Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

Go Home

How much would Alberta independence actually cost? We’ve heard $50B. $170B. Even an initial estimate approaching $400B. Keith Wilson, Dennis Kalma and the Alberta Transition Council have done the work to examine a different question: Can Alberta actually afford to govern itself? Forward to Freedom estimates $22.2–$32.1B in annual...

10,165 views • 8 days ago •via X (Twitter)

45 Comments

Following the Threads 🇨🇦🇨🇦's profile picture
Following the Threads 🇨🇦🇨🇦8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Your numbers and policies are not believable until the people who came up with them take some responsibility. Identify themselves and their credentials. I don’t believe a word you say. No accountability, no credibility.

FarmGeek's profile picture
FarmGeek8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Did you ask the same of our Premier when she threw out a $400 billion price tag for independence?

Following the Threads 🇨🇦🇨🇦's profile picture
Following the Threads 🇨🇦🇨🇦8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma I don’t need to. I I already don’t trust a word that comes out of her mouth.

Ron Walton's profile picture
Ron Walton7 days ago

@miss_tanyac @ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma How about reading the starting point and the report Albertans are entitled to, at minimum, 12% ownership of all Dominion of Canada Net International assets and holdings. Plus CPP

Following the Threads 🇨🇦🇨🇦's profile picture
Following the Threads 🇨🇦🇨🇦7 days ago

@miss_tanyac @ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma The CPP is mine and everyone else’s that has paid into it. Not the Separatists. Also I am not going to believe or trust a report that the authors have not taken accountability for writing.

Ron S. Friedman's profile picture
Ron S. Friedman8 days ago

At the moment, the referendum is not even about independence. It's about: 1. Keep the situation as is, with less available options. 2. Keep the seperation option on the table, that can be used in negotiations with Ottawa as leverage. My take, more options is better than fewer options.

Brian's profile picture
Brian8 days ago

@ikwilson @ATCAlberta @DennisKalma It’s well worth the chance to be rid of the east.

Clay Thompson.'s profile picture
Clay Thompson.7 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Give it up and crawl back in your hole

Jeffrey Rath's profile picture
Jeffrey Rath8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma You mean THE VALUE OF FREEDOM that Keith is putting his name on? 😂

Third Most Albertan Man in the World's profile picture
Third Most Albertan Man in the World8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Alberta has been the economic engine of Canada despite Ottawa putting every roadblock possible in our path while siphoning off tens of billions each year to assist the ne'er do wells. It boggles the mind that anyone could think Alberta can't prosper on our own. No costing needed.

aggs's profile picture
aggs8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma This whole thing is a bad look for those at the helm. They’re fighting amongst themselves, with no clear plan for government or its structure. The divide is real, and it’s sad we’ve reached this point. All Canadians deserve equal representation and a voice. 🇨🇦

FarmGeek's profile picture
FarmGeek8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma I really wish folks would look less at being LEAD and more at taking individual action to secure Alberta’s future.

aggs's profile picture
aggs8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma You can’t run a province without structure! There are other government systems out there that work very well, but this isn’t going to change anything. All it does is divide us further. Maybe that’s the point? 🤔

Mikey11's profile picture
Mikey118 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Get a grip..all of your leaders are either stealing from their own family over 1,000,000 dollars,rath owes over 11,000,000 to indigenous people who stole and the crib keeper from his sport store is a racist ...can't make this shit up..go back under the rock you people came from.

FarmGeek's profile picture
FarmGeek8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma That’s a weird way of saying have a nice day. ✌🏽

Shug Mungus (thee/thou)🇨🇦's profile picture
Shug Mungus (thee/thou)🇨🇦7 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma You people have no plausible plan beyond burning it all down. Of course Alberta separation would be a disaster.

TW's profile picture
TW7 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma

Rock Quarry's profile picture
Rock Quarry8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma

RogueKiwi's profile picture
RogueKiwi7 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Wow you're getting some hate and crazy comments. Hang in there girl! I love your combine videos ❤️ The thing is say when people ask if we can afford it....of course we can. We're already subsidizing the rest of Canada!

WillyJim🍁's profile picture
WillyJim🍁7 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Legit question, why don’t you all start an Alberta separatist party?

The Harsh Reality 🇨🇦's profile picture
The Harsh Reality 🇨🇦7 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Have you considered that the Forward to Freedom estimate is so low because they estimated $0 for all of the costs they didn't know?

Thesis Pi's profile picture
Thesis Pi7 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Separatists are bad at math. Maybe stop counting other people's money...

2 + 2 = 4's profile picture
2 + 2 = 47 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma In some way shape or form, Alberta needs to govern itself. If that is through separation, so be it.

hopper990's profile picture
hopper9907 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma The Unionized Elbows up crowd will never allow us to break free of our yokes. I hope so but I'll be very surprised if we'll be successful this round. Then they'll probably pass a phoney law to remove our ability to even vote on it ever again. The plan is to indenture us for life

Relicdog66's profile picture
Relicdog667 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Alberta Independance cost = billions, Alberta Independence and sovereignty value = priceless.

