Video wird geladen...

Video konnte nicht geladen werden

Zur Startseite

Does believing in a different creator for the universe constitute shirk? Muhammad Yasir al-Hanafi, the popular Ash'ari theologian, answers the question.

430,556 Aufrufe • vor 8 Monaten •via X (Twitter)

34 Kommentare

Profilbild von Mohammed
Mohammedvor 8 Monaten

At this point, do these people consider anything to be shirk? Because every act of polytheism can be justified with such absurd logic.

Profilbild von A
Avor 8 Monaten

Thats basically a dependent god. This is giving attributes of Allah to ghair Allah and adding “dependent on allah” to not make it shirk lol Can I worship ganesh believing he is dependent on Allah? Is it shirk? Shirki Sheikh: not shirk

Profilbild von Rogue Theist
Rogue Theistvor 8 Monaten

This is a justification for polytheism by proxy.

Profilbild von Shakavelli
Shakavellivor 8 Monaten

‘Demigods are not shirk’

Profilbild von udara malam
udara malamvor 8 Monaten

Akhi brother Farid, you should make it clear that you opposed his beliefs otherwise people will misunderstood your post.

Profilbild von Exposing Deviant Sects and Scholars
Exposing Deviant Sects and Scholarsvor 8 Monaten

1 of the underlying reasons Sufis never call clear cut shirk to be SHIRK akbar that takes one out of Islam is because ALL (each and every one) of their Scholars promote or defend Heretics like #IbnArabi (Claimants to divinity) Not once u find them making takfir on these heretics

Profilbild von ABDULHAMID
ABDULHAMIDvor 8 Monaten

Mufti Menk seems wayyy better at this point than them

Profilbild von Salim
Salimvor 8 Monaten

Yeah, this is not shirk This is Shirk Alrububia

Profilbild von Fikran Yusufzai | 🇸🇩
Fikran Yusufzai | 🇸🇩vor 8 Monaten

That's correct, this is a bid'ah, not shirk. We believe Allah gave 'Esa (AS) the power to give life and would not say that's shirk because the power was given by Allah. Same here.

Profilbild von Hamza Farah
Hamza Farahvor 8 Monaten

الله اكبر is there any kufr after this ? These people have exceed the shirk and kufr of the pagan arabs in pre Islamic time even the pagan Arabs knew that Allah was the creator and controller of affairs alone but having known that they worshiped others beside Allah but you have Daniel the rafidii and this ashari claiming the belief that believing others can control the universe besides Allah is not kufr ?! Or shirk ?!! أخزاهم الله وقطع الله لسانهم Consider what the Quran actually says وَلَئِن سَأَلْتَهُم مَّنْ خَلَقَ ٱلسَّمَـٰوَٰتِ وَٱلْأَرْضَ وَسَخَّرَ ٱلشَّمْسَ وَٱلْقَمَرَ لَيَقُولُنَّ ٱللَّهُ ۖ فَأَنَّىٰ يُؤْفَكُونَ ٦١ If you ask them ˹O Prophet˺ who created the heavens and the earth and subjected the sun and the moon ˹for your benefit˺, they will certainly say, “Allah!” How can they then be deluded ˹from the truth˺? Surah 29:61 وَلَئِن سَأَلْتَهُم مَّنْ خَلَقَ ٱلسَّمَـٰوَٰتِ وَٱلْأَرْضَ لَيَقُولُنَّ ٱللَّهُ ۚ قُلْ أَفَرَءَيْتُم مَّا تَدْعُونَ مِن دُونِ ٱللَّهِ إِنْ أَرَادَنِىَ ٱللَّهُ بِضُرٍّ هَلْ هُنَّ كَـٰشِفَـٰتُ ضُرِّهِۦٓ أَوْ أَرَادَنِى بِرَحْمَةٍ هَلْ هُنَّ مُمْسِكَـٰتُ رَحْمَتِهِۦ ۚ قُلْ حَسْبِىَ ٱللَّهُ ۖ عَلَيْهِ يَتَوَكَّلُ ٱلْمُتَوَكِّلُونَ ٣٨ If you ask them ˹O Prophet˺ who created the heavens and the earth, they will certainly say, “Allah!” Ask ˹them˺, “Consider then whatever ˹idols˺ you invoke besides Allah: if it was Allah’s Will to harm me, could they undo that harm? Or if He willed ˹some˺ mercy for me, could they withhold His mercy?” Say, “Allah is sufficient for me. In Him ˹alone˺ the faithful put their trust.” Surah 39:38

Profilbild von Misbah Bangee
Misbah Bangeevor 8 Monaten

Athari for the win. Btw which books would u recommend for indepth athiri creed knowledge?

Profilbild von Mon Mothmā
Mon Mothmāvor 8 Monaten

That last nervous unsure cackle at the end 💀

Profilbild von Joe
Joevor 8 Monaten

Neoplatonism in full effect.

