Loading video...

Video Failed to Load

Go Home

Is Jim Edmonds catch overrated?

nut_history's profile picture

BaseballHistoryNut

256,020 subscribers

123,684 views • 1 year ago •via X (Twitter)

News & PoliticsSportsEducation
LIVE

Anya Rossi• Live Now

Private livecam show

11 Comments

Mike McCabe's profile picture
Mike McCabe1 year ago

Maybe the best catch ever

Trump2024Film's profile picture
Trump2024Film1 year ago

Do you agree?

Coby’s Gambling Corner's profile picture
Coby’s Gambling Corner1 year ago

not a chance - unreal fkn catch i tried doing this one time when I played for team Toronto and I damn near broke my face and back and completely missed the ball - lucky tho I threw the guy out trying to get a triple

Bradd Roembke's profile picture
Bradd Roembke1 year ago

Not at all. One of the greatest catches ever.

The Rev's profile picture
The Rev1 year ago

Honestly, it’s underrated

Jeff Bates's profile picture
Jeff Bates1 year ago

Ummmm no

Sarcasm Level Expert's profile picture
Sarcasm Level Expert1 year ago

Not a chance. He was one of the best to make catches like that.

HuronShipwreck's profile picture
HuronShipwreck1 year ago

Nope. Never thought it was overrated and on rewatching I feel the same way

Eric The Red's profile picture
Eric The Red1 year ago

Nope. It’s an all time top 5 catch

SS's profile picture
SS1 year ago

Hello no

John Surtin's profile picture
John Surtin1 year ago

No. That was a phenomenal catch, in a dead sprint, straight over his head.

Related Videos

I’m probably on a island here but I think this Jim Edmonds catch is super overrated
0:43

I’m probably on a island here but I think this Jim Edmonds catch is super overrated

BaseballHistoryNut

170,777 views • 2 months ago

A lot of followers are saying “Jim Edmonds is a HOF snub”. He seems to be as overrated as this catch was. Not a HOFer imo
0:43

A lot of followers are saying “Jim Edmonds is a HOF snub”. He seems to be as overrated as this catch was. Not a HOFer imo

BaseballHistoryNut

183,712 views • 1 year ago

Jim Edmonds makes an unreal catch
0:35

Jim Edmonds makes an unreal catch

BaseballHistoryNut

248,411 views • 3 years ago

28 years ago today, Jim Edmonds made one of the most overrated catches of all time
0:31

28 years ago today, Jim Edmonds made one of the most overrated catches of all time

BaseballHistoryNut

1,176,549 views • 1 year ago

Where does this Jim Edmonds catch rank among the all-timers?
0:45

Where does this Jim Edmonds catch rank among the all-timers?

OldTimeHardball

35,147 views • 6 months ago

Jim Edmonds was playing shallow and David Howard hit it much harder than expected, but Edmonds chased it down and made the spectacular catch
0:43

Jim Edmonds was playing shallow and David Howard hit it much harder than expected, but Edmonds chased it down and made the spectacular catch

BaseballHistoryNut

429,631 views • 2 years ago

This catch by Jim Edmonds still makes my jaw drop every time I see it
0:45

This catch by Jim Edmonds still makes my jaw drop every time I see it

Kent Murphy

34,470 views • 1 year ago

Is that Jim Edmonds son playing in right field?
0:29

Is that Jim Edmonds son playing in right field?

Barstool Sports

535,195 views • 4 months ago

Drop whatever you’re doing, folks Jim Edmonds makes an iconic catch for the ages that I will probably watch 20 times tonight; was Edmonds unfairly snubbed by HOF voters?
0:45

Drop whatever you’re doing, folks Jim Edmonds makes an iconic catch for the ages that I will probably watch 20 times tonight; was Edmonds unfairly snubbed by HOF voters?

Not Gaetti

24,262 views • 5 months ago

Jim Edmonds That guy rocked.
1:14

Jim Edmonds That guy rocked.

That Guy Rocked MLB

120,051 views • 20 days ago

Jim Edmonds was a demon in the field
1:00

Jim Edmonds was a demon in the field

OldTimeHardball

117,679 views • 2 months ago

Willie Mays makes “the catch” Cannot believe some say this catch is overrated!
0:20

Willie Mays makes “the catch” Cannot believe some say this catch is overrated!

BaseballHistoryNut

17,554 views • 7 months ago

OTD: 9/4/04 Jim Edmonds hits his 300th career home run💣
0:59

OTD: 9/4/04 Jim Edmonds hits his 300th career home run💣

Cardinals Talk

10,643 views • 1 year ago

Single most overrated catch in MLB history ????
0:29

Single most overrated catch in MLB history ????

🏳️‍⚧️Casas Thought club🇵🇱

120,008 views • 2 months ago

27 years ago today Jim Edmonds made one of the greatest catches of all-time 🤯
0:38

27 years ago today Jim Edmonds made one of the greatest catches of all-time 🤯

FOX Sports: MLB

640,501 views • 2 years ago

Name a player that should be in the Hall of Fame, but isn’t. I’ll start: Jim Edmonds
0:47

Name a player that should be in the Hall of Fame, but isn’t. I’ll start: Jim Edmonds

Big League Digest

626,591 views • 3 years ago

Is Kyle Williams being overrated? James Stewart ☝️ Tony Massarotti Michael Felger Jim Murray Kevin Maggiore Felger & Massarotti Kyle Fabrizio
10:03

Is Kyle Williams being overrated? James Stewart ☝️ Tony Massarotti Michael Felger Jim Murray Kevin Maggiore Felger & Massarotti Kyle Fabrizio

98.5 The Sports Hub

23,282 views • 1 year ago

good morning, everyone. The Cardinals play the Reds in Cincinnati today One of the best catches of Jim Edmonds careers 😤
0:54

good morning, everyone. The Cardinals play the Reds in Cincinnati today One of the best catches of Jim Edmonds careers 😤

Cardinals Talk

56,468 views • 1 year ago

OTD: 07/06/04 Jim Edmonds robs Adam Dunn of a home run😮‍💨 one of the best catches you’ll see.
0:55

OTD: 07/06/04 Jim Edmonds robs Adam Dunn of a home run😮‍💨 one of the best catches you’ll see.

Cardinals Talk

19,664 views • 9 days ago