Don't think it gets much closer than this

Safe. Ball was still moving in bis glove when the foot was on

Clearly safe when you look at slow motion. Ball didn’t reach the back of the glove before runner’s foot hit the bag.

Tie goes to the runner.

Tie goes to the runner. But this is not a tie, it is clearly safe.

I always thought a tie goes to the runner.. was I lied to my entire childhood?

Yes. But under the new interpretation of ball in back of glove: safe.

Foot hits before the glove closes around the ball.

Tie goes to the runner. He’s safe.

Without replay he would be out

Agreed. But safe. Can see the entire ball, which means it’s not completely in his glove yet.