Skip navigation
Explaining the problems of Nathan Cofnas' strategy (to Nathan Cofnas).
0:00 / 31:51

Explaining the problems of Nathan Cofnas' strategy (to Nathan Cofnas).

Dave Greene

@GreeneMan632K followers

Visit on X
409 likesDownloadOriginal post

23,528 views

Explaining the problems of Nathan Cofnas' strategy (to Nathan Cofnas).

41 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • William M Briggs - Statistician to the Stars!'s profile picture

    @FamedCelebrity

    Now I listened to all of this, and I did not hear anywhere what our little buddy's plan is, except to expose them to race realism. They are exposed every day in life. But they chose a different and unfalisifiable cause for those differences ("racism"). How do you disabuse them of this moral position? Equality is deeper than race differences. I'm a gen Xer, and it is of course impossible for me to find any university employment. How do I, and my fellows, retake the hill?

    31 likes

  • Dave Greene's profile picture

    @GreeneMan6

    I have no idea what the plan could be.

    17 likes

  • William M Briggs - Statistician to the Stars!'s profile picture

    @FamedCelebrity

    I have some ideas about how to restore universities. More soon.

    7 likes

  • UBERSOY's profile picture

    @UBERSOY1

    Nathan Cofnas won that debate

    17 likes

  • Dave Greene's profile picture

    @GreeneMan6

    Our chief conflict was his refusal to admit that lies were more epistemically damaging than errors. I can absolutely prove this proposition in the general case.

    37 likes

  • UBERSOY's profile picture

    @UBERSOY1

    I’d love to read that article given I basically agree with your premise. But I think Cofnas’ strategy can work on the elite level (where reality is generated) while yours is basically true on the managerial level (where morality/power is being generated)

    4 likes

  • Dave Greene's profile picture

    @GreeneMan6

    Cofnas did not present a coherent plan in our two hour discussion. Even in this clip, he can’t keep his story straight. First he says that it’s his mission to save the universities . Then he says they are a lost cost. Then he says we need to build in parallel, but Cofnas did not spend his time building in parallel but rather trying to take out academic frauds inside the system, something you WOULDNT be doing if your plan was to build an alternative.

    15 likes

  • UBERSOY's profile picture

    @UBERSOY1

    The plan has been published online

    3 likes

  • Joseph de Maistre on X's profile picture

    @FMClausewitz

    People in academia have a hard time coming to terms with it, for all the reasons one would expect. Maybe now he will be free to reflect.

    12 likes

  • Brainwright's profile picture

    @jaggerode

    I can’t feel any sympathy for him. You gave him plenty of warning. See, Cofnas thinks the universities are wrong like he could be. But they are corrupt.

    11 likes

  • Harken ⚜️'s profile picture

    @Toads411

    This was a frustrating discussion when it was live

    6 likes

  • Rasmus Munch Søndergaard's profile picture

    @Rasmus_MunchS

    Your points are interesting, but you are insufferably impolite.

    6 likes

  • Dave Greene's profile picture

    @GreeneMan6

    this is the last 30 minutes of a two hour dialogue where cofnas was dragging his heels on basic facts.

    24 likes

  • Rasmus Munch Søndergaard's profile picture

    @Rasmus_MunchS

    You continue to proffer insults which merely proves my point.

    3 likes

  • Rasmus Munch Søndergaard's profile picture

    @Rasmus_MunchS

    @GreeneMan6 Poor savage.

  • calling in the wilderness's profile picture

    @wolajacy

    Cofnas is obviously right. Postulating some idiotic schemes and circling again and again to the obsession with Fauci gave me second hand embarrassment

    4 likes

  • Oskar Holmberg's profile picture

    @Ramblemoe

    Cofnas strikes me as the kind of autist that doesn't understand people or the social world. The first 40 seconds of this clip is all anyone needs to watch.

    4 likes

  • Otto Grey's profile picture

    @ottothegrey

    Weak men will walk all the way up to the solution and then pretend they can no longer see the path and turn around.

    3 likes

  • Jalen Horm 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿's profile picture

    @mootfolk

    When you referenced Steven Pinker was you aware of his relationship with Cofnas? He's a reference on his CV.

    3 likes

  • Matthew Braham's profile picture

    @MatthewBraham1

    Here is Cofnas's position. A's disadvantage is explained by natural property P rather than by B's conduct. Therefore B's conduct is not the wrong, and remedies addressed to B's conduct are misdirected. Any decent philosopher can see this collapses.

    3 likes