ICARDI A good idea? A bad idea?

If fit a big yes!

Great idea. Just look at his goalscoring record!! Imagine bringing him on with 10 mins to go if we need a goal. We don’t have this option currently!

He is nuts, but I think he could be a good signing.

Pointless conversation as its not going g to happen. There not assed about a single free agent. It's as simple as that

A desperate idea He’s a free agent for a reason 😬

It's the best somewhat realistic free option there is imo

I’d give it ago but depends on the size of wages

Huge wages for a stop gap that would potentially stop us from signing a long term striker in Jan. No gaurantees he could even do a job in the prem at his age as well.

How many years back? Like asking for the 2015 version of Vardy, only to realise that only the slower, less prolific 2026 version is available.

Good idea on a 1 year deal with an option

Shandy Van der Meyde

Bad Idea - like all these free transfers there is a reason their clubs and no others clubs want them. AVOID!

No brainer get him signed 🖊

Pros: Proven goalscorer in multiple leagues, adds depth and quality option Cons: Absolute bin fire of a personal life, likely to be disruptive

Deceptive pace. Slower than he looks...

Yes - we need proven support/cover.

Good idea. Need a striker. Capable talented just needs the right club.

No thanks

bad

Good

The next Andy VDM/Drenthe…

I’d take Martial…

Knee injury year before last but stayed fit last season. Significant drop in game time + production, but it takes a while to recover fully from ACL injury. Best available CF but personal life would drives Moyes nuts. May be worthwhile just for that alone 😅

Good idea

Apparently TFG bought Roma 7years ago And it was only when fans kicked off that they started to tear the club with respect It’s gonna take the fans to start kicking off for these chancers TFG to start adding value on their bargain buy of the club

Great idea

At least it’s an idea

Yes, Barry will relegate us.

If he can improve us in the middle of this terrible unbeaten run he'd be more than welcome UTFT

He’d score more than Barry. Fact

Good idea in the sense that it fills some air time on a podcast, or are you actually involved with trying to sign him?

Good