It’s worth noting that there is no evidence that Nathan Cofnas is either a eugenicist or a racist. Or at least I have not seen any evidence of it. Horizontal differentiation - acknowledging that differences exist - does not imply that any moral hierarchy should be imposed. This kind... of obfuscation is routinely used to tar anyone who discusses group differences as a bigot. The same rhetorical move is applied to those who acknowledge biological differences between the sexes. Does saying men and women are different make you a sexist? Absurd right. So apply the same thing to race. Moreover, the smoking gun quote where Nathan Cofnas allegedly said that "blacks would disappear from almost all high-profile positions outside of sports and entertainment" is quite literally a direct reference to a 2013 Harvard report. Many commentators and mainstream media outlets accusing the Arday whistleblower of racism from The Observer to The New Yorker are CLEARLY taking him out of context ⬇️show more

In fact, I would even argue that Cofnas is kinda woke as he thinks that these group differences actually warrant distributive interventions such as racial quotas See him defend his views against @MrWinMarshall's on color-blindness:

@MrWinMarshall They know and they don’t care - without DEI, their world collapses.

@MrWinMarshall The same mainstream commenters AGREE with Cofnas. They all think abolishing affirmative action would lead to that.

@MrWinMarshall Correct. They know that we will never get "equal representation" if the universities abolished affirmative action

@MrWinMarshall I made a chart of what is meant by "racist". In this case they mean one of the fake critical race theory redefinitions. If your definition is something like category 2 (old meaning of racial hatred) then what you're looking for is not what they're alleging.

It also appears that Cofnas may be autistic, or as they say on the spectrum. Which might explain his lack of social grace and inability to stay quiet about things people would really really rather he kept quiet about. Whilst gregarious and charming Arday was likely faking his autism claims. This feels like a satirical novel that is a bit on the nose,

@MrWinMarshall Here's a thought for the day, Melissa. Every time a girl selects a smart, successful, broad-shouldered man as husband, that's 'eugenics'. Every time a man selects a pretty, healthy, long-legged woman, that's 'eugenics'. ALL life forms 'discriminate'. Its a matter of survival.

@MrWinMarshall 100%

@MrWinMarshall I listened to this episode and he comes across as VERY run of the mill not racist and even advocates FOR affirmative action.

@MrWinMarshall Please comment on JKR's post saying she thinks Cofnas is racist, and compare this with John Cleese's long-standing TDS. Both of these great people have awakened to reality, but they still seem to be caught in the tentacles of the MSM of Britain to some extent.

@MrWinMarshall When you change the meaning of words, you can create any narrative you want. Example Jason Ardays suicide being a lynching and assassination.

There are racial differences in intelligence because of evolution. Humans have different size brains, cerebrums, cerebral cortexes, prefrontal lobes, prefrontal cortexes, parietal lobes, temporal lobes, occipital lobes, etc. East Asians (specifically Japanese, Chinese, and Koreans) are the most intelligent, followed by Northern Europeans, then mulattos, and lastly Sub-Saharan Africans In the United States of America, Koreans, Chinese, Indians, and Ashkenazi Jews average 1300 SAT and 27 ACT. Whites average 1100 SAT and 21 ACT. Hispanics average 950 SAT / 18.5 ACT. Native Americans, Blacks, and Pacific Islanders, average 900 / 16 ACT. “Asians” average 1250 / 24 ACT because Vietnamese (and other “Asians”) bring the “Asian” average down by scoring 1100 SAT / 21 ACT The difference in General Intelligence between White Americans and Black Americans is the same as the difference between White Americans and Jews, Indians, Chinese, and Koreans in America General Intelligence (USA) Native American 91 Black American 91 Pacific Islander 91 Hispanic American 94 White American 103 Asian American 111 Korean, Chinese, Indian 115 Ashkenazi Jew 115 Full Scale IQ (USA) Black American 85 Hispanic American 90 White American 100 East Asian 108 Ashkenazi Jew 108 Full Scale IQ (Worldwide) Aborigines 65 Bushmen 70 Sub-Saharan African 75 North African 80 Southwest Asian 80 Middle Eastern 85 Native American 85 African American 85 Pacific Islander 85 Latin American 85 Southeast European 90 Southeast Asian 90 Southwest European 95 North Eastern European 95 Northern European 100 East Asian 108 Ashkenazi Jew 108 4 Race Breakdown IQ (Worldwide) East Asian 105 European 95 Mulattos 85 Sub-Saharan 75

@MrWinMarshall He admitted himself that he subscribes to it dear

@MrWinMarshall ChatGPT thinks he's racist.

@MrWinMarshall Leftists are like infants trying to draw: squiggly lines all over the place that bear no relation to what they are attempting to portray; no room for shade, definition or nuance. Tell them their painting is crap and they have a tantrum and start throwing things

@MrWinMarshall Analyzing "racist” data is enough to get you labeled a racist.

@MrWinMarshall What’s wrong with being a eugenicist?

@MrWinMarshall He puts whites third for IQ ...and on aggregate, he is correct Worst white supremacist ever

@MrWinMarshall Every person who prefers to marry into their own race is a racist. Is there anything wrong with this? Almost everyone on earth is a racist by that definition. The word should simply lose its power.

@MrWinMarshall These are thoughts and ideas of people with little to no experience living among different people. I have lived with people from different parts of the world for long periods of time. What is measured as IQ largely depends on culture and environment.

@MrWinMarshall How do we know you weren't hired by woke and DEI?

@MrWinMarshall Eugenics actually good. We use it all the time actually to check fetus and recommend abortion in case of severe abnormalities.

@MrWinMarshall They have to spin it or face reality.

@MrWinMarshall You're right, but expecting you'll convince a broader public of that is a losing game. That's why it's a shame that Cofnas has become the public face of the good guys in this Jason Arday story.

@MrWinMarshall When liberals chose Obama over Hilary as the president, were they treating Hilary immortally? When Cambridge hired and promoted Jason Arday over other black scholars, was it treating other black scholars immortally?

@MrWinMarshall You seem to think they are operating in good faith.

@MrWinMarshall Invoking Lee Kuan Yew is revealing, why do you present hereditarianism as neutral science when its proponents are openly discussing how society should be organised around presumed biological differences between populations? That’s the debate.

@MrWinMarshall Over the last few years I’ve noticed a lot of people REALLY struggle with is/ought distinctions

@MrWinMarshall Nathan is the hero of this story.