正在加载视频...

视频加载失败

加载此视频时出现问题。这可能是由于临时网络问题，或视频可能不可用。

Excellent stuff here. Sam Harris explains why getting into a debate about the history of the Middle East can be a fools errand if what you're trying to achieve is clarification about the morality of the most recent war in Gaza. Transcript below. Making Sense Podcast

Brett Hall

39,044 subscribers

25,378 次观看 • 2 个月前 •via X (Twitter)

Anya Rossi• Live Now

Private livecam show

0 条评论

暂无评论

原始帖子的评论将显示在这里

相关视频

"If we take history as a guide, the negotiations are always a fakeout" If war in Iran is about to be over, then why is Trump deploying our troops to the Middle East?

"If we take history as a guide, the negotiations are always a fakeout" If war in Iran is about to be over, then why is Trump deploying our troops to the Middle East?

Fuentes Updates

28,759 次观看 • 4 个月前

We have the best information technology in history – so why can’t we have a reasonable conversation anymore? From a discussion on Making Sense Podcast with Sam Harris about communication, free speech, institutional distrust, and the future of social order. Watch here: #Communication #Information

We have the best information technology in history – so why can’t we have a reasonable conversation anymore? From a discussion on Making Sense Podcast with Sam Harris about communication, free speech, institutional distrust, and the future of social order. Watch here: #Communication #Information

Yuval Noah Harari

24,649 次观看 • 1 年前

Bonnie, who is Palestinian, opens up about the war in the Middle East after the attack on Iran and explains why she rarely talks about it "I feel survivors guilt all the time, so I don't talk about things.. Half of my family lives in the Middle East and I don't know what to do"

Bonnie, who is Palestinian, opens up about the war in the Middle East after the attack on Iran and explains why she rarely talks about it "I feel survivors guilt all the time, so I don't talk about things.. Half of my family lives in the Middle East and I don't know what to do"

bloom 𖧧

1,073,292 次观看 • 5 个月前

“No exit plan, no objective, and no idea of what to do if the risks continue to escalate” Former Pentagon Middle East Adviser Jasmine El-Gamal explains why she is concerned about escalating conflict in the Middle East #Peston

“No exit plan, no objective, and no idea of what to do if the risks continue to escalate” Former Pentagon Middle East Adviser Jasmine El-Gamal explains why she is concerned about escalating conflict in the Middle East #Peston

Peston

15,971 次观看 • 5 个月前

KARL: What do you say to Trump supporters who are worried that the US is involved in yet another war in the Middle East? JD VANCE: We are not interested in protracted conflicts in the Middle East, but there's a question about how do you achieve peace, and we believe the way you achieve peace is through strength (He's getting close to saying "war is peace" ... )

KARL: What do you say to Trump supporters who are worried that the US is involved in yet another war in the Middle East? JD VANCE: We are not interested in protracted conflicts in the Middle East, but there's a question about how do you achieve peace, and we believe the way you achieve peace is through strength (He's getting close to saying "war is peace" ... )

Aaron Rupar

149,447 次观看 • 1 年前

“You don’t have to debate the history of the Middle East to resolve the conflict there.” Sam Harris on why he believes the real issue isn’t ancient grievance, but present-day values, intentions, and ideology.

“You don’t have to debate the history of the Middle East to resolve the conflict there.” Sam Harris on why he believes the real issue isn’t ancient grievance, but present-day values, intentions, and ideology.

Making Sense Podcast

14,866 次观看 • 2 个月前

MATT GAETZ REACTS TO BENJAMIN NETANYAHU’S RECENT STATEMENT: “THAT WAS ISRAELI P.M. BENJAMIN NETANYAHU LECTURING US ABOUT NEEDING TO LEARN THE LESSONS OF HISTORY, WHILE AT THE SAME TIME, INVITING THE UNITED STATES INTO A REGIME CHANGE MIDDLE EAST WAR…”

MATT GAETZ REACTS TO BENJAMIN NETANYAHU’S RECENT STATEMENT: “THAT WAS ISRAELI P.M. BENJAMIN NETANYAHU LECTURING US ABOUT NEEDING TO LEARN THE LESSONS OF HISTORY, WHILE AT THE SAME TIME, INVITING THE UNITED STATES INTO A REGIME CHANGE MIDDLE EAST WAR…”

One America News

1,274,682 次观看 • 1 年前

Jake Sullivan on Iran: The United States is at war with Iran in the middle of an active shooting war that, in my view, was a war of choice. It did not stem from an imminent threat to the United States. We have yet to hear a clear and distinctive answer to the question: Why? What is this all about and what are we trying to achieve?

Jake Sullivan on Iran: The United States is at war with Iran in the middle of an active shooting war that, in my view, was a war of choice. It did not stem from an imminent threat to the United States. We have yet to hear a clear and distinctive answer to the question: Why? What is this all about and what are we trying to achieve?

Clash Report

17,487 次观看 • 3 个月前

"It's obvious the reason why Sam Harris doesn't want to get into the history of it is because that might be kind of humanizing toward the other side, and clearly what he's in business of doing is dehumanizing them. And that's the whole game." Dave Smith and Robbie Bernstein dismantle Sam Harris' ridiculous "Why I Won’t Debate Critics of Israel" article on Substack.

"It's obvious the reason why Sam Harris doesn't want to get into the history of it is because that might be kind of humanizing toward the other side, and clearly what he's in business of doing is dehumanizing them. And that's the whole game." Dave Smith and Robbie Bernstein dismantle Sam Harris' ridiculous "Why I Won’t Debate Critics of Israel" article on Substack.