Ron Walton's profile picture
Ron Walton7 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma All my life

Aaron Weeks's profile picture
Aaron Weeks8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Hey Tanya, none of that matters when none of you are adult enough to have a conversation with people who disagree with you… You can’t have democracy without dialogue… None of that matters when your ring leaders are raging liberals…

Watch_Dawg's profile picture
Watch_Dawg8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma You ZERO balanced the big ticket items...you have no credibility!!

Kasei Todou | Privacy for AB's profile picture
Kasei Todou | Privacy for AB8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Guys I would like to let you guys know that if the binding vote passes, I will be proposing my #ABATAct at convention. Foreign censors will either have to get in line or pay the costs.

David Ferretti's profile picture
David Ferretti7 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma It wouldn’t cost anything because Alberta won’t leave. What we’ll gain is leverage if Ottawa THINKS we’ll leave. Vote accordingly.

Glenn's profile picture
Glenn8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Everyone’s got an opinion… we all do and you know what that means! Oh save the “experts”. Why are they all libtards or NDP weaklings?

P.Rose's profile picture
P.Rose8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Are you telling me the people you guys used which you won't give names for are more qualified? Trevor Tombe - economic professor Kent Fellows — a. professor of economics John Lester — public-finance/economic-policy specialist Robert Johnston Carlo Dade Anthony Sayers Jen Winter

Jeff Hutton's profile picture
Jeff Hutton8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma ROTFL

Wizard's profile picture
Wizard8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Keep ot up

Brian Poncelet's profile picture
Brian Poncelet7 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Education time Alberta couldn’t even run the Heritage fund. They squandered billions using it as an ATM. Thinking a new set of politicians is going to fix the problem means you are delusional. The numbers they are using is assuming oil is going to remain high. That’s wrong.

FarmGeek's profile picture
FarmGeek6 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma So after those points, your solution is to vote for more of the same??

Brian Poncelet's profile picture
Brian Poncelet6 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma No most politicians will tell you what you want to hear. The problem is the people who want to separate are trying to tell you that everything is going to be fantastic. The reality is Canada is stronger together. The #Trump fiasco is a perfect example.

TiredOfTech 🇺🇸's profile picture
TiredOfTech 🇺🇸7 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma How do you put a price on freedom? The cost of not doing it is perpetual servitude.

Jr T's profile picture
Jr T7 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Laughable estimates. You should be ashamed trying to swindle people.

Hrafin's profile picture
Hrafin7 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma The transition council is a shadow group, how can you trust a shadow organization that operates in secrecy ?

FarmGeek's profile picture
FarmGeek6 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma lol says the guy hiding behind a shadowy, secret X account

RSM's profile picture
RSM8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma

alancaster's profile picture
alancaster8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Seeing you sit in the combine while you share your thoughts really makes me buy into the farmer narrative you have cultivated so well.

FarmGeek's profile picture
FarmGeek8 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Don’t have many options for where to make a video these days unless it’s from the combine cab. I’m not sure if that was a compliment or a backhanded dig, but you have a good day!

alancaster's profile picture
alancaster6 days ago

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma I guess you'll never know...

Related Videos

Could Alberta actually leave? Keith Wilson joins Glenn Beck Americans with an interest in their northern neighbours are curiously looking on, wondering about the possibility of Alberta breaking away from the rest of Canada to create a new province. Glenn Beck raised the subject with Keith Wilson during the prominent Alberta independence activist and constitutional lawyer's appearance on Blaze Media's The Glenn Beck Program. “Is there enough support in Alberta to actually get that done,” Beck asked, in addition to whether Wilson actually thought “Canada would allow” the province, “the Texas of Canada,” to leave Confederation. Wilson pointed to the unique legal framework in Canada, which allows a province the ability to exit through a referendum. “If a clear majority of voters within a province vote on a clear question for independence, that triggers two routes to independence,” the constitutional law expert said. “One is the parties have to enter into good faith negotiations, meaning Alberta needs to go into a meeting room with the federal government and the other provinces and say, 'alright, we've got national parks here; we've got military bases in Alberta. We'll pay you, the federal government, a certain amount of money for those bases and national parks,'” Wilson explained. “The other path is if the parties don't enter into good faith negotiations,” he continued, noting that was “something we're very concerned about here in Alberta.” This route could see a “unilateral declaration of independence,” something that “relies on international recognition,” he cautioned. “If the United States and other countries are prepared to recognize Alberta independence, it creates a clear pathway,” Wilson told the American host. Wilson and Beck also discussed two other federal policies that are contentious in Alberta — the Liberal government's gun grab and its continued expansion of the Medical Assistance in Dying program. Independence campaigners assert they've collected enough signatures to trigger the citizen-led referendum, with a vote expected to take place in fall 2026.

