正在加载视频...

视频加载失败

Getting "Professor" Dave to admit his brain has no purpose.

273,923 次观看 • 9 个月前 •via X (Twitter)

58 条评论

Bart 的头像
Bart9 个月前

Seems like he's attempting to explain that the brain evolved to confer a survival advantage and wasn't "designed" with a "purpose" by some supernatural entity and you were sheepishly trying to get him with a 'gotcha'.

Made by Jimbob 的头像
Made by Jimbob9 个月前

No retard. Dave said his brains purpose isn’t the think. This means that he has no good reason for anyone to listen to what’s coming from his brain.

warpox 的头像
warpox9 个月前

@bkolendowski He said no inherent purpose, but he finds purpose in using his brain.

Cogent 的头像
Cogent9 个月前

@ByJimbob @bkolendowski Finding purpose and there being inherent purpose aren't the same.

Not NFT | Unicron made me do it 的头像
Not NFT | Unicron made me do it9 个月前

@warpox @ByJimbob @bkolendowski No shit. As if it isn’t the literal point everyone is trying to convey. Seems like you aren’t using your brain for its purpose.

Cogent 的头像
Cogent9 个月前

@warpox @ByJimbob @bkolendowski What? @grok

Grok 的头像
Grok9 个月前

The thread debates if brains have "inherent purpose" (designed intent) or just evolved utility for survival/thinking. Dave argues no inherent purpose in evolution, but we can assign one. The reply mocks missing that obvious distinction, implying irony in your point. What's confusing you specifically?

Idol Killer 的头像
Idol Killer9 个月前

Dave's smugness is only outmatched by his foolishness.

Kenny 的头像
Kenny9 个月前

This is a dumb argument

Made by Jimbob 的头像
Made by Jimbob9 个月前

Did you arrive to that conclusion using a purposeless brain?

Kenny 的头像
Kenny9 个月前

Why would the existence or lack of an objective purpose be relevant at all? This is like a weird gotcha that doesn’t refute the secularist worldview. A thing without purpose can still be useful You can’t just presuppose everything has a purpose.

RealLichHours🇻🇦 的头像
RealLichHours🇻🇦9 个月前

@ByJimbob Because objective morality requires an order so that we can’t point out what is disordered. TLDR: atheists cannot tell anyone why murder is wrong or why we should outlaw it beyond “it makes me sad/uncomfortable”

Kenny 的头像
Kenny9 个月前

@Gamerstuvwxyz @ByJimbob Neither can you, I can make consequential arguments as to why outlawing murder is better for society, but there is no objective standard for morality. I can say that same thing about you though, justify that God is good without a circular argument

RealLichHours🇻🇦 的头像
RealLichHours🇻🇦9 个月前

@ByJimbob You actually can’t make consequentialist arguments because consequences don’t matter without mortality

Kenny 的头像
Kenny9 个月前

@Gamerstuvwxyz @ByJimbob If we both agree that we want pizza, I can then make an argument of what the best way to get the pizza is, even if I can’t morally justify that we should get pizza to begin with.

Spartan Up North 的头像
Spartan Up North9 个月前

"Because I'm right" LMAO

Godrules 的头像
Godrules9 个月前

YouTube totally props up his channel. Most of his videos have nothing to do with science, but rather are him simply mocking people he disagrees with, calling them anti-scientific. His idea of science is an atheistic philosophy which promotes anything that explains away God (Evolution, Uniformitarianism, etc).

Call Me Emo 的头像
Call Me Emo9 个月前

How does the "purpose" or lack thereof of brains take away from its current abilities?

Made by Jimbob 的头像
Made by Jimbob9 个月前

If the brain has no purpose to think, then how would you know it’s capable of properly thinking?

Call Me Emo 的头像
Call Me Emo9 个月前

As how we all do. Test to see if it functions properly like it's ability to compute and perform tasks, learning etc. How would you tell if a brain is capable of proper thinking??

Robert Mera 的头像
Robert Mera9 个月前

@ByJimbob And what would you use to test your brain? I believe you’d have to ultimately rely on your brain to assess the results of the tests, but then you’re still in the same conundrum. If you’re using your brain to test your brain, do you see the problem that leads you to?

Call Me Emo 的头像
Call Me Emo9 个月前

@ByJimbob No no no no.... How then do YOU assess the functionality of brains? This is pretty funny knowing that for example we use computers to assess the functionality of other computers..... So after you answer the question, tell me where my logic is flawed.

Robert Mera 的头像
Robert Mera9 个月前

@ByJimbob You asses whatever results the computers produced with your brain. And now you’re back to square one. How come you don’t see the circularity of this issue?

Call Me Emo 的头像
Call Me Emo9 个月前

@ByJimbob Circularity isn't inherently bad.... But you're yet to explain to me how do YOU assess the functionality of Brains????

ARW 的头像
ARW9 个月前

it's useful but not purposeful. not inherently purposeful but he uses it to think. "he", whatever that is, came from unpurposeful slop and got to create purpose for himself. that's god-like, sounds fun.

Made by Jimbob 的头像
Made by Jimbob9 个月前

That’s what so wild. They think there is an “I” that’s “using a brain” for some purpose when In fact they are their brain

ARW 的头像
ARW9 个月前

Right and it's rotting. You pin them on that, they have to revert to calling themselves slop, chaotically ordered matter. But they want you to listen to their enlightened view. Unknowingly trying to pass on their illness to the interlocutor as if it were genes. Smugfest

Ask.Seek.Knock 的头像
Ask.Seek.Knock9 个月前

If you have to say, “Because I’m right.” In a debate….. You lost the Debate.

BigTech 的头像
BigTech9 个月前

JB what is the purpose of a cloud in the sky?

