Fred Donner's view on Hadiths and Hadith sciences

He didn’t actually say anything of substance. It’s just typical kafir not wanting to accept any science from the Muslims. Alhamdulilah our tradition and its maintainers are sound.

its crazy how lazy these “intellectuals” are when it comes to hadith science. the amount of ppl that would be implicated in a majority of sahih bukhari and sahih muslim being fabricated is ridiculous…and bukhari was persecuted by the rulers in the first place

The guy is all over the place just by this clip alone I have not used it in my work and there maybe Hadith that are authentic. That is an issue alone

Did a smurf wipe his head?

His best evidence against it is the Prophet predicting things 200 years after? There’s things 700 years after and even 1000 years predicted in the future 😂 so who fabricated those when it was written before it happened.

Why are you so enamoured by these idiots with their dumb takes??

why the heck does he have blue hair??

pls share the full video link, thanks

Thankyou

So he’s saying Salafi methodology is false because there’s no way the Prophet ﷺ made any prophecies 🤣 That’s like saying I don’t think pizza is food because there’s no way food is round 🍕

Asfaras I know FazlurRahman states that theProphet might have issued similar warnings for the future—drawing inspiration from the fates of past nations mentioned in the Quran—but that narrations providing specific details about the future,such as names,locations,are fabrications.

This guy transgender?

No, but that isn't bad tho at least not in shia islam

@murica1stmuslim More interesting question is was Ibn Taymiyya, Magneto of islam since he was traumatized & became radical.

@murica1stmuslim Great 😊👍 Sunnah follower for sure Ibn Taymiyyah says there were two opinions: later scholars rejected the Satanic Verses reports as unreliable, while the early Muslims (al-salaf) accepted them as authentic.

@murica1stmuslim Use Google Translate in the search bar of Google by uploading the image or sny Ai u use

ماذا قال ؟ لم أسمع إلا كلمات رجل لا يعلم شيئا عن الحديث و علومه. أمت الباطل بالسكوت عنه، و ليس بنشره.

I’m sorry, are we rlly taking the opinion of a man with blue hair

I don’t understand why we as Muslims are getting upset at what he’s saying. He has a true interest in studying Islam using a secular approach, and he’s being respectful.

yes, prophet's could never prophesize.

“No method for deciding whether it’s authentic hadith or not” yeah this guy doesn’t know shit

Uneducated muslims in the comments who dont even know what he means

Hearsay is NOT science!

Funny they use more lenient sometimes made up sources, testimony etc to push their version of events. Clear jealously !

lol “we know Hadith fabricated because the thing being predicted in the Hadith came true hundred of years later” lolllll Just say shahdah Fred. So many Hadith predicting what we are seeing now. Also no comment on mutawatir Hadith.