Profilbild von Wesam Almahdi
Wesam Almahdivor 8 Monaten

Why does he shave his entire mustache but leave his unibrow? Someone that backwards in fiqh will certainly be backwards in aqidah

Profilbild von CATMAN
CATMANvor 8 Monaten

@YasirAlHanafi Imam Abu Hanifa Rahimahullah is free from you , You Stupid Mushrik

Profilbild von τeg R
τeg Rvor 8 Monaten

he's not wrong. Daniel is careful in the words he uses and says power GIVEN by Allah, it's also said as an extreme example, he doesn't believe it himself. Yasir even said it's not an islamic belief, so neither does he. Why are you still talking about this? Need engagement?

Profilbild von GeneralSound
GeneralSoundvor 8 Monaten

I think we all very tired of this now no matter what side… It’s proven fueling the flames publicly has no benifit to the ummah at all… and one from either side looks ends up looking like idiot - time and time again These matters should be kept private. I more worried about our fellow Muslims who is on the brink of getting nuked and this will be a big problem for all in the region

Profilbild von JUSTICE
JUSTICEvor 8 Monaten

The guy is a kafir clearly...

Profilbild von Zeyad Afzal
Zeyad Afzalvor 8 Monaten

Clown show.

Profilbild von Abu Mu'awiyah
Abu Mu'awiyahvor 8 Monaten

Lmfao. Was Abu Jahil a mushrik?

Profilbild von Abu Ahmad al Hanbali
Abu Ahmad al Hanbalivor 8 Monaten

Wouldn’t Muhammad yasir fall into the third nullifier? If not then what’s the reason him saying that this isn’t shirk os dangerously extreme enough and to me it fits the nullifier @Farid_0v

Profilbild von Ali ahmed
Ali ahmedvor 8 Monaten

@MahatAzizElmi Question should be to these two rafidi simps can you TELL US IS ANYTHING SHIRK🤣

Profilbild von TraderAkh
TraderAkhvor 8 Monaten

Is it so difficult to worship Allah alone? To call upon him alone? To call upon another, be it a “wali” or the noble prophets (peace and blessing be upon them all) shows lack of faith in Allah

Profilbild von Imados
Imadosvor 8 Monaten

Yeah this is shirk

Profilbild von Type_Zero
Type_Zerovor 8 Monaten

Why are you lying? He said nothing about 'different creator'. The prophet or the saint, in that scenario is only a wasila, NOT actual creators provided that their power is purely dependent.

Profilbild von Ibn Gani al Drenici al Albani
Ibn Gani al Drenici al Albanivor 8 Monaten

Is this new or old Brother ? Not that it change anything but I’m curios

Profilbild von Farid
Faridvor 8 Monaten

Two months.

Profilbild von Bio Sa
Bio Savor 8 Monaten

This is clearly major shirk and major kufr. Stay away from these mushrikeen if you care about your akhirah. This mushrik Daniel and this ashari polytheist (like all asharis) trying to protect their shia brothers in kufr Exposed - Shia believe imam controls everything

Profilbild von ابو عمر
ابو عمرvor 8 Monaten

From his answer, you can tell that he benefits from this polytheism yet calls it a myth. I seek refuge in Allah from him. You are charlatans and liars, agents of devils.”

Profilbild von Cringe Bunny
Cringe Bunnyvor 8 Monaten

@ABDULHAMID_21 So people try to confuse you about clear cut shirk because they want to unite with Iran

Profilbild von Sunnī
Sunnīvor 8 Monaten

Will you ever tell us attributing how much control would constitute shirk? I am not asking about kufr.

Profilbild von Asim
Asimvor 8 Monaten

This is basically saying God Almighty granted this “person” a SHARE in his attributes. That is the very definition of shirk. Yet, it’s like the Christian’s with Jesus. Both parties still claim God is One, meaning legally…

Profilbild von H☝🏽
H☝🏽vor 8 Monaten

“Makes the hair on my body stand up” yeah that’s your fitrah bro. Stop pandering to this Shia/shirk apologist.

Profilbild von AlAlbani
AlAlbanivor 8 Monaten

This is crazy , how is NOT shirk These people dont know the beauty of tawheed

Ähnliche Videos

सृष्टि रचना (Srishti Rachna Fully Explained In Hindi) : क्या सृष्टि की रचना के पीछे है कोई दिव्य शक्ति? Who is Creator of the Universe? You will also get answers to these questions: How the Universe Works? | How Big is the Universe? | How the Universe was Created According to Hinduism? | How Big the Universe Really is? | How Big is Our Universe? | Is the Universe Real? | What if Naruto was the Creator of the Universe? | Who is the Creator of the Universe Jesus Christ? | Why Would the Creator of the Universe be Personal? | Who is Allah? - The Creator of the Universe | Who Created the Creator of the Universe? | Who is the Creator of the Universe? | Who is the Creator of the Universe in Hindi? | Who is the Creator of the Universe? | Why God is the Creator of the Universe? | Creator of the Universe? | Creation of universe in quran | Creation of universe in islam | Creation of universe bible story | Creation of universe iskcon | Creation of universe according to vishnu puran | Creation of universe in hinduism | Creation of universe | What is Satlok? _________________________________________ संत रामपाल जी महाराज से नाम दीक्षा प्राप्त करने के लिए या अपने नजदीकी नामदीक्षा केंद्र का पता करने के लिए हमे +91 82228 80541 नंबर पर कॉल करें | #creationofnature #sristirachna

SA True Story

808,851 Aufrufe • vor 1 Jahr