Video yükleniyor...
Video Yüklenemedi
🇵🇸🇮🇱 Do you think the war was handled appropriately and proportionally? My stance is clear, but I want to hear from those who disagree as well as those who agree. My stance is simple: Oct 7 was HORRIFIC, but the response was not proportional and horrific as well. The... show more
771,625 görüntüleme • 2 yıl önce •via X (Twitter)
9 Yorum

Video from @ShaykhSulaiman

War is not supposed to be proportional. War is meant to be overwhelming in order to defeat your enemy. There is never going to be a requirement that war be fair and proportional. That is crazy. If someone is trying to kill you, then you should bring an overwhelming response and destroy your enemy. In any war, someone has to win and someone has to lose. They need to just fight this out until one side or the other is ready to surrender.

"The response was not proportional" Would you mind sharing what's a proportional response? Did Israel have to rape, mutilate, lynch, behead, and burn the exact number of women and children, and then abduct the exact number of people?

It was started in 1948 when they took over the land. Simple.

October 7 was HORRIFIC but what about all the terrorist attacks Israel and the West did to Palestine before October 7?

We are sincerely all ears @MarioNawfal, what is the most humane way of ending Hamas?

I have no idea where people got the idea that wars are supposed to be "proportional." Quite the opposite, actually. If you're attacked, your goal should be to make the retaliation so devastating that your opponent is unwilling or better yet, unable to attack you again.

No such things as proportionality or equivalence in war. Israel's jobs is to make October 7th will never happen again and the neighbour is never a threat to its civilians ever again. Palestinian and Gazan can now have a chance at making better decision, have a government that will not embezzle from them and give them a future rather than celebrate death and be obsessed with 4th century Islamic expansionism.

You have no idea what you are talking about. What is proportionality?? The proportional response is to dismantle the Hamas regime, to topple Hamas - Hamas is embedded in the Palestinian population, the less painful way is for 2 million Palestinians who are being sacrificed by the terrorists to topple the Hamas regime - but they don't. So Israel is now forced to dismantle the regime piece by piece, it's a war. Let me explain a very simple concept - Hamas will no longer be on Israel's border, that is Israel's right as a nation-state that was attacked by an Islamist terrorist organization that has an army - that is the proportional response, casualties do not figure in proportional response, the goal is removal of Hamas which is proportional to the invasion & massacre Hamas carried out and the threat they represent to Israeli citizens. There is no HUMANE WAY to destroy a terror organization that spent 15 years building a massive terrorist base in every inch of GAZA. Regards.

