I posed a question for Sheil Kapadia this week: removing the QB, would you rather have the Cardinals roster or Chargers roster?

@SheilKapadia Incredible pre-emptive excuse making for Herbert

@SheilKapadia Nate, Talk more about how many wide open receivers Justin missed Sunday, instead of try to create a narrative that he somehow now has a horrible roster, and it’s not his fault they lost Ya know, journalistic integrity

@SheilKapadia I just know one or both of yall were super high on the Chargers headed into the year 😂

@SheilKapadia Even if it’s close you are basically saying Herbert is a worse player then Jacoby

because I thought the defense was very unimpressive in week one. From pass rush to even things like botches on the backend. Still think the offense will get right, though. Week one wasn't as poor upon review!

@SheilKapadia Nate you had the Chargers ranked 3rd in the NFL coming into the season for offense. There was a lot of talk about the defense in this clip but why are we suddenly SO down on this roster after 1 game?

@SheilKapadia It’s not Herbert’s fault . Per usual

@SheilKapadia The Cardinals don't have a bad roster. Prior to last season, you would not have been called crazy to say they might contend for the playoffs. They were the most injured team in the league last year, so people only remember how they looked at the end of the year.

@SheilKapadia Cards roster

@SheilKapadia .. so after one game all of sudden the Chargers don’t have the roster to compete?!? So let me guess Herbert has been let down by roster management, coach, city, fans, jersey colors?!

@SheilKapadia I'd take Cardinals with the QBs thrown in

@SheilKapadia What the hell are we doing man

@SheilKapadia Still the Chargers by a decent margin. I have the offenses rated almost equal -QB but Arizona near bottom of the league defensively. I know there’s a few young names we’re excited about but there’s very little there for now IMO

@SheilKapadia good question. but can make an argument the chargers QB played the worst of any player who played in that game tho.

@SheilKapadia This is exactly why one Week 1 result shouldn’t define a team. The QB matters, but so do the other 52 players…and history shows that 0-1 teams recover while some 1-0 teams collapse. Evaluate the roster, then let the season develop 👇

@SheilKapadia crazy that’s even a question 😭

@SheilKapadia Herbert gonna be in year 20 and ppl will still have excuses for him

@SheilKapadia Stop

@SheilKapadia Here come the Justin Herbert excuses!

@SheilKapadia I wish I could love anything as much as football talking head nerds love making excuses for Herbert .

@SheilKapadia Why would you remove the QB? I don’t think Jacoby is a scrub.

@SheilKapadia I’d trade for their offensive roster in a heartbeat. Our tackles have shown not to matter with how bad our IOL is. Then a much improved WR core and jumping to the best TE in the league

@SheilKapadia The excuses keep on coming.

@SheilKapadia Give me Cardinals with the QB

@SheilKapadia Cardinals better OL, DL, WRs, TE, LBs.

@SheilKapadia Comparing non QB rosters is always a fun exercise. I thought the Jags were at least as good as the Manning Broncos that time they were a historic 26pt dog.

@SheilKapadia You people are the worst 😂

@SheilKapadia Arizona was so bad at the end of the last year defensively. Maybe I put too much weight on that in betting the under win total on them, but I need to see more to update my thoughts on them.

@SheilKapadia Dream team, can’t wait for this episode