Skip navigation
Israeli historian Ilan Pappé explains....
0:00 / 2:54

Israeli historian Ilan Pappé explains....

Rahul SA 🇿🇦

@Rahul_AJ_199011K followers

Visit on X
586 likesDownloadOriginal post

18,154 views

Israeli historian Ilan Pappé explains....

30 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Lyrical Ability Controls Everything's profile picture

    @LACEdaFlyFellow

    Pure gibberish. The question of Jewish indigeneity to the land has conclusively been answered by genetic studies. I, as a Christian descended from pagans, have no indigenous ties to the Levant. His claim that my religious tie is similar to the ties of European Jews is lying.

    7 likes

  • Paul Smyth's profile picture

    @berealalistic

    It’s exactly the same as the British going in to India. Every single Israeli in power is WHITE EUROPEAN. Just look at the colour of their skin 🙏 They have zero connection with that part of the world

    5 likes

  • Skendong Poetry's profile picture

    @_Skendong

    A very clear explanation indeed.

    2 likes

  • Knight Knight's profile picture

    @KnightK85816183

    He is an Israeli Historian, but doesn't know that Palestine never existed? Weird... Point me to it in the Quran since it has such a deep spiritual connection to the land. Must be a happy coincidence that it is the result of Romans renaming Judea to get it. They just got lucky.

    1 like

  • George Jacobs's profile picture

    @Salem_GeorgeJ

    He's asked a question of the origins of the Jews and he deflects. Arabs are not indigenous to the Levant, and Christians can be any nationality. What a brain dead tool.

    1 like

  • Max Loykas's profile picture

    @Cookoo98239664

    Bollocks. The so called indigenous people were Arabs from neighbouring lands. They were never dispossessed. Jewish immigrants bought land from landlords when they arrived. Arab generals instructed Arab occupants in Israel in 1948 to vacate the land and return after they win the war, which they lost. This is the Nakba, the catastrophe.

    1 like

  • RandomMusings's profile picture

    @RandomMusings6

    All humans alive today had ancestors who migrated or were expelled from different places (including my own). Jews are not special in this regard. What they are doing is unethical and immoral.

    1 like

  • We the People's profile picture

    @lilly9298759

    Palestinians were not even paid for the homes from where they were forcibly expelled Put the shoe on the other foot and ask if Jews would accept the same forcible expulsion with no right of return

    1 like

  • Tom Hawklin Jr's profile picture

    @TomHawklin10558

    Working For Press TV An Iranian Propaganda Channel that used torture to obtain fake confessions. Rotten. Easily bought.

    1 like

  • The Master of Darwish's profile picture

    @Th447371

    It is a misconception that is often misused by the antizionists that refer to Jews as only a religion like Islam or Christianity The Jewish religion came to be called Judaism because it became a vehicle to continue the national identity of the Jewish people following their expulsion from Judea.. Jewish identity first as a tribal confederation and later as a nation was established hundreds of years before the consolidation of what we now know as Judaism the religion Jews were known as a distinct people centuries BEFORE the consolidation and later evolution of their cultural practices and faiths into a cohesive religious community. Papa is a liar

    1 like

  • LeORaSoma's profile picture

    @LeORaSoma1

    My mother was there and the British definitely occupied Palestine as the French did Lebanon No one’s ever met at the white British coloniser

    1 like

  • Libbylefty4Gaza's profile picture

    @libbyliberalnyc

    It is totally gobsmacking that Kamala is showing up highest in most Dem Party national polls for prez for 2028 after her unconditional support for the genocide launched under Biden. After her own reverberating defeat in the 2024 election. Wt absolute f???? It is chilling that so many of the Dem Party establishment and its followers are now proving to be such card-carrying zombie sociopaths after 3 years of daily evidence of relentless and merciless Israeli annihilation of the Palestinian people and now the Lebanese all with the use of US-supplied deadly weaponry. Not only are these Americans willing to ignore the daily published suffering of helpless fellow human beings but also such earnestly expressed and often publicly-demonstrated collective outrage of substantial numbers of horrified fellow Americans and global brethren. How can this begin to be explained? Scott Peck said evil is moral laziness to the nth degree. Accompanied by colossal ignorance? But how can they still be incapable of such minimal critical thinking along with an incapacity of exercising even a minimal humanitarian sensibility — a minimal exercising of collective conscience? Is it Stockholm Syndrome out of authoritarian-following enthrallment to the corrupt and amoral corporate political establishment and its omnipresent corporate, Zionist-run propagandizing media? We domestic and global non-sociopaths must contend with our profound despair of this latest proof of the dystopian levels of implacable denial among these profoundly dreadful but seemingly banally clueless Americans.

    1 like

  • JD Slazenger's profile picture

    @Diocletian212

    Pappé is a communist. Enough said.

  • Jourum's profile picture

    @Tiberius67587

    I like all those "Historians" that seem to make the most absurd claims while rejecting 99% of all historians, became they need to promote some propaganda.

  • Josh Maranry - Top Click Media's profile picture

    @TopClickMediaSA

    Quoting a Kapo

  • Mike Tyr der Aufklärer - Übergott und Übermensch's profile picture

    @DonnerErel

    Rhis is worthless slave talk who respect death dead as there god. Worthless for me now. Nothing to learn hear anymore.

  • Hardus Hartzenberg's profile picture

    @Hardus_Hartzenb

    This Jewish idiot does not even know that Israel was promised to the sons of Israel, given to the Islamists by Israel government, and now saw that it did not apease the Islamists who want to colonize the whole world. Stupid stance to take.

  • AntonSollo's profile picture

    @AntonSolloneon

    Muslims didn't exist back then, he is cherry picking the history time for his benefit, Historians are politicians with "time machine".

  • MrSheen's profile picture

    @olsona635

    Where did Islam come from? The other two religions are indigenous to the land. You dont get to keep starting wars, lose them and claim you are victims.

  • Horatio Hornblower's profile picture

    @hornblowerone

    What utter nonsense.