"It was selfish." Author Lionel Shriver reflects on her decision not to have children.
213K followers
187,521 views
35 Comments
Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

@TeeBaille
I love her! I love her writing. I did not want to have children when I was younger. I was not raised to believe it would be valuable. I changed my mind the day I met my husband in my mid 30s. Being a mother is the best thing I have ever done and will ever do.
63 likes

@JamesHo35836287
An important perspective: "I was given something that I refused to give back" the gift of life and love! "I was selfish"--my life and comfort was more important than future generations of humanity. There are many like her, yet few willing to face the ire of the feministas.
56 likes

@MarkRichardson2
Shriver wrote something similar back in 2006:
52 likes

@meghan_daum
Lionel is making a very nuanced point that, to my reading, is less about personal regret than a statement of fact about larger population trends. She and I have talked about this in interviews before and will again. For my part, I share much of her sentiment while also having zero regrets about my own choices. Both can be true at the same time.
52 likes

@EdwardYYZ
Now that I'm too old for breeding, I'm coming to agree with Ms. Shriver on the selfishness idea, that I failed at a key part of my civic responsibility. (Complicating factor: at an early age, my father told me "Never get married" and my mother told me "Never have children.")
44 likes

@BosqueBrief
I’ve thought about how you are part of an unbroken chain of 2 billion years of successful sexual reproduction, and yet you cannot be bothered to participate? it will interfere with your sleep? Travel plans? Or “career?” Ok, good luck with that.
38 likes

@Quillette
Full video:
38 likes

@Bucks53
I admire her honesty, and her willingness and ability to face reality. Her writing reflects this.
29 likes

@botsisname
It’s not just passing on the gift that was given to you by your parents it’s an unbroken chain of life for over 3 billion years that said yes and then you say no?
20 likes

@JoshSchoen
wow, so well said... respect for being so honest
18 likes

@yogamaryreilly
The decision not to have children is maladaptive in terms of evolution - a tendency which will rapidly be removed from the gene pool.
16 likes

@mayorquimby123
@clairlemon For most boomers it was a choice. For many people of subsequent generations, it's the forced choice of declining economic conditions.
14 likes

@Samuelschmamuel
Yet, so many parents are fairly poor parents, they go into it unthinkingly. Don't nurture their kids enough, so it's also a form of selfishness to have kids without really consciously committing and choosing, rather than just drifting into it. Which is what I see many seem to do.
13 likes

@Gypsy45Beach
Sadly true. It's not just the women. Many men shirk their responsibilities as well.
7 likes

@Quillette
You can purchase Lionel Shriver's latest book here:
7 likes

@AConcernedPare2
Very well said. The decision not to have children is ultimately rooted in selfishness.
6 likes

@BitterTonic
Meh. Calling women selfish for not having children? This is just regular male supremacist lingo used by authoritarians. (Shriver always teeters on MAGA's edge, picking up their ideas) The US is going full Fascist. Don't get sucked in.
6 likes

@SunnydaleDreams
This is bollocks. "Selfish" is HAVING kids because you want want want an endless list of imagined goodies out of it. Never thinking about will those children benefit from YOU. There are selfish reasons to HAVE children. It's not selfish to abstain from that.
5 likes

@BobMuenkel
I applaud her self-awareness. We need more of this.
5 likes

@gar18784
She's a Narcissist. She thinks she's special. Today, it's common sense not to have kids when you can't earn enough money to pay for housing and medical. Also, 20 years ago the problem was over population. What happened?
5 likes













