Video wird geladen...

Video konnte nicht geladen werden

Zur Startseite

Does Scotland need fiscal autonomy? Andy Maciver explains why he thinks the country would benefit and why the public should support it, no matter their thoughts on the constitution. Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein

HolyroodSources's profile picture

Holyrood Sources

5,075 subscribers

15,625 Aufrufe • vor 1 Monat •via X (Twitter)

LIVE

Anya Rossi• Live Now

Private livecam show

0 Kommentare

Keine Kommentare verfügbar

Kommentare vom Original-Post werden hier angezeigt

Ähnliche Videos

“An independent Scotland would have much less room for its own fiscal policy than they’d like to say” Dan Neidle explains the two reasons as to why he thinks it’s very tricky for the Scottish Government to raise income tax in its current state. Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein | Andy Maciver
0:53

“An independent Scotland would have much less room for its own fiscal policy than they’d like to say” Dan Neidle explains the two reasons as to why he thinks it’s very tricky for the Scottish Government to raise income tax in its current state. Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein | Andy Maciver

Holyrood Sources

45,037 Aufrufe • vor 15 Tagen

“Are the SNP are ignoring the national security risks of leaving the UK“ asks Calum Macdonald No- replies Geoff Aberdein Yet, Andy Maciver thinks Scotland could still have Trident if it were independent…
2:10

“Are the SNP are ignoring the national security risks of leaving the UK“ asks Calum Macdonald No- replies Geoff Aberdein Yet, Andy Maciver thinks Scotland could still have Trident if it were independent…

Holyrood Sources

14,603 Aufrufe • vor 9 Monaten

“He doesn’t even have to look at them” If Reform UK and the Scottish Conservatives have a chance to elect Labour’s Anas Sarwar as First Minister, will they do so? Andy Maciver explains why he thinks that they won’t have a choice. Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein
0:51

“He doesn’t even have to look at them” If Reform UK and the Scottish Conservatives have a chance to elect Labour’s Anas Sarwar as First Minister, will they do so? Andy Maciver explains why he thinks that they won’t have a choice. Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein

Holyrood Sources

17,273 Aufrufe • vor 3 Monaten

“You don’t just get a referendum - you have to earn the right to one.” Lord Offord argues Scotland should prove it can deliver growth and good government before another independence vote. Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver | Geoff Aberdein
2:48

“You don’t just get a referendum - you have to earn the right to one.” Lord Offord argues Scotland should prove it can deliver growth and good government before another independence vote. Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver | Geoff Aberdein

Holyrood Sources

193,860 Aufrufe • vor 11 Monaten

“It’s crazy, I've been covering this all year and it's not going to go away.” Rebecca McCurdy explains the significance of the Sandie Peggie case… Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver | Geoff Aberdein
0:59

“It’s crazy, I've been covering this all year and it's not going to go away.” Rebecca McCurdy explains the significance of the Sandie Peggie case… Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver | Geoff Aberdein

Holyrood Sources

10,383 Aufrufe • vor 8 Monaten

NEW: Live on our podcast, John Swinney reverses the SNP's position on oil and gas. He says the war in the Middle East "changes the balance of the arguments". Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein | Andy Maciver
3:58

NEW: Live on our podcast, John Swinney reverses the SNP's position on oil and gas. He says the war in the Middle East "changes the balance of the arguments". Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein | Andy Maciver

Holyrood Sources

37,247 Aufrufe • vor 4 Monaten

"Scottish independence is inevitable." James Hawes tells us the UK is "finished" in the next 10, 20 or 30 years. Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver | Geoff Aberdein
1:02

"Scottish independence is inevitable." James Hawes tells us the UK is "finished" in the next 10, 20 or 30 years. Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver | Geoff Aberdein

Holyrood Sources

40,192 Aufrufe • vor 1 Jahr

🆕EXCLUSIVE: Anas Sarwar and Jackie Baillie say they support nurse Sandie Peggie. The Scottish Labour leader tells us: "Knowing what we know now, we would not have supported the [Gender Recognition Reform] bill." Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver | Geoff Aberdein
4:31

🆕EXCLUSIVE: Anas Sarwar and Jackie Baillie say they support nurse Sandie Peggie. The Scottish Labour leader tells us: "Knowing what we know now, we would not have supported the [Gender Recognition Reform] bill." Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver | Geoff Aberdein

Holyrood Sources

831,311 Aufrufe • vor 1 Jahr

"You have to start to ask questions about the voluntary nature of the union." Andy Maciver on what could happen if John Swinney were to win a majority next year... Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein
1:59

"You have to start to ask questions about the voluntary nature of the union." Andy Maciver on what could happen if John Swinney were to win a majority next year... Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein

Holyrood Sources

16,226 Aufrufe • vor 10 Monaten

"Nicola Sturgeon had a very clear opinion of the opponents of the Gender Recognition Act... Do you agree with her assessment?" John Swinney says he wants to create: "respectful debate in Scotland." He tell us knowing then what he knows now, he still would have backed the Gender Recognition Reform Bill. Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein | Andy Maciver
2:07

