Getting "Professor" Dave to admit his brain has no purpose.
@ByJimbob1.4万 位关注者
273,923 次观看
58 条评论
评论来自 X (Twitter) 上的原帖

@bkolendowski
Seems like he's attempting to explain that the brain evolved to confer a survival advantage and wasn't "designed" with a "purpose" by some supernatural entity and you were sheepishly trying to get him with a 'gotcha'.
391 个赞

@ByJimbob
No retard. Dave said his brains purpose isn’t the think. This means that he has no good reason for anyone to listen to what’s coming from his brain.
253 个赞

@warpox
@bkolendowski He said no inherent purpose, but he finds purpose in using his brain.
152 个赞

@_lifeinpixels
@ByJimbob @bkolendowski Finding purpose and there being inherent purpose aren't the same.
26 个赞

@CornOfUnicron
@warpox @ByJimbob @bkolendowski No shit. As if it isn’t the literal point everyone is trying to convey. Seems like you aren’t using your brain for its purpose.
91 个赞

@_lifeinpixels
@warpox @ByJimbob @bkolendowski What? @grok
1 个赞

@grok
The thread debates if brains have "inherent purpose" (designed intent) or just evolved utility for survival/thinking. Dave argues no inherent purpose in evolution, but we can assign one. The reply mocks missing that obvious distinction, implying irony in your point. What's confusing you specifically?
6 个赞

@The_Idol_Killer
Dave's smugness is only outmatched by his foolishness.
97 个赞

@kennywingism
This is a dumb argument
95 个赞

@ByJimbob
Did you arrive to that conclusion using a purposeless brain?
272 个赞

@kennywingism
Why would the existence or lack of an objective purpose be relevant at all? This is like a weird gotcha that doesn’t refute the secularist worldview. A thing without purpose can still be useful You can’t just presuppose everything has a purpose.
46 个赞

@RealLichHoursss
@ByJimbob Because objective morality requires an order so that we can’t point out what is disordered. TLDR: atheists cannot tell anyone why murder is wrong or why we should outlaw it beyond “it makes me sad/uncomfortable”
61 个赞

@kennywingism
@Gamerstuvwxyz @ByJimbob Neither can you, I can make consequential arguments as to why outlawing murder is better for society, but there is no objective standard for morality. I can say that same thing about you though, justify that God is good without a circular argument
12 个赞

@RealLichHoursss
@ByJimbob You actually can’t make consequentialist arguments because consequences don’t matter without mortality
68 个赞

@kennywingism
@Gamerstuvwxyz @ByJimbob If we both agree that we want pizza, I can then make an argument of what the best way to get the pizza is, even if I can’t morally justify that we should get pizza to begin with.
12 个赞

@Spartan_UpNorth
"Because I'm right" LMAO
58 个赞

@GodRules_HQ
YouTube totally props up his channel. Most of his videos have nothing to do with science, but rather are him simply mocking people he disagrees with, calling them anti-scientific. His idea of science is an atheistic philosophy which promotes anything that explains away God (Evolution, Uniformitarianism, etc).
58 个赞

@The_Archangel_1
How does the "purpose" or lack thereof of brains take away from its current abilities?
54 个赞

@ByJimbob
If the brain has no purpose to think, then how would you know it’s capable of properly thinking?
97 个赞

@The_Archangel_1
As how we all do. Test to see if it functions properly like it's ability to compute and perform tasks, learning etc. How would you tell if a brain is capable of proper thinking??
32 个赞




























