Loading video...
Video Failed to Load
GPT-6 Extra High vs. Kimi K3 Swarm - ECHO Start Menu Both models received the exact same prompt. I’m shocked at the quality Kimi K3 was able to output here. Its overall visual quality is above GPT-6’s and even above the menu from the actual game. However, it took... show more
119,119 views • 5 days ago •via X (Twitter)
36 Comments

I think Astra def wins. it looks almost identical to the original

I agree, Kimi quality though is the best I’ve seen

If the precedent is about photorealism, Astra will give you a very photorealistic result. I think goal-setting played a pivotal role in deciding the outcome.

I agree, Astra could’ve done better if realism was the goal

KIMI K3 max & Swarms is not fair tho

Kimi just appears to be distorting a 2D image in order to give the illusion of the eyeball tracking the menu. Did you give them assets, or did they have to find them? And was 3D on the table, or were they stuck with 2D?

Kimi's output is highly realistic, but for a game menu, that level of realism is actually a drawback

Kimi is not better, though. the skin job is very bad. everything deforms together like it's one mesh and not a mesh for the eyball separate from the mesh of the skin. The texture seems less blurry and higher quality, though. It also cheated the blinking motion by making a picture of the closed eyes appear with a vertical swipe transition instead of animating the mesh.

No mention of the dilating pupil? Astra's eye is realistically reaching to brightness. That's huge

kimi is absolute fire at front end shit

In terms of actual quality and movement, Astra wins 100% if you look at Kimi the blink is just a PNG swipe down and up, and the eye movement is only around the iris itself not the rest of the eye, looks uncanny because the rest of the eye is dead. Whereas Astra's is more alive.

Astra absolutely blows that one away; the other one might look like it has higher resolution, but Astra completely crushes it when it comes to dynamic eyewear movement and pupil contraction.

Unfair comparison ngl, it should gpt 6 astra max swarm vs Kimi k3 swarm, don’t try to save your usage

Kimi is literally morphed 2d texture slop lol wtf, also the GUI is slop too

Man GPT 6 made sure to nail the smallest details Look at how the ye pupils get bigger/smaller

42 minutes vs 3.5 hours is the part I’d pick. Kimi looking nicer doesn’t matter if it takes 5x longer. For Remie I need the one that finishes in a session I can actually afford.

@ChrisGPT sometimes it's wild how lesser-known models outperform the big names. I've seen it too, their training focus must be spot on. Wonder what datasets they're using!

No one mentioning how the eye tries to focus on Astra?! Easy winner for me

more detail/resolution doesn’t necessarily mean that the output is better

GPT’s is way better

Astra's output is better here.

The quality gap versus runtime is interesting.

Kimi won

The longer time for k3 seems worth it. It looks great.

Kimi K3 beating GPT-6 here??

The first-pass visual quality is impressive. I’d really like to see which one holds up better after 5–10 iterations.

How are u even doing this? How do u prompt it like that

Solid writeup — actual numbers, actual tradeoffs, no fake urgency. Two things worth flagging though: this is a sample size of one prompt, and “3.5 hours” for Kimi is wall-clock time that likely includes retries/iteration, not raw generation time — worth knowing if that gap holds on a second, unrelated task before calling it a general 5x speed difference.

How does Kimi K3 cost $3.75 yet their $19 Moderato sub lasts me 30 minutes till it's exhausted for the 5 hr limit.

kimi taking 5x longer but only costing ~60% more is honestly the wildest part of these benchmarks. token pricing is gonna get weird real fast.

This looks like three separate scores: visual preference, fidelity to the original, and working interactions. For a recreation task, I’d keep those separate. A prettier redesign can still miss the brief, while an accurate screenshot can miss the behavior.

Stylish and modern design!

Bruh this might take time if human dose it like Kimi k3 lol

any way you could share the kimi k3 files? it looks beautiful lol

You found a cool fringe case that k3 beat astra in something on graphics lol, cool!

Kimi >>> astra
