Skip navigation
🗣️ 'From a getting decisions right perspective, VAR is absolutely working… The bit I have some…
0:00 / 1:35

🗣️ 'From a getting decisions right perspective, VAR is absolutely working… The bit I have some…

BBC Sport Scotland

@BBCSportScot199K followers

Visit on X
15 likesDownloadOriginal post

55,384 views #BBCFootball

🗣️ 'From a getting decisions right perspective, VAR is absolutely working… The bit I have some agreement with is about stadium atmosphere and how we improve that' SFA chief executive Ian Maxwell on VAR ⚽️ Listen to Sportsound on BBC Radio Scotland & BBC Sounds. #BBCFootball

11 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Daz Sutherland's profile picture

    @Dazzy_deff

    An app on your phone updating? I've nae had a phone signal at pittodrie during a game for about 20 years. So good luck with that.

    14 likes

  • mark mcfadden's profile picture

    @mark265987

    Try telling st mirren that ya bampot. It's absolutely crap.

    8 likes

  • Fraser Elgin's profile picture

    @Fraser1874

    Over 30 errors according to the review panel. With the chance to revisit every key decision, you could argue that there should be zero errors. So very much not working

    7 likes

  • Duke's profile picture

    @Mckdukester

    Anyone who says VAR in Scotland is "absolutely working" is either an idiot or a liar... I'll let you choose Ian..............

    6 likes

  • CraigMcD's profile picture

    @c_mcdonald3

    Are they in the real world? Whether or not VAR technology is working is one thing…..it’s just being used by completely incompetent and inconsistent officials….why can’t they admit it and demonstrate what’s being done to address such incompetence

    5 likes

  • David_Davy_Dave's profile picture

    @David_Davy_Dave

    Stone wall pen in LC final not given Diomande red card v Utd rescinded Raskin phantom goal v Hibs As a Rangers fan I must say if that’s VAR working then let’s just be honest and say decision making in this country is hopelessly & utterly corrupted

    4 likes

  • Matt 🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🟥⬜🟦's profile picture

    @uberhonda

    This clown is living on another planet. Missing guys punching the ball out in the box. Disallows Celtic goal when no way to know ball was out. Non award of a clear penalty in LC final. No goal in Hibs Rangers when a yard over the line. Numerous fuck ups from Walsh.

    4 likes

  • cameron's profile picture

    @CammyStewart20

    Is he on drugs? Decisions are just as bad with VAR than they were without. The problem isnt the technology. The problem is the incompetant referees your put in charge of using the technology

    3 likes

  • CallMeBayGirl's profile picture

    @CallMeBayGirl

    It's working for some. Dundee Utd basically qualified for Europe over St Mirren thanks to the number of wrong decisions Saints had topping that stat for the second season running. A few officials are simply at it but many more could do with unconscious bias training.

    3 likes

  • James Morrison's profile picture

    @troonlegal

    Two names he wouldn’t mention: Nick Walsh : Matthew McDiarmid At least he acknowledged the in stadium experience with VAR needs to change!

    2 likes

  • Soccer Bot™'s profile picture

    @soccerbottm

    Are you the best football expert? ⚽️🏆 Find out now with our brand new match prediction and climb up the leaderboard and compare yourself with friends.

    3,735 likes