GPT-6 Astraに「Sibeliusを使って、ショパン風のワルツ32小節書いてみて」とお願いしたら、めっちゃすごかった!
@yogo_escentier2.7K followers
33,365 views
23 Comments
Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

@yogo_escentier
一応作曲科出身として、曲そのものに対してコメントすると、「2-3ヶ月ぐらい作曲を勉強した人が書いた曲」って印象ではある。 色々out of styleだったり、書法の拙さが目立つ反面、転調や主題労作などの構成感にはちょっとセンスを感じる。 ぶっちゃけ「ChatGPTがSibeliusを操作して20分ぐらいで作った」という事実を除いたら、曲そのものはすごくはない、今は。 ただ、今回のはリサーチゼロでいきなりやらせた結果だし、SKILLでもいくらでも知識補強できるだろうし、今後のモデルそのもののアップデートでさらによくなるだろうし、やっぱりすごい! めちゃくちゃ今後が楽しみ
23 likes

@yogo_escentier
Astraが作曲して作った楽譜(一切人間は手を入れていない)
6 likes

@jkphilly_fan
Poor voice-leading, odd interval decisions . If you gave it more music theory training, it might not make the mistakes its making. It might be an advanced AI, but it is still missing very basic theory a music oriented high school student would know. I needs more Paul Hindemith.
5 likes

@yogo_escentier
Exactly aligns with my honest opinion.
1 like

@yogo_escentier
With that being said, I’m more fascinated about the fact we can now let AI assistants help us with some *real* tedious work, which happens in GUI apps, that was never possible before.

@jkphilly_fan
Right, for orchestral work, not necessarily orchestration, but the repetitive work with part extraction, instrument range check, score notation clean up would be good taks. Perhaps a contextual phrase generator/recommender to fix a line that needs more vitality.
1 like

@yogo_escentier
Totally. I'm pretty sure I'll be especially counting on it for tediously adding dynamic/expression marks to various instruments within a score, and I love how they can now do it with context awareness rather than a cold-blooded automation. Although the quality of the performance may be highly dependent on the AI model, I think it's also very controllable via instructions.

@bartek_wl
Nothing impressive in this crap
1 like

@NauticosPi
ja, das ist ziemlich gut. es wird unaufhaltbar, er hat sogar gespielt wie ein pianist
1 like

@Syntetisaattori
Quite nice! Between bars 29-30 there is strange melodic movement.
1 like

@matthewmontag
it's impressive, but does Sibelius not articulate slurs in playback? It sounds like one continuous legato

@thenewpaulhugh
Wow, that's splendid indeed, bravo

@jparrycomposer
Had it used Sibelius before ?

@yogo_escentier
Surprisingly, no. It didn’t even look up how to use it. I didn’t give it any manuals or anything.
1 like

@jparrycomposer
That's very interesting 👍 While I'm fundamentally against prompting AI to compose music, I can see a lot of potential in getting its help with software...especially for labour intensive stuff like adjusting tuning systems... what people call a Centaur use (half man/half machine)
1 like

@yogo_escentier
I’m with you on that. I like how we now have a choice on how much work we delegate to the AI assistant. Personally I’m a composer, supposedly just like yourself, and want to be in control of my own ideas. Yet it does not mean I want to do all the repetitive tedious work on my own by hand!
1 like

@jparrycomposer
Exactly 👌

@goldrestart
シベリウスの使い方をまず学習しろ、なんて前段はなく、いきなり指示ですか? それとも、以前からの学習の蓄積は多少あったんですか?

@yogo_escentier
いやほんとにまっっっったく事前の知識入れてなく、です。 特にネットで調べたりすらしてなかったような…? すごいですよね
1 like

@Neakih_kick
曲自体は完成してて打ち込むのにポチポチ時間がかかってるんだろうなぁ 流石に打ち込みながら次を考えてるってことはないよな あと17、18小節目あたりに特にショパンみを感じた

