Loading video...
Video Failed to Load
How much would Alberta independence actually cost? We’ve heard $50B. $170B. Even an initial estimate approaching $400B. Keith Wilson, Dennis Kalma and the Alberta Transition Council have done the work to examine a different question: Can Alberta actually afford to govern itself? Forward to Freedom estimates $22.2–$32.1B in annual... show more
10,165 views • 8 days ago •via X (Twitter)
45 Comments

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Your numbers and policies are not believable until the people who came up with them take some responsibility. Identify themselves and their credentials. I don’t believe a word you say. No accountability, no credibility.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Did you ask the same of our Premier when she threw out a $400 billion price tag for independence?

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma I don’t need to. I I already don’t trust a word that comes out of her mouth.

@miss_tanyac @ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma How about reading the starting point and the report Albertans are entitled to, at minimum, 12% ownership of all Dominion of Canada Net International assets and holdings. Plus CPP

@miss_tanyac @ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma The CPP is mine and everyone else’s that has paid into it. Not the Separatists. Also I am not going to believe or trust a report that the authors have not taken accountability for writing.

At the moment, the referendum is not even about independence. It's about: 1. Keep the situation as is, with less available options. 2. Keep the seperation option on the table, that can be used in negotiations with Ottawa as leverage. My take, more options is better than fewer options.

@ikwilson @ATCAlberta @DennisKalma It’s well worth the chance to be rid of the east.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Give it up and crawl back in your hole

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma You mean THE VALUE OF FREEDOM that Keith is putting his name on? 😂

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Alberta has been the economic engine of Canada despite Ottawa putting every roadblock possible in our path while siphoning off tens of billions each year to assist the ne'er do wells. It boggles the mind that anyone could think Alberta can't prosper on our own. No costing needed.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma This whole thing is a bad look for those at the helm. They’re fighting amongst themselves, with no clear plan for government or its structure. The divide is real, and it’s sad we’ve reached this point. All Canadians deserve equal representation and a voice. 🇨🇦

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma I really wish folks would look less at being LEAD and more at taking individual action to secure Alberta’s future.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma You can’t run a province without structure! There are other government systems out there that work very well, but this isn’t going to change anything. All it does is divide us further. Maybe that’s the point? 🤔

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Get a grip..all of your leaders are either stealing from their own family over 1,000,000 dollars,rath owes over 11,000,000 to indigenous people who stole and the crib keeper from his sport store is a racist ...can't make this shit up..go back under the rock you people came from.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma That’s a weird way of saying have a nice day. ✌🏽

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma You people have no plausible plan beyond burning it all down. Of course Alberta separation would be a disaster.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Wow you're getting some hate and crazy comments. Hang in there girl! I love your combine videos ❤️ The thing is say when people ask if we can afford it....of course we can. We're already subsidizing the rest of Canada!

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Legit question, why don’t you all start an Alberta separatist party?

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Have you considered that the Forward to Freedom estimate is so low because they estimated $0 for all of the costs they didn't know?

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Separatists are bad at math. Maybe stop counting other people's money...

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma In some way shape or form, Alberta needs to govern itself. If that is through separation, so be it.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma The Unionized Elbows up crowd will never allow us to break free of our yokes. I hope so but I'll be very surprised if we'll be successful this round. Then they'll probably pass a phoney law to remove our ability to even vote on it ever again. The plan is to indenture us for life

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Alberta Independance cost = billions, Alberta Independence and sovereignty value = priceless.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma All my life

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Hey Tanya, none of that matters when none of you are adult enough to have a conversation with people who disagree with you… You can’t have democracy without dialogue… None of that matters when your ring leaders are raging liberals…

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma You ZERO balanced the big ticket items...you have no credibility!!

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Guys I would like to let you guys know that if the binding vote passes, I will be proposing my #ABATAct at convention. Foreign censors will either have to get in line or pay the costs.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma It wouldn’t cost anything because Alberta won’t leave. What we’ll gain is leverage if Ottawa THINKS we’ll leave. Vote accordingly.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Everyone’s got an opinion… we all do and you know what that means! Oh save the “experts”. Why are they all libtards or NDP weaklings?

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Are you telling me the people you guys used which you won't give names for are more qualified? Trevor Tombe - economic professor Kent Fellows — a. professor of economics John Lester — public-finance/economic-policy specialist Robert Johnston Carlo Dade Anthony Sayers Jen Winter

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma ROTFL

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Keep ot up

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Education time Alberta couldn’t even run the Heritage fund. They squandered billions using it as an ATM. Thinking a new set of politicians is going to fix the problem means you are delusional. The numbers they are using is assuming oil is going to remain high. That’s wrong.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma So after those points, your solution is to vote for more of the same??

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma No most politicians will tell you what you want to hear. The problem is the people who want to separate are trying to tell you that everything is going to be fantastic. The reality is Canada is stronger together. The #Trump fiasco is a perfect example.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma How do you put a price on freedom? The cost of not doing it is perpetual servitude.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Laughable estimates. You should be ashamed trying to swindle people.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma The transition council is a shadow group, how can you trust a shadow organization that operates in secrecy ?

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma lol says the guy hiding behind a shadowy, secret X account

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Seeing you sit in the combine while you share your thoughts really makes me buy into the farmer narrative you have cultivated so well.

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma Don’t have many options for where to make a video these days unless it’s from the combine cab. I’m not sure if that was a compliment or a backhanded dig, but you have a good day!

@ATCAlberta @ikwilson @DennisKalma I guess you'll never know...





