Having player choice doesn't determine the way Cloud reacts toward each character Here's some similar situation in all of the dates but Cloud responds accordingly :

aww both aerith and red got the handholding scene 🥺

The way he’s uninterested by the fireworks in most of them but in Tifa he admires her instead… oh they make me sick

They can’t choice the way Cloud act towards them 😊😊😊

Yeah, we can only pick an in-game dialogue to get affection points, but the result in those cutscenes are still the same

Even with the in game dialogue Cloud acts differently towards people especially Tifa

I can only compare his hand holding with Tifa to his paw holding with Red, no one else

Coping cleriths in the comments making up fanfiction about how Cloud is jealous.

Rebirth Spoilers

There is so much differences when it comes to tifa, hehe. Cloud is truly inlove with Tifa

We really are discussing this 😭 🔫

We all steal a glance at Tifa just by existing

I only stan Red x Cloud, no more wars. The paws are SOFT.

"they ARE soft" -- "HUH?"

Perfect video

I’m so distracted by the dudes night out I’m sorry 😂😂 Cait is too relatable

Tifa is Cloud's special lover 💕

Right. Still think it's better to watch it 1 by 1

Sooo MANY CUTENESS!!!!!

@RedFaeWings I love Nanaki soooo much 💕🤭