Here's a commentary comparison between Crofty, Alex Jacques and Ben Edwards on Hamilton's Silverstone win "Don't call it a comeback, he's been here for years" is my personal favourite

My personal fav: Separated by language, united by love

Crofty has best energy but Alex best commentary

You cut off one of the best bits, the build up from Crofty in the last few corners.

I enjoyed Crofty's call a lot more, just had that pinch more passion in the "and here's a 9th for you!"

you cant deny that Crofty has the best voice. He may not have the best commentary but he definitely has the nicest voice. Ben Edwards has the worst, id rather grit my teeth on sandpaper than listen to his voice!

and ofc the "official" one is the worst one why did channel 4 have to steal Alex again?

Ben Edwards was one of the racing voices of my childhood so I'm biased towards him but god damn man Jacques' call was magic

The last one is auraless

Jacques makes me mute it automatically, what a horrific commentator. Crofty is okay and Edwards is really good

Crofty is just too good in epic moments, painful as it was this commentary in AD was a masterclass