跳过导航
I spent 6 hours testing Midjourney v8 against every major image model.
0:00 / 0:28

I spent 6 hours testing Midjourney v8 against every major image model.

Alex Patrascu

@maxescu3.9万 位关注者

在 X 上查看
130 个赞下载原帖

20,884 次观看

I spent 6 hours testing Midjourney v8 against every major image model. Conclusions: 1. v8 is better when you use a profile 2. If you push --s to higher levels, you start to get the same person 3. v8 in RAW mode is subpar 4. v8 lacks fidelity What do you think? Prompt below:

33 条评论

评论来自 X (Twitter) 上的原帖

  • Is this a 3D model? 的头像

    @IsThisA3DModel

    what a waste of 6 hours. who cares lol

    662 个赞

  • Flowers ☾ 的头像

    @flowersslop

    midjourney always has this wannabe vintage 2015 tumblr kinda vibe as default which is obnoxious

    13 个赞

  • Alex Patrascu 的头像

    @maxescu

    True! You can tell an MJ image from a mile away

    4 个赞

  • Alex Patrascu 的头像

    @maxescu

    Prompt: Capture a candid cinematic close-up portrait of a woman with messy braided hair, bathed in soft golden sunlight filtering through trees. Her face is in sharp focus, with a gently blurred background of foliage creating a dreamy, intimate atmosphere. The lighting is natural and warm, softly illuminating her features and enhancing skin tones. Her expression feels spontaneous and authentic, with subtle emotion in her eyes and relaxed presence. The composition places her slightly off-center, adding a natural, unposed feel. Fine details in her hair and skin remain visible, while the soft background glow adds depth and calm. The overall mood is warm, nostalgic, and inviting, evoking a quiet moment captured in time.

    8 个赞

  • Tabi Yume 的头像

    @U79916881747113

    I am just an enthusiast not a PRO. Based on my @midjourney v8 renders i strngly belive its main useage would be for cinematic experince stroy telling and if your trying it to compare for UGC material then its the wrong tree ur barking at. Tuned it with my --p and moodboard.

    7 个赞

  • Alex Patrascu 的头像

    @maxescu

    @midjourney Do you think my prompt example here qualifies as UGC? What are you talking about? Also, your examples have an insanely artificial skin texture. We can't still be doing this in 2026. If you want cinematic storytelling there are so many more, better, more powerful models.

    2 个赞

  • Tabi Yume 的头像

    @U79916881747113

    Nowdays people are comparing with UGC clean image rather then astistic style. NO matter what most of us are using Mj image as base image on other VG or IG as intial frame or storyboard, and thats a fact. It definetly doesnt have the 4K image sharpness like other IG models but Asthetics is killing it😉

    1 个赞

  • Alex Patrascu 的头像

    @maxescu

    @midjourney You clearly haven't tested any other models to see what's possible these days.

  • ATLANTIQ 的头像

    @Krzysztof_8888

    old @midjourney was like this, it was the best

    4 个赞

  • NΞXUS 的头像

    @NEXUS_TO_NOVA

    Just test what you said and it's 💯 accurate

    2 个赞

  • Alex Patrascu 的头像

    @maxescu

    It's sad. I've not used MJ in a very long time, and I kept renewing in hope that maybe v8 will be good, because they hyped it so much, but it's clear now that it's over for them. It was good while it lasted.

    2 个赞

  • NΞXUS 的头像

    @NEXUS_TO_NOVA

    I don’t know what they changed in the model architecture, but it doesn’t behave like it used to. This one seems to understand prompts better at times, but yeah, I've expected way more from them. I feel like they tried to replicate what Nano banana and Seedream does but didn't go well

    1 个赞

  • Alex Patrascu 的头像

    @maxescu

    They need their models to be faster and use less compute. In their office hours, they kept repeating that they don't have the GPUs to scale, so then probably the older architecture couldn't be optimized.

    1 个赞

  • NΞXUS 的头像

    @NEXUS_TO_NOVA

    I'm trying to find a way to explore this, I was able to come up with this kind of image

    3 个赞

  • Alex Patrascu 的头像

    @maxescu

    Man I keep trying, but the I can't do this plastic look anymore. It's something that doesn't click with me anymore.

    1 个赞

  • NΞXUS 的头像

    @NEXUS_TO_NOVA

    I understand you, this is also what I'm trying to figure out with this version.

  • The Right Rationale 的头像

    @Right_Rationale

    Midjourney's strength has never been realism, but artistic creativity, cinematic imagery, etc... I feel these comparisons miss the point.

    2 个赞

  • « 𝗢 ʙ ꜱ ᴄ ᴇ ɴ ᴇ ꜱ ᴇ ʟ ᴇ ɴ 𝗘 » 的头像

    @ObsceneSelene

    Nanobanana Pro is better than all of them.

    1 个赞

  • FALLENGRAIL 的头像

    @fallengrail

    can any other model make something like this?

    1 个赞

  • Emily 的头像

    @IamEmily2050

    Seedream V5 Pro and Nano banana Pro V2 should be coming in few weeks 🤭🤭🤭.

    1 个赞