Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

Go Home

17,960 views • 1 month ago •via X (Twitter)

9 Comments

Colin Glassey - Author's profile picture
Colin Glassey - Author1 month ago

I honestly don't know what to make of this statement by Mr. Tolkien. Everything - that we know of - which lives, dies. Death is both inevitable and completely "natural". In Tolkien's world, the Valar are immortal & Elves are immortal. The Blessed Lands are the Undying Lands - but humans can not go there. For Humans, Hobbits, Dwarves, and Ents, death will find them all. Tolkien was a very deep thinker and he is completely beyond me here.

Angelfire's profile picture
Angelfire1 month ago

I was lucky enough to visit his and his wife’s grave a few weeks back. He will always be one of the greatest minds of all time.

Chen G.'s profile picture
Chen G.1 month ago

People make a lot out of Tolkien quoting Simone de Beauvoir, but the quotation is from John Warrack's biography of Carl Maria von Weber. So it's really about one of Tolkien's favourite composers.

Deeple101's profile picture
Deeple1011 month ago

Hmm… the kings of numenor would give up their lives freely for the next generation. Interesting. Puts that bit of knowledge into perspective. Hmm. I gotta go reread the books again soon.

Noatman's profile picture
Noatman1 month ago

Life is the problem, not death. We will never know the truth about the world or ourselves rendering it meaningless. Even if life had meaning, within 2 generations of your death, the memory of you will be forgotten, perhaps lingering on in the occasional thoughts of a few.

JJ's profile picture
JJ1 month ago

@grok, be so kind, post in a written form what just Mr. Tolkien said so I can use you to translate it

Alex Sherman's profile picture
Alex Sherman1 month ago

Man I wish the man lived long enough to voice audio books. I'll have to settle for short clips

Trad Aesthetics's profile picture
Trad Aesthetics1 month ago

You aren't alone. Try being an author, it hangs in our brains a lot more.

Cruelty Sponge's profile picture
Cruelty Sponge1 month ago

Shut it, white boy