Made by Jimbob 的头像
Made by Jimbob9 个月前

From my views clouds exist to sustain life in a variety of ways. From your view the sustaining of life and all preconditions are pure chance.

BigTech 的头像
BigTech9 个月前

"Pure chance" is a vague straw-man. Sad.

BigTech 的头像
BigTech9 个月前

@ByJimbob Wrong.

Made by Jimbob 的头像
Made by Jimbob9 个月前

@BigTech404 Apparently Big Tech has the same epistemic system as Dave, “wrong, I’m right”

White Man, Organize! 的头像
White Man, Organize!9 个月前

"because I'm right" is a logical fallacy because it infers inherent purpose from a stated perspective that denies inherent purpose exists. What is I? What is "right"? How do you "know" that, or anything at all?

Stephenkeddy 的头像
Stephenkeddy9 个月前

@jaydyer This little clip encompasses their entire worldview 😂 because im right😂

JP Coughlin 的头像
JP Coughlin9 个月前

Dave is a professional well poisoner

MARKofBLADEz 的头像
MARKofBLADEz9 个月前

atheism = pride and stupidity both evident in this clip

Zero Point Energy Disclosure 的头像
Zero Point Energy Disclosure9 个月前

People don’t hate this guy enough. His level of arrogance needs to be clinically studied and examined. Bro needs to study basic logic and reasoning and the fundamentals of fallacies because every argument he makes is based on emotion and truths that don’t exist

jjeg 的头像
jjeg9 个月前

this isn’t the gotcha that you think it is.

robert 的头像
robert9 个月前

This interviewer is so low iq and it shows. The professor is saying no “inherent” purpose. And he is just focusing on tryna make him look dumb and not actually listen.

ScottieDOESknow 的头像
ScottieDOESknow9 个月前

This is reminiscent of Dillahunty "The mind doesn't exist" 😂

Right Arm of the Forbidden One 的头像
Right Arm of the Forbidden One9 个月前

Why is his nose so big

DailyTodayDaily 的头像
DailyTodayDaily9 个月前

“Why would I listen to sounds coming from a purposeless brain” Dave: ***immediately invokes metaphysics***

exAtheistChristian - Gabriel 的头像
exAtheistChristian - Gabriel9 个月前

The fact that he needs to calls himself professor should already give some doubts about what kind of idiot he is. But then he speaks, and all doubts are gone for good.

𝒦𝑒𝓋𝒾𝓃 𝒱𝓈 𝐸𝓋𝒾𝓁 † 的头像
𝒦𝑒𝓋𝒾𝓃 𝒱𝓈 𝐸𝓋𝒾𝓁 †9 个月前

Push a little bit more Jim, he'll get here I know it.

mir.sajiin 的头像
mir.sajiin9 个月前

@jaydyer This isn't the gotcha you wanted it to be, getting him to accept "the brain has no inherent purpose", doesn't refute his worldview.

Mr Overprayed 的头像
Mr Overprayed9 个月前

Absolute coomer physiognomy

Challenge Your Beliefs 的头像
Challenge Your Beliefs9 个月前

No INHERENT purpose. It certainly has function. For example, it'll make up fictional entities to come up with fake explanations for things.

Oneloveabove22 的头像
Oneloveabove229 个月前

@Rach4Patriarchy Lolol Professor Douchebag 🤣 I can't stand that fella

The Word 的头像
The Word9 个月前

That “professor” is one smug piece of shit. If he was 1/10th as intelligent as he thought he was, he could be in the business of telling God how to run the universe.

Thok Grararah 的头像
Thok Grararah9 个月前

No he didn't. @grok please explain what the difference between purpose and inherent purpose in evolution is.

RoboticFaith 的头像
RoboticFaith9 个月前

In Professors Dave's case I think he's right 😂

Gainzor Zilla☦️ 的头像
Gainzor Zilla☦️9 个月前

@jaydyer It’d be pretty easy to get an admission that his argument is a result of chaos and flux from his accidental, meaningless brain. So there’s also no real purpose or meaning behind his argument. Just a chunk of grey matter having a chemical chain reaction. It also destroys the self

🎶🎚️BIBLICALLY BASS’D™🎚️🎶 的头像
🎶🎚️BIBLICALLY BASS’D™🎚️🎶9 个月前

Bro digging himself into his own hole… without purpose. Purposely and purposefully

JKBDTS 的头像
JKBDTS9 个月前

Oh, no! If there's no god, then our brains have no purpose! We all need to imagine that there's a god that made our brains with a purpose using our brains that are potentially purposeless! Also, what is the purposes of god's mind or brain? Huh?

𝔼𝕥𝕙𝕠𝕤 𝕠𝕗 𝕥𝕙𝕖 𝔼𝕒𝕤𝕥 的头像
𝔼𝕥𝕙𝕠𝕤 𝕠𝕗 𝕥𝕙𝕖 𝔼𝕒𝕤𝕥9 个月前

There is no way that phisiognomy belongs to goyim.

Ayhan 的头像
Ayhan9 个月前

All this just proves is that Dave is an atheist which we already know. Not a gotcha moment, bud. A lot of things don't have purposes.

Introduction_of_Coffee 的头像
Introduction_of_Coffee9 个月前

This is such a weak argument. Dave is in the right here. "Purposeless" is too vague to have any bite. In other words, it doesn't logically flow that, just because our brains weren't designed to be rational, they do not happen to be rational. A bulletproof car may not be designed with intent to float, but if it happens to be watertight then it will still hold you up during a flood. In that sense, the car's purpose wasn't to be a boat until you needed it to be. A new purpose was ascribed to it. All this was is clip farming.

相关视频