Rebel News

43,303 views • 6 months ago

I spent a lot of time reading the Canada West Foundation’s new report on Alberta separation, and I think Albertans should read it too. Not because I agree with where it ultimately lands. I don’t. But because something interesting happens when you work through the report carefully: parts of it make a remarkably strong case for why Alberta is having this conversation in the first place. Decades of attempted reform. The same constitutional frustrations resurfacing again and again. Alberta’s enormous fiscal contribution to Canada. Legitimate questions about debt, assets, trade, pensions, investment, and what a transition could look like. Those questions deserve serious answers. But identifying things that would need to be negotiated is very different from proving they cannot be negotiated. And there’s one question I think deserves just as much scrutiny as every risk associated with leaving: What happens if Alberta stays? Because staying is a choice too, and it comes with its own assumptions, costs, and risks. That distinction matters even more as we approach October 19. We are not being asked to settle every detail of an independent Alberta that day. We are being asked whether Alberta should accept the status quo, or begin the process that gives us the leverage to find out whether there is something better. After reading this report, I’m even more convinced we should find out. Vote Option 2. #LetAlbertaDecide #Alberta #AlbertaPolitics #Option2

FarmGeek

27,487 views • 29 days ago

Alberta flags allegedly stolen from children at Canada Day parade Imagine taking Alberta flags out of the hands of children because you don't like how their parents might vote. That's exactly what one Alberta independence campaign says happened in Wetaskiwin. Now, the RCMP investigation has reportedly been escalated. I spoke with the man behind United Alberta Flags, John Tomkinson, at Keith Wilson's sold-out 1,000-person Let Alberta Decide Stampede breakfast. The turnout at Wilson's Stampede breakfast made one thing clear: Alberta's independence movement is drawing crowds in the real world, not just online. Nearly 1,000 people packed Ranchman's Cookhouse just days after tickets went on sale, bringing together supporters and third-party advertiser groups from across the province ahead of the October 19 referendum. One of those groups was United Alberta Flags, founded by Tomkinson. His organization has been travelling the province, handing out Alberta flags and encouraging Albertans to proudly display them as part of the referendum campaign. But Tomkinson's group has also become embroiled in a growing controversy. United Alberta Flags alleges that volunteers with the opposing Forever Canadian campaign removed Alberta flags and referendum campaign materials from children and families during the Wetaskiwin Canada Day parade. According to Tomkinson, additional witnesses and video evidence have led the Wetaskiwin RCMP to elevate the investigation to the Central Alberta RCMP Investigations Division. Tomkinson told me about the alleged incident, the RCMP investigation, and what he is doing to grow support for Alberta independence across the province. REPORT by Sheila Gunn Reid:

Rebel News

12,646 views • 2 months ago

The Conservative Party has an Alberta problem — a big one It's not because Alberta has abandoned the Conservatives, but because Alberta's Conservative voters might be outgrowing Ottawa, and we have the poll numbers to prove it. A new @ActForAlberta poll shows something remarkable: 66% of Conservative Party of Canada supporters in Alberta support independence; 51% strongly support it. Another 15% somewhat support it. That is not a fringe. That is not a handful of angry keyboard warriors. That is the federal Conservatives' Western engine room looking at Confederation and saying: maybe this deal is done. And that explains something important about the way Pierre Poilievre and the federal Conservatives talk about Alberta independence. They oppose it, of course. They have to. The Conservative Party of Canada cannot win without Alberta. Take Alberta out of Confederation and the CPC loses its safest seats, its donor base, its volunteer army, and its moral claim to represent Western Canada. Without Alberta, there may never be another Conservative government in Ottawa again. So yes, they are against independence. But notice what they are not doing. They are not going full Liberal-style Project Fear. They are not screaming that Albertans are stupid, racist, reckless, dangerous separatists who need to be shamed back into line. Why? Because they can read a poll. If two-thirds of your own Alberta supporters back independence, you cannot sneer at them without blowing up your own base. You cannot smear them as extremists when they are your riding presidents, your donors, your door-knockers, your sign crews, your voters. So, the CPC is trapped. Ottawa needs Alberta to stay. But Alberta conservatives are increasingly asking: what exactly are we staying for?