"Nicola Sturgeon had a very clear opinion of the opponents of the Gender Recognition Act... Do you agree with her assessment?" John Swinney says he wants to create: "respectful debate in Scotland." He tell us knowing then what he knows now, he still would have backed the Gender Recognition Reform Bill. Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein | Andy Maciver

Holyrood Sources

45,047 Aufrufe • vor 1 Jahr

"A plague on all your houses." Geoff Aberdein reacts to news of the closure at Mossmorran. "We are getting things wrong. The transition is not being taken place in the managed and just fashion that was promised." "We need our politicians to wake up." Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver
4:29

"A plague on all your houses." Geoff Aberdein reacts to news of the closure at Mossmorran. "We are getting things wrong. The transition is not being taken place in the managed and just fashion that was promised." "We need our politicians to wake up." Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver

Holyrood Sources

22,750 Aufrufe • vor 9 Monaten

"By their own metric, there is no windfall." "If the oil and gas industry was on the banks of the River Thames as opposed to the banks of the River Dee would we be having this conversation?" "You can't win an election with a backdrop of deindustrialisation and mass unemployment." Geoff Aberdein on the continuation of the energy windfall tax. Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver
4:50

"By their own metric, there is no windfall." "If the oil and gas industry was on the banks of the River Thames as opposed to the banks of the River Dee would we be having this conversation?" "You can't win an election with a backdrop of deindustrialisation and mass unemployment." Geoff Aberdein on the continuation of the energy windfall tax. Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver

Holyrood Sources

13,042 Aufrufe • vor 8 Monaten

"Do you think any less of Anas Sarwar for taking a seat in the House of Lords" Paul Sweeney MSP is challenged over the Scottish Labour leader's decision to join Andy Burnham's government in London. Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein | Andy Maciver
1:06

"Do you think any less of Anas Sarwar for taking a seat in the House of Lords" Paul Sweeney MSP is challenged over the Scottish Labour leader's decision to join Andy Burnham's government in London. Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein | Andy Maciver

Holyrood Sources

12,098 Aufrufe • vor 26 Tagen

"We were knocking our pans in, to win elections, to get to the referendum and you're on the take..." Geoff Aberdein says: "I can understand the sheer sense of betrayal amongst the members," of the SNP after Peter Murrell pleaded guilty to embezzling £400,000 from the party. Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver
2:49

"We were knocking our pans in, to win elections, to get to the referendum and you're on the take..." Geoff Aberdein says: "I can understand the sheer sense of betrayal amongst the members," of the SNP after Peter Murrell pleaded guilty to embezzling £400,000 from the party. Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver

Holyrood Sources

18,139 Aufrufe • vor 2 Monaten

The Scottish Government has just lost £22 million! Were they foolish, gamblers, cynics or delusional when implementing a new top income tax rate of 48%? Dan Neidle, founder of Tax Policy Associates, explains his four theories as to what the government might have been thinking. Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein | Andy Maciver
1:16

The Scottish Government has just lost £22 million! Were they foolish, gamblers, cynics or delusional when implementing a new top income tax rate of 48%? Dan Neidle, founder of Tax Policy Associates, explains his four theories as to what the government might have been thinking. Calum Macdonald | Geoff Aberdein | Andy Maciver

Holyrood Sources

15,016 Aufrufe • vor 19 Tagen

"John Swinney could have leaned into this and come out with more credibility, had he acted decisively." Geoff Aberdein breaks down how the SNP leader missed a chance to distance himself from the past and protect his leadership after the embezzlement scandal. "He's not convincing in some of his answers." Andy Maciver | Calum Macdonald
2:10

"John Swinney could have leaned into this and come out with more credibility, had he acted decisively." Geoff Aberdein breaks down how the SNP leader missed a chance to distance himself from the past and protect his leadership after the embezzlement scandal. "He's not convincing in some of his answers." Andy Maciver | Calum Macdonald

Holyrood Sources

17,150 Aufrufe • vor 2 Monaten

"2029 will be the breaking point," for the United Kingdom says James Hawes. "2029 will finally reveal, particularly to the Scots, that this narrative that voting Labour can protect you from a red-blooded Tory England is no longer valid... The SNP will bounce back very strongly under new leadership." Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver | Geoff Aberdein
2:35

"2029 will be the breaking point," for the United Kingdom says James Hawes. "2029 will finally reveal, particularly to the Scots, that this narrative that voting Labour can protect you from a red-blooded Tory England is no longer valid... The SNP will bounce back very strongly under new leadership." Calum Macdonald | Andy Maciver | Geoff Aberdein

Holyrood Sources

22,093 Aufrufe • vor 1 Jahr

“No self-awareness, no loyalty and no class” Geoff Aberdein and Andy Maciver reacts to Nicola Sturgeon’s criticism of the SNP election campaign. This could be a "transformative moment" for John Swinney... Andy suggests that loyalty to Sturgeon and the previous administration are "holding the country back."
3:13

“No self-awareness, no loyalty and no class” Geoff Aberdein and Andy Maciver reacts to Nicola Sturgeon’s criticism of the SNP election campaign. This could be a "transformative moment" for John Swinney... Andy suggests that loyalty to Sturgeon and the previous administration are "holding the country back."

Holyrood Sources

167,678 Aufrufe • vor 12 Tagen