Video yükleniyor...
Video Yüklenemedi
Even for a strong script like PS, Mani didn't get "songs for situations". #Ilaiyaraaja, MSV etc didn't work to make a "super-hit album", but within limits of story, situations & characters..yet churned out super hits ! That discomfort on the face of #ARR when Mani reveals it 😂
83,917 görüntüleme • 6 gün önce •via X (Twitter)
38 Yorum

Looks like he is hanging on to Rahman only because he cannot go back to Raja. Vairagiyathoda velila vandhutom ippo epdi pordhunu. Vairamuthuva thavirthu avaru ellaraiyum ulla sepparu

Exactly

Even on KB's issue IR expected KB should have come directly instead of sending Rajini for compromise who was nowhere involved in the whole controversy.For whatever KB did to IR,IR would have still let things go if only KB directly reached out to IR.

Manirathnam should have chosen Raja atleast for PS. It needs Tamil flavour. It needs Saivism flavour. It needs originality and nativity. Raja would have given a grand elevation to this grand epic and literature of the Tamil land. Marketing gimmicks could not save Manirathnam.

There is a story that Illayaraja was dropped from Roja because of an argument about a situational song which Mani was not happy with. Raja allegedly told Mani to change the situation to suit his song and that was the breaking point between them.

Rubbish...Raaja was never approached for Roja.

@nmadankumar How do you knew that he was not approached ?

@Rajaram93584674 @nmadankumar Roja is Kavithalaya movie KB & IR had bit of misunderstandings after pudhu pudhu arthangal so after that they didn't work together. If KB is producer how can Mani approach IR for Music ??

@Rajaram93584674 @nmadankumar We are only speculating what is told via news.

@Rajaram93584674 @nmadankumar ARR has told recently ManiRatnam approached him only for Thiruda Thiruda , before he revealing are you aware about this ?

@TweetbySRG @nmadankumar Mani had plans ready for Thiruda Thiruda before Roja..But Roja happened first. Roja was done for KB and Mani postponed TT for that.

I saw his interview where without any hesitation he said that he cares less about lyrics. can't find it now It's a huge downgrade, Raja fought temptation of reproducing same popular song in Tamil because dialogue demanded different

These two jokers have no clue of Ponniyin Selvan. Music should fit the time signature because it is a period film. Movies like Brave Heart, Gladiator and etc in the Hollywood had periodic Music to uplift or hold the screenplay.

You saw Rahman’s face in a clip on your நாலணா phone and decided you knew what he felt. The arrogance of morons who pass judgment on people who’ve actually achieved something is appalling. Social media has created these half-boils.

It's a sin to compare him with Ilayaraja and MSV.... They were different at a level. They can churn out tunes one after the other like sea waves, no stopping....

MSV is Emperor Illayaraja is King of kings This kid is not that class As simple as that

ARR lost touch since 2012... His music faded...From 5/5 chartbusters in a single movie... To not one worthful song today... Thug life ended his movie career.. except Alai payuthe...MR movies are all shitty ... Only IR and ARR music and BGM helped them to work..

Seruppu Vangitu Kaala vettikalam edhammal oru matterah

I think Mani would be regretting forever for having disputes with IR during Thalapathy movie.

Another day of Raja fans whining over ARR song choices, while Raja himself survived on same old tunes for years. Ultimately, Mani had to move past him because of his repetitive work. PS will remain a benchmark, a deeply imaginative work that Raja can only dream of.

lol 😂

Mani to #ARR : Give me something..I will find a situation to fit it... #ARR to Ranjit Barot / Sukhwinder: Give me something..I will give it to Mani... 🤣😂😅🤣😂

How it starts: Maapillaiku kudikku oru sombu thanni kondu vaa How it ends: Maapillai sombu irundha dhan thaali kattuvenu soldrar

பாவம் பா மணி...

பாய் கூட சேர்ந்த அப்புறம்தான், மணி சார் bgm ல work பன்ன எல்லாம் கத்துகிட்டாரு. ராஜா கூடவே இருந்திருந்தா இதெல்லாம் பன்னிருக்க முடியுமா?

இன்னொரு video இருக்கு.. Shortly...

Both legends are devoid of ideas! 😭

Quite a shocking admission

Pathetic music director imho

’s craft is brilliant as always, but his style didn’t quite fit the world of #PonniyinSelvan. Mani Ratnam should have approached @ilaiyaraaja—Maestro’s music would have transported us straight into the Chola era with our eyes closed. #PS1 #PS2 Maestro will make our soul to feel the era.

Beautiful - BR 😂

Btw are they discussing abt பொன்னியின் செல்வன் or braveheart? தமிழ்லயே பேசலாமே..

Paaja fans pls don’t be retarded😭😭

PS strong script nu solrathe thappu

ARR won a national award for this BGM in PS. Cope more Raja fans.

Please take Ilayaraja for comparison with ARR. Not MSV. G.Ramanthan,MSV, KVM are different brand of heavenly creators with many bench mark indices like kappolittiya thamizhan, Ambigapathy, Karnan, Mannathi mannan திருவிளையாடல் ,Thillana mohanaambal to name a few...

What happened between IR n mani

WHEN ILAYARAJA on his peak he said no to many but particularly KB , Vairamuthu,bharathiraja & mani Only Vairamuthu spoke against him also he praised him in many occasions! KB and bharathiraja later got frndly with him Mani always praise him I would say it's a creative choice