Rebel News

27,822 views • 5 months ago

Something is changing in Alberta… and you can feel it. Drone shots of a convoy rolling into Mirror. Trucks and cars lined up. Horns blaring. Alberta flags waving in the wind. An anthem playing over top that captures exactly what this moment feels like. Pride. Unity. Momentum. This wasn’t just a group of people showing up. These were volunteers and canvassers who had just spent an entire day traveling town to town, knocking on doors, reaching communities with no permanent signing locations, and collecting hundreds of signatures for Alberta independence. And then they came together to celebrate. Young and old. Rural and urban. All united by one idea: 👉 Alberta can stand on its own 👉 Alberta deserves a future built by Albertans 👉 Alberta is waking up I’m proud to have been part of it. And here’s the truth… If you’re watching this and thinking “I wish I was there” — you can be part of the next one. We are just getting warmed up. There are going to be more convoys, more rallies, and bigger gatherings all summer long. So here’s what you do: Get yourself a big blue beautiful Alberta flag Grab a few friends Show up next time Be part of something that actually matters. 🚨 HOW TO SIGN THE PETITION If you haven’t signed yet, this is critical: • You must sign in person • Look for an official Elections Alberta canvasser (badge required) • There are pop-up signing locations happening all over Alberta • There are permanent signing locations listed at • And there are canvassers going door-to-door right now This is how we turn momentum into real action. This isn’t just about a petition. It’s about the future of this province. And from what I saw in Mirror… Alberta is ready.

Jon Alberta Patriot

56,386 views • 6 months ago

🚨 We're launching an Alberta independence campaign — and this is why we had to do it We’re going 'all in' on the independence referendum on October 19. I have major news to share with you. We are officially launching Act For Alberta — a legally registered third-party campaign group supporting the Alberta independence petition drive, which is ending on May 2, 2026. When Alberta independence goes to a referendum later this Fall, Act for Alberta will also be there. "Third party" doesn't mean we're forming a political party. Think of it as a SuperPAC: the same kind of organization we've set up federally for past elections. In Alberta, this registration is the only legal path for us toadvertise in support of Alberta independence, both during the petition drive, and during this Fall’s referendum. If we don't register, Elections Alberta can — and will — prosecute us. So: reason number one is legal protection. Act for Alberta will advocate fearlessly in favour of the Yes campaign, you know the bureaucrats would come for us otherwise. Reason number two is that the mainstream media, and the entire establishment — every major political party, every major media outlet, every union, every TV talk show — is going to go to war against Alberta. Alberta is about to be overrun by pro-Liberal, pro-Carney, anti-Alberta propaganda. Someone needs to fight back. Reason number three is even more simple: we genuinely believe in this independence referendum, and we believe Albertans should have their say. Two weeks ago, a citizens' petition with more than 170,000 signatures was submitted to trigger a constitutional referendum on Alberta independence. I love the idea of a referendum. Let the people speak! There are issues that politicians refuse to touch because they're too scared or politically correct — and Alberta independence is exactly the kind of thing ordinary people talk about privately that official people are terrified to mention publicly. Now, ordinary people get a vote, even if politicians are afraid. This is your chance to be part of it. Please visit our website at right now to learn more and find out how you can help — before this campaign really heats up. Here’s what's at stake. Quebec has had two independence referendums — the last one came within 0.5% of passing — and no one called them traitors for it. The Supreme Court of Canada has confirmed these votes are legal. Parliament passed the Clarity Act specifically to govern how such a vote works. And yet when Albertans ask for the same democratic remedy, the regime media calls it treason, and government lawyers line up to say why only Quebec gets those votes, not Albertans. Why the double standard? Because the establishment makes a very good living off Alberta, and they will say and do anything to protect that arrangement. Alberta sends $20 billion a year to Ottawa — only to have its pipelines blocked, its oil tankers banned (while OPEC tankers sail freely into eastern ports), and its workers ruled out of senior federal jobs for not speaking French. Here's the question I keep coming back to: if Alberta were its own country today, would it vote to join Ottawa on these terms? I doubt it. Visit to see how we're going to make that case. going to fight on the Yes side using real professional campaign tools: TV ads, digital ads, our billboard truck, and public events. Because every powerful institution in Canada has already lined up against this referendum. Alberta needs a fearless, unapologetic voice on the other side. That's us. We need your help. Please go to to join us. The independence referendum is October 19th, barely six months away. Elections Alberta bureaucrats would love nothing more than to prosecute Rebel News for daring to speak up during this campaign. So we registered Act For Alberta as a third-party campaign group. Now they can't touch us. We're going all in - stand with us. This is the exact playbook Quebec used — twice. The separatist Bloc Québécois has sat in Parliament for decades and no one blinks. The Parti Québécois is currently leading the polls in Quebec. But when Albertans ask for the same democratic conversation, the regime calls it treason. That double standard is exactly why this referendum matters — and why we're fighting for it. Alberta sends $20 billion to Ottawa every year. In return: blocked pipelines, cancelled LNG projects, banned oil tankers, and sneers at us because they think Alberta has nowhere else to go. Well, now Alberta does have somewhere else to go. The U.S. has already said they'd buy Alberta oil if Alberta were independent.

Rebel News

83,429 views • 5 months ago