Skip navigation
I’m a student or national security. I still argue that pausing/blocking Satluj for ‘national…
0:00 / 3:06

I’m a student or national security. I still argue that pausing/blocking Satluj for ‘national…

Shiv Aroor

@ShivAroor1.6M followers

Visit on X
2,305 likesDownloadOriginal post

143,754 views

I’m a student or national security. I still argue that pausing/blocking Satluj for ‘national security’ reasons makes zero sense:

33 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Archie's profile picture

    @archieposts

    Haan, go on normalising suicide bombing and give full exposure to Bhindrawal fan boys and then cry later that we have a major Khalistani extremism in Punjab.

    21 likes

  • jatin's profile picture

    @108jatin

    let it be a level playing field then!. Sikh groups didn't even allow Bhindrawale portrayed as a Khalistani in the movie Emergency.

    21 likes

  • Moye Moye's profile picture

    @OlaaUberr

    Meanwhile Jaswant Singh Khalra views....based on which movie is made

    16 likes

  • aman singh's profile picture

    @amansin88383501

    KPS Gill was a monster. Gulshan Kumar a fruit vendor from Tarn Taran, was allegedly killed in a fake encounter by Tarn Taran police in 1993. Gulshan a Hindu was killed by KPS team and then collected reward from Indian government by faking him as a Sikh fighter.

    13 likes

  • Ashwamedh's profile picture

    @Quantum49873873

    u let them release this movie...nxt yr they r gonna return and make an even bigger propaganda movie fully glorifying bhindranwale...extremist ideologies like khalistanism shd be given no quarter and be absolutely crushed..govt shd also revoke oci card of dosanjh...he is a proven committed khalistani

    9 likes

  • ASPR's profile picture

    @HitRunDFI

    You are a lund of national security. You have lost no family members in Punjab and Kashmir but I have. Glorifying suicide bombing with a BGM music of Sikh religious shabads tells a lot about them and their supporters.

    6 likes

  • Red Jat's profile picture

    @IP_Sidhu

    He was a Lawyer.. who got involved as his own friend was picked up and vanished ..then his mother met the same fate as they were just baptised Sikhs!! and then he saw Mass Graves and all he was asking was atleast tell who you killed and where are they buried.. basic human rights!! and They thought lets just get rid of him too.. and mind you ... judges doctors deputy comissioners .. no one could say nothing to even a Hawaldar at that time This was way worse than what Mughals era did to finish Sikhs!!

    4 likes

  • Vineeth Naik 🇮🇳's profile picture

    @vineeth_naik

    I watched it just because it was "paused/blocked". Would not have otherwise. If you ask me, showing cops to be ruthless with monopoly of violence should discourage seperatists.

    4 likes

  • Undeniablelogic's profile picture

    @iamaloneranger

    I am student of national security. Doesn't that mean by your own logic, your opinion is useless. Because if your opinion mattered even an ounce you would in it rather than being a sideshow with camera.

    3 likes

  • Deepak Rathor's profile picture

    @rathor0811

    Does stopping something which can cause revival of khalistani extremism makes sense to you? If yes, then stop portraying yoursrlf as a intellectial. 🙏

    3 likes

  • 大神's profile picture

    @shamron_ar7851

    It does make sense. It sends the message that it's just a narrative being pushed for political goals. It's never meant to stop people from watching, especially in this age

    3 likes

  • Shibi Payamal's profile picture

    @ShibiPayamal

    Promoting terror simps and glorifying political assassination is not right

    2 likes

  • Piyush Mathur's profile picture

    @PIYUSHMATHUR9

    Since it’s streaming add free on you tube … by now everyone has watched it ;I am sure ! It’s just the debate on news the forum that stands active. 🤓

    2 likes

  • U97007's profile picture

    @u97007

    Silencing voices is never good. Especially a film that just talks about extrajudicial encounters and police brutality.

    2 likes

  • Pramod Bahadur's profile picture

    @_pramod_bahadur

    Modiji has been crying and whining about dark days of emergency and even repeatedly cries about it in Mann ki baat and in Parliament. Celebrates 50+ years. What’s he doing any different now?

    2 likes

  • amit kulkarni's profile picture

    @iammystery1

    Let Kangana Ranawat's 'Emergency' also get a relief from ban

    2 likes

  • PBKS Nation 🦁's profile picture

    @SidharthFandom

    I am really amazed how Godi media anchors like you @navikakumar supporting Satluj. Finally a sensible move

    2 likes

  • Skshukla's profile picture

    @Skshukl43886021

    Blocking one film during active recruitment cycles ≠ censorship. it's threat management. show me the evidence you wanted this blocked outside heightened separatist activity, and then we talk about principle

    1 like

  • Shivani's profile picture

    @Shivani57481297

    That senior citizen Khalra used to address Bhindrawla as Saint !!! And movie whitewashed him as human right activist and a martyr. Level of stupidity and brainwashing being done is alarming. Trying to change the actual history.. earlier Urduwood used to produce such films.

    1 like

  • Sriku P's profile picture

    @SrikuP93

    It is easy to be swayed by emotion when you watch the movie- to understand both sides of the story- I recommend reading this book by KPS Gill...And since Google and the internet are free, I hope you all learn what happened to the Tarn Taran Hindu families (the location mentioned in the movie) Hindu families. P.S. The protagonist of this movie called Jarnail Bhidranwala a “saint”!!

    1 like