Skip navigation
don't let them fool ya with video game assets!
0:00 / 0:35

don't let them fool ya with video game assets!

Matt Ferraro

@mferraro893K followers

Visit on X
301 likesDownloadOriginal post

18,445 views

don't let them fool ya with video game assets! Working feature tree, working assembly, 100% AI generated! Text-to-CAD is not the hard part and it is not the interesting part!

20 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Matt Ferraro's profile picture

    @mferraro89

    Early access signup here:

    16 likes

  • Jern's profile picture

    @Jern123d

    I would argue that text-to-CAD is actually very hard. It is a fundamentally bad idea because a two sentence prompt is completely inadequate to describe a CAD design of almost any non-trivial complexity. Text-to-CAD creates instant garbage

    7 likes

  • Matt Ferraro's profile picture

    @mferraro89

    I think we are saying the same thing but differently! Text to cad is garbage unless you have powerful ways to validate that the parts are actually manufacturable and performant, which we believe is mostly an simulation and FEA problem!

    10 likes

  • Brian Ratliff's profile picture

    @BrierRat

    It's not validation, in my experience. It's communication which is the problem. Mechanical design is a much higher dimensional space than most coding applications. For instance, take the napkin sketch and the associated model below. How many dimensions are required to fully define this shape, even given drafting conventions such as "lines appearing straight are straight"? And this is just simple throwaway test model geometry with ~8 features.

    4 likes

  • Matt Ferraro's profile picture

    @mferraro89

    @Jern123d exactly! that's why we built our system as a really good CAD program first. If you need a specific dimension set, it's faster to just go in and set it than to ask an AI to do it. But if you need to change all your countersunk screw holes to counterbored, that's a job for AI

    5 likes

  • Andres's profile picture

    @AndresMilioto

    dark mode + some real bike rpms

    5 likes

  • Matt Ferraro's profile picture

    @mferraro89

    Engine you gotta stop. You smoke too tough. You spin too fast. They'll kill you

    4 likes

  • MilkDromeda's profile picture

    @dromeda_mi1208

    I have investigated AI to CAD for a period of time, I think model tree is not needed for AI parametric design, and it is also the most significant difference between AI CAD modeling and human design, if we think deeply through it. but still excited to see this browser platform.

    2 likes

  • Space Colonize's profile picture

    @Spacecolonize

    Text to additive manufacturer is coming too

    2 likes

  • Matt Ferraro's profile picture

    @mferraro89

    can't wait!

    1 like

  • Jake Dahn's profile picture

    @jakedahn

    Oh em gee, I can almost hear it

    2 likes

  • Connor Kapoor's profile picture

    @connorkapoor

    Looking good! Did you guys reset accounts?

    1 like

  • Matt Ferraro's profile picture

    @mferraro89

    Yes we reset accounts, I’ll get you sorted here in a few mins!

    2 likes

  • SC Maker Space's profile picture

    @DominicVrolijks

    Makes me think I should sell my CAD library as training data. 32k files at last count.

    1 like

  • Carl Lumma's profile picture

    @clumma

    What geometric modeling kernel are you using? And does it run on a sever or in the browser?

  • Matt Ferraro's profile picture

    @mferraro89

    It’s parasolid under the hood, so it runs on a server. The client gets a brep and mesh, so the browser is doing the actual render work!

    2 likes

  • Chizzydigital's profile picture

    @Chizzydigital

    This one is more impressive

  • Alex's profile picture

    @abenz95

    what's the hard part then? tolerance stack-up validation? or getting the assembly to actually survive a physics sim?

  • Maicon Lourenço's profile picture

    @maiconloure

    Awesome motion!

  • Daniel Owsianski's profile picture

    @dannyow

    I wrote my own browser viewer for OpenSCAD because reviewing the result was the bottleneck, never producing it. Whether the part is actually right I learn 3 hours later at the printer. What do you give people to check an AI assembly before that point?