Captain Ⓐncapistan

61,140 次观看 • 2 个月前

Is the Trump Administration trying to make us forget about the history of the the United States’ wars in Afghanistan and Iraq? Our columnist Jay Caspian Kang talks about America’s history of spinning its conflicts with the Middle East—and why the Trump Administration isn’t even bothering to justify the U.S.’s latest incursion into the region. Read his latest column:

Is the Trump Administration trying to make us forget about the history of the the United States’ wars in Afghanistan and Iraq? Our columnist Jay Caspian Kang talks about America’s history of spinning its conflicts with the Middle East—and why the Trump Administration isn’t even bothering to justify the U.S.’s latest incursion into the region. Read his latest column:

The New Yorker

27,194 次观看 • 5 个月前

100% there is no genocide in Gaza. No eradication project. People confused about what the word means is culturally appalling and dangerous for the future of western society. The confusion has indeed been engineered by people know what they are doing. No genocide does not mean simply too much death and destruction in war. It is about intent and action to destroy a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group, in whole or in part. Sam Harris Making Sense Podcast is spot on.

100% there is no genocide in Gaza. No eradication project. People confused about what the word means is culturally appalling and dangerous for the future of western society. The confusion has indeed been engineered by people know what they are doing. No genocide does not mean simply too much death and destruction in war. It is about intent and action to destroy a national, ethnic, racial, or religious group, in whole or in part. Sam Harris Making Sense Podcast is spot on.

John Spencer

268,251 次观看 • 2 个月前

"When 9/11 happened, what were we doing in the Middle East? Nothing." My goodness, this Ben Ferguson clown is completely ignorant about the history of US foreign policy and can only try to debate Dave Smith via filibuster. What a shit show.

"When 9/11 happened, what were we doing in the Middle East? Nothing." My goodness, this Ben Ferguson clown is completely ignorant about the history of US foreign policy and can only try to debate Dave Smith via filibuster. What a shit show.

Captain Ⓐncapistan

154,178 次观看 • 4 个月前

🚨What if the biggest assumption about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is wrong? ד״ר עינת וילף Dr. Einat Wilf joins Dave Rubin for a deep dive into the history of Palestinian rejection of statehood proposals, the aftermath of October 7th, the anti-Israel movement, and the future of peace in the Middle East. WATCH HERE:

🚨What if the biggest assumption about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is wrong? ד״ר עינת וילף Dr. Einat Wilf joins Dave Rubin for a deep dive into the history of Palestinian rejection of statehood proposals, the aftermath of October 7th, the anti-Israel movement, and the future of peace in the Middle East. WATCH HERE:

The Rubin Report

92,772 次观看 • 2 个月前

BREAKING: Trump released video of the Kharg Island attack, which he claims was the “most powerful bombing raid in the history of the Middle East”. It shows what appears to be attacks on a civilian airport used to transport oil workers, attacks on empty fields and nothing remotely close to the “most powerful bombing raid in the history of the Middle East.”

BREAKING: Trump released video of the Kharg Island attack, which he claims was the “most powerful bombing raid in the history of the Middle East”. It shows what appears to be attacks on a civilian airport used to transport oil workers, attacks on empty fields and nothing remotely close to the “most powerful bombing raid in the history of the Middle East.”

Brian Krassenstein

193,670 次观看 • 5 个月前

Sick of hearing about "anti-Semitism"? Say hello to "Zionophobia." "Zionophobia is simply irrational, obsessive resistance to the idea of Jewish self-rule anywhere in the Middle East," Judea Pearl tells Sam Harris.

Sick of hearing about "anti-Semitism"? Say hello to "Zionophobia." "Zionophobia is simply irrational, obsessive resistance to the idea of Jewish self-rule anywhere in the Middle East," Judea Pearl tells Sam Harris.

Chris Menahan 🇺🇸

62,111 次观看 • 7 个月前

Pope Leo XIV responded to questions about peace negotiations in the Middle East in light of the ongoing G7 taking place in France. He expressed hope that the recent memorandum "truly will be a solution, that the war will genuinely be over and that we can move forward for the good of everyone."

Pope Leo XIV responded to questions about peace negotiations in the Middle East in light of the ongoing G7 taking place in France. He expressed hope that the recent memorandum "truly will be a solution, that the war will genuinely be over and that we can move forward for the good of everyone."

Vatican News

20,840 次观看 • 2 个月前

Tillis: “Secretary Hegseth is the leader of arguably the most complex, consequential organization in the history of mankind. Making a bad mistake can start a war. Making a bad mistake can get American military personnel killed. You've got to be tight on your execution. And you need to be tight on documenting every decision that could be subject to a question about whether or not the law of war and the law of the sea were followed. It's a legitimate question.”

Tillis: “Secretary Hegseth is the leader of arguably the most complex, consequential organization in the history of mankind. Making a bad mistake can start a war. Making a bad mistake can get American military personnel killed. You've got to be tight on your execution. And you need to be tight on documenting every decision that could be subject to a question about whether or not the law of war and the law of the sea were followed. It's a legitimate question.”

Kaitlan Collins

158,138 次观看 • 8 个月前

In this episode of In Focus podcast, Stanly Johny speaks to Sharmada about the details of Trump’s #Gaza peace plan, what it promises to achieve, and whether it can truly bring a lasting #ceasefire.

In this episode of In Focus podcast, Stanly Johny speaks to Sharmada about the details of Trump’s #Gaza peace plan, what it promises to achieve, and whether it can truly bring a lasting #ceasefire.

The Hindu

15,877 次观看 • 10 个月前