Is Jim Edmonds catch overrated?

Maybe the best catch ever

Do you agree?

not a chance - unreal fkn catch i tried doing this one time when I played for team Toronto and I damn near broke my face and back and completely missed the ball - lucky tho I threw the guy out trying to get a triple

Not at all. One of the greatest catches ever.

Honestly, it’s underrated

Ummmm no

Not a chance. He was one of the best to make catches like that.

Nope. Never thought it was overrated and on rewatching I feel the same way

Nope. It’s an all time top 5 catch

Hello no

No. That was a phenomenal catch, in a dead sprint, straight over his head.