正在加载视频...

视频加载失败

How does exclusive homosexuality persist, despite evolution? An evolutionary biology professor of mine during undergrad suggested that a hint might be found in the cultural trope of the "rich gay uncle." It's true that gay men tend to have somewhat more financial success than straight men, and it's also...

347,295 次观看 • 8 个月前 •via X (Twitter)

34 条评论

Steve Sailer 的头像
Steve Sailer8 个月前

"a hint might be found in the cultural trope of the "rich gay uncle."" What cultural trope of the "rich gay uncle?" How is your gay uncle with the interior decorating business in Provincetown going to help you have more kids in Peoria compared to your straight uncle in Peoria?

Gregory Cochran 的头像
Gregory Cochran8 个月前

Your professor was innumerate.

Heliotroph☀️🍇 的头像
Heliotroph☀️🍇8 个月前

If there is any heritable component to homosexuality, it persisted because social mores meant even men with obvious and strong homosexual preferences still married a woman and gave her kids

🐭olini 的头像
🐭olini8 个月前

Simple. It doesn’t. Sexuality does not exist. It is a social construct and a relatively new one at that.

Andrew 的头像
Andrew8 个月前

He missed the obvious point: non child bearing people stop overpopulation and contribute to social well-being by being net producers.

Werner Zagrebbi 的头像
Werner Zagrebbi8 个月前

This is a good start, but the true evolutionary psychology of homosexuality remains an important unsolved problem

CarlLefavre 的头像
CarlLefavre8 个月前

It is easily explained. There’s a bunch of gay traits, and if one inherits a preponderance of them, then one is gay. If one inherits just a few of them, one is attracted to and actually more attractive to the opposite sex, so off they go into the next generation.

Sol Hando 的头像
Sol Hando8 个月前

This would have to result in brothers of a gay man having 2+ more surviving children on average, which isn’t plausible.

Elizabeth Austin 的头像
Elizabeth Austin8 个月前

I'm going to propose something more radical: you can't explain homosexuality by the theory of evolution.

Chríss 的头像
Chríss8 个月前

What an obviously ridiculous hypothesis that flies in the face of established evolutionary understanding.

BigButt thaPlug 的头像
BigButt thaPlug8 个月前

The math doesn't work. A gay uncle would need to benefit the offspring MORE than the mother and father

TheChosenOne 的头像
TheChosenOne8 个月前

You can completely destroy the argument about the “gay gene” by this one fact; boys raised by single mothers are significantly more likely to be gay than boys raised by single fathers or a nuclear family.

Nova 🌸 的头像
Nova 🌸8 个月前

This makes zero sense. A male’s development cannot know what their siblings do or don’t do. Whether they have kids or not cannot be known by a male’s brain and therefore deciding sexuality. And besides, gays come out during teen years mostly, and their siblings are usually the same age with no kids.

Fanatical🌱 的头像
Fanatical🌱8 个月前

This discussion never includes the obvious opportunity cost: this strategy must be compared to the heterosexual one.

Joseph Somsel 的头像
Joseph Somsel8 个月前

That's one of the hypotheses mentioned in this book. One piece of research suggests that gays have as many offspring as normies. They do this by starting early and gaining advantageous experience. That maintains their numbers in the gene pool. I'm skeptical. Still a bit of unresolved science it seems.

CoconutGreek 的头像
CoconutGreek8 个月前

Not true

MM_00 的头像
MM_008 个月前

Open homosexuality is only tolerated in tolerant (ie. dying) societies. Closeted grandpa who did his marital duty is a more effective transmission route.

jkv 的头像
jkv8 个月前

Ffs, for that to work out gay men would have to be more invested in their niece and nephews than the actual parents. This sort of effect would be WILDLY noticable irl and there's nothing like it. This is incredibly stupid and everybody who entertained it should be ashamed.

Molly Myers 的头像
Molly Myers8 个月前

The gay gene is linked to more fertility in straight people. The gay gene itself doesn't need to be adaptive. Just like the gene for sickle cell is maladaptive but linked to a gene that protects against malaria in people who don't carry the sickle cell gene.

Danimal 的头像
Danimal8 个月前

you're overthinking it. variation explains it. there's 8 billion people. not everyone is going to be the same

Mach Velli 的头像
Mach Velli8 个月前

It's like when a certain species male bird -- whose female counterpart have red tail feathers -- humps the hell out of a red feather duster. Sexual impulsivity run amok.

TGGP 的头像
TGGP8 个月前

My understanding is that they don't have higher incomes, on average Nor, as Greg Cochran has pointed out, are they especially devoted to their younger relatives like ants or wolves.

Name no longer missing 的头像
Name no longer missing8 个月前

Bit a stretch. The child-molesting uncle is more of a trope than the rich gay uncle.

Lucius Mullhorn 的头像
Lucius Mullhorn8 个月前

I’m sorry, but this isn’t serious. This is such sloppy pop Darwinism that it can be readily dismissed.

Partisan Bureaucrat 的头像
Partisan Bureaucrat8 个月前

Couldn't this just be passed through women as they dont need to be aroused to get pregnant and have children? Why does it have to be an adaptive trait?

Martin Elisabeth 的头像
Martin Elisabeth8 个月前

gay stuff persists because it's really fun. Also, in 2022 a study was reported to find gay men earn on average 11% less than straight men and bisexual men even less. I agree, rich gay uncle theory isn't right...

Old Whig (NRx) 🇺🇲🇸🇪🇫🇮🇪🇪🇦🇹 的头像
Old Whig (NRx) 🇺🇲🇸🇪🇫🇮🇪🇪🇦🇹8 个月前

Thats the hypothesis why major affective disorder survives, siblings get the creativity and drive witouth the mania. The hypomanic phase mimics the creative phase.

