Skip navigation
Jeff Dean explaining Google built a ChatGPT-style chatbot roughly a year before OpenAI released…
0:00 / 2:02

Jeff Dean explaining Google built a ChatGPT-style chatbot roughly a year before OpenAI released…

Linas Beliūnas

@linasbeliunas14K followers

Visit on X
2,339 likesDownloadOriginal post

394,186 views

Jeff Dean explaining Google built a ChatGPT-style chatbot roughly a year before OpenAI released theirs. Tens of thousands of Google employees were already using it and loved it. Leadership still killed any public launch because: • “What if people stop searching on Google?” • “What if it says inaccurate or ‘bad’ things?” Google invented the Transformer architecture, and still threw away the first-mover advantage for nothing. Innovator's Dilemma at its finest.

41 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • Arman Tsaturian's profile picture

    @armantsaturian

    google is like xerox in 70s invented the whole tech stack, failed to commercialise because of monopoly position on market

    59 likes

  • Linas Beliūnas's profile picture

    @linasbeliunas

    What about too big too fail?

    5 likes

  • Arman Tsaturian's profile picture

    @armantsaturian

    maybe. xerox and ibm are still around. but the question is who wins, not who stays alive

    7 likes

  • phebbar's profile picture

    @phebbar

    Nothing new. I have heard unconfirmed stories of Microsoft having had a version of Google docs based on its office in the works much before Google released docs. History repeats. The incumbent factor is too much to bear. And did we forget Xerox ignoring PARC work. There are many more like that I guess.

    18 likes

  • John Smith's profile picture

    @Wood_Maya_8

    Pichai needs to go

    17 likes

  • Linas Beliūnas's profile picture

    @linasbeliunas

    Brin/Page back in?

    3 likes

  • AlphaBull's profile picture

    @AlphaBullish

    Is that googles kodak moment

    10 likes

  • Linas Beliūnas's profile picture

    @linasbeliunas

    You think so?

    1 like

  • Ben Schulz's profile picture

    @schulzb589

    @AlphaBullish Kodak had the best digital camera for around 2 to 4 years.

    1 like

  • AlphaBull's profile picture

    @AlphaBullish

    @linasbeliunas They were the first in 1975 company killed it citing loss of film revenue, sounds similar to What if people stop searching on Google?

    1 like

  • davidlee's profile picture

    @davidlee

    It's also completely rational and understandable why they made those choices. That's the whole point of the Innovator's Dilemma. He didn't call it "The Innovator's Choice" Also if you believe we're barely at the beginning in AI with many games to play (frontier, enterprise, diffusion, consumer, etc), they still remain better positioned than most

    5 likes

  • Steve Kyler's profile picture

    @steveky1er

    Just an observation — Google had the tech early and still played it safe. Not financial or career advice.

    4 likes

  • A. Ego's profile picture

    @CobAltEgo

    A guy was so spooked by it he quit and blew the whistle. @grok what was his name?

    4 likes

  • Joee113's profile picture

    @Joee1131

    Well said

    2 likes

  • Jackson Ling's profile picture

    @jackson_llk

    @chargrnmn @grok where can i watch the full interview?

    2 likes

  • TheActualNomad's profile picture

    @TheActualNomad

    @grok if Jeff is Level 11 who could really kill that? CEO or the board?

    2 likes

  • 幂等之力's profile picture

    @EdwinAb42897535

    当你一个不能被忽视的大家伙时 你就不得不对很多事负责 负责意味着你有很多事情不能做 至少不能没有顾虑的做 这些事里面很大一部分是跟创新有关的 这不是谁的错 宇宙本就是这样运作的

    2 likes

  • The Unblinking Eye's profile picture

    @Unblinking3Y3

    Microsoft Tay

    2 likes

  • David T's profile picture

    @datval

    "What if people stop searching on Google?" - I don't think he ever implied this. The issue clearly was accuracy associate with Google. Google telling you to do something stupid is not the same as an experimental product from "unknown" start-up like OpenAI doing the same.

    2 likes

  • Sipho Ngwenya's profile picture

    @seeps001

    It's easy to criticize after the fact

    1 like