. THEY do not care about truth, just backing their guy. It's like watching a football match, a defender handles the ball on the line and you say penalty and the fan says, no, it wasn't.

Dr. Jonathan N. Stea's profile picture
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea9 months ago

💯🥄

Related Videos