𝔉𝔯𝔞𝔫𝔨 𝔍𝔞𝔪𝔢𝔰 ⚒ 的头像
𝔉𝔯𝔞𝔫𝔨 𝔍𝔞𝔪𝔢𝔰 ⚒8 个月前

The data doesn't support this and the maths doesn't work. It's probably largely environmental - including in utero hormone levels. The birth order effect would suggest this.

DavidAnderson_JD_NYC 的头像
DavidAnderson_JD_NYC8 个月前

I thought the helper at the nest theory was disfavored today?

crysteria 的头像
crysteria8 个月前

Wouldn't this still get bred out of the family pretty quick? The rich gay uncle improves the family's fitness, but not everyone in the family has the chance-to-be-gay gene, and the siblings with the gene have less offspring than the ones without? I guess the number of individuals with the gene could go up while the portion of the family with the gene goes down... i think this theory could explain the number of homosexuals persisting but not the portion of the population.

Timbalina 的头像
Timbalina8 个月前

Ahh yes, my gay uncle tried very hard to get me to have more kids. All these years later I still dont have have the heart to tell him that there is no way I could have gotten pregnant and thats not really the way it works either and why couldn't we tell anyone

CryptoMonkeyLux 的头像
CryptoMonkeyLux8 个月前

OMG americans are even more stupid then we thought, both sides of the mic by the way 😂

Jack JP Nguyen 的头像
Jack JP Nguyen8 个月前

@wrongthinkmcgee Children will look like their uncle rather than their dad, even they only share 25% of them And I’m a gay men. So when my brother has children, he will look like me. And I will support him like an extra dad. Win-win

Sifi (Kenso) 的头像
Sifi (Kenso)8 个月前

This is a load of tosh if you think about it for two seconds.

相关视频

Why are so many young people single these days? Pooja Arora (Pooja Arora): So my last question: I wanted to talk about why people are single nowadays. I would have asked about human nature, but that’s for another day. I sent you an article—how do you think common knowledge fits into that area? Why do you think so many youngsters are single? Me: Yes, it’s a good question. I’m not sure that common knowledge is an important part of the answer, but some of it is that women no longer depend on the economic contributions of men for their livelihood, as was true, say, in my mother’s era, when women were not professionally trained. To pay the rent, they had to be married. Now, not only are women better educated, but the economy has shifted to favor the kinds of skills that women, as opposed to men, have. And just as women have been rising, men have been sinking because of the decline in blue-collar work. There have also been cultural trends that favor women’s temperaments. Men have been distracted by internet gaming, gambling, and pornography and are less desirable as marriage partners. Women with more economic power are more likely to raise their standards for what they want in a man. In my parents’ generation, it was not uncommon for a woman to marry a man with much less education and, sometimes, less intelligence. This was not unusual among my parents’ friends. The men often had a high school degree and then went immediately into a small business—sometimes a family business, sometimes one he started himself. The criterion was: does he make a living? No one cared about education. That has changed, with the result that there are fewer men who satisfy the criteria women now have. This was mentioned in the article you shared with me. Also, with more sexual freedom, people don’t have to get married simply to have sex, which was again true in my parents’ generation. There’s a process that has been in place since the baby boomers and has accelerated among millennials and Generation Z. For other reasons, I think a generation of men may also be incapable of socially skilled interaction, partly because they’ve grown up with screens instead of face-to-face contact. There is some fear that a sexual encounter could result in an accusation of rape or sexual harassment. There is so much pornography that, for an increasing number of men, it serves as an outlet for what in the past would have required actual human contact. There are many factors. The article from The Economist lists them, I think, quite skillfully. It’s not clear how to reverse the trend. Increasing the economic prospects of men and creating an educational system that is less feminized and more encouraging of male achievement might help. Another could be changing norms—and here common knowledge comes in. Among women, is it a sign of low status to be with a man who has less education than you? Men, from time immemorial, have been happy to marry women with less education than themselves. Women don't. That immediately reduces the marriage pool. Maybe that’s a norm that could change. Go back to the norm in my parents’ generation? Pooja Arora: No, let’s not do that. Me: Okay, let's not do that. Pooja Arora: We’re happy to marry men who are not as educated as us. It’s fine. They just have to be nice and kind at this point in time. Me: Well, yes—exactly. Nice and kind.

Steven Pinker

89,569 次观看 • 9 个月前

Despite fifty years of “gay pride”, and an increasingly protracted, and contentious alphabet soup of ‘LGBT+’; there is one group, in a vast ocean of awareness, that rarely gets discussed. Gay men. The stats are clear – Gay men are, by far, America’s number one victim of sexuality based hate crimes, outnumbering all other victims combined. They face more hate crime, they feel less safe in public, they are less accepted in every country in the world; they were, and still are, uniquely persecuted, throughout history, across the globe, and deep within theological text. And yet, the story of the lowly gay male is one I so rarely see. In fact, from my almighty gay following, I only hear the opposite: that the gay male, has become the “white man” of LGBT. An unwelcome figure, so often cast out and “decentred” in the incessant purity contest, that so-called “progressives” desperately flagellate themselves over. And it’s not right. I’ve seen deeply illuminating conversation at the intersection of being a ‘gay woman’, with so many important points of view, a straight man like me would otherwise have no hope of seeing. And now it’s time to have a specific conversation about “gay men”, to understand their unique experiences – both current day and historic – that are so frequently glossed over. So why do gay men experience homophobia so differently to lesbian women? What do you think? New podcast: Ask us Anything with Lisa Britton in 4K here!

TheTinMen

20,599 次观看 • 10 个月前