Video wird geladen...
Video konnte nicht geladen werden
John MacArthur brilliantly explaining why we don't need to agonize over trying to understand how God's sovereignty and human responsibility work together: "People say, 'Oh, I can't understand election and I can't understand how it fits with choice.' Look, I can't understand a lot of things, and you know... show more
87,780 Aufrufe ⢠vor 9 Monaten ā¢via X (Twitter)
40 Kommentare

MacArthur put forward doctrines that were historically condemned by the Church, masked contradiction under appeals to mystery and tangled his followers up into all sorts of knots, leaving them a hundred times worse off than when he found them. Flee to Christ. Abandon Calvinism

Full video

As my dad always taught me: endeavor to understand the Lord. But until you do, your inability to understand Him should not prevent you from trusting and believing what you do understand.

Thatās very wise counsel.

Calvinism is false and not in scripture.

With all due respect to MacArthur this is the same kind of thing said by Islamists about the contradictions in their text. I wouldnāt call it brilliant. But the things is, an argument defending mysterious contradictions in the Bible is not necessary because the Bible nowhere teaches that God controls everything (JMacās definition of sovereignty). Man is responsible for his sin because he is the one and only cause of his sin. Not God.

MacArthur is telling you the contradictions in Calvinism are so incredibly blatant that thereās no making sense of it so donāt even try.

One thing that he did not understand but should have is that sinner's will are bound to sin and can never be obedient to God with respect to their right behavior...

What in the world are you talking about? Christians are not bound by sin. What false religion are you involved in?

Election is based on God's foreknowledge, so free will of man is true. There is nothing complicated about it.

I do believe there are some keys in Scripture to help us make better, though not exhaustive, sense of the conundrum in my book which I was privileged to have John endorse and tell me personally how important he thought it was:

Thereās a big difference between a mystery and a flat out logical contradiction. We have free will AND pre-destined fates at the same time? Thatās a square circle, not a mystery. Godās sovereignty doesnāt permit Him to create logical inconsistencies, nor does it force Him to run things the way Calvin and MacArthur said He must.

With all due respect to pastor MacArthur... who was brilliant on many issues, especially culturally, he could not understand it because he embraced the untenable position of theological determinism. Once you let that go, embrace a robust view of God's knowledge and a sovereignty that has to deal with lordship rather than meticulous control, the scriptures reveal that human responsibility is tied to man's libertarian freedom and God has sovereignty over these free creatures to grant or deny them access to himself.

@DevinAkin Yep!! Why would I think that as a finite creature, I could fully understand an infinite God?

Then how did Adam and Eve rebel before sin was introduced. Almost seems like God gave them a free will and that itās very important to God and parents and everyone in any kind of meaningful relationship. Prove me wrong.

Yes, letās hold to a high view of God whose ways are inscrutable.

Can someone explain to me using scripture. 1. How can man be chosen for salvation (Calvinist Doctrine of Election), then condemned (Romans 5:18), and then again be saved before the foundation of the world? 2. How can you be saved if you havenāt heard the Word (Romans 10:14) and believed in the Resurrection? (Romans 10:9-13) 3. Why would God send His Son into the world to save the world (John 3:17; Luke 5:31-32)) if they have already been saved before the foundation of the world? 4. If the Lord is Lord of all (Romans 10:12) and there is no distinction between Jew and Greek, and He wishes no one to perish (2 Peter 3:9), why would He choose only some people to be saved before the foundation of the world?

Itās a preacherās way of saying āwe made this stuff up, and it makes no sense, but thatās because God is so sovereign.ā

So God gave us a word he didn't want us to understand? You know this is not an issue if you just remove the lens of Calvinism. The Bible speaks for itself and is not difficult to understand

The most important thing is to believe what the Bible says about salvation, forgiveness of sin, and new life in Christ. It matters that God chose His elect before the foundation of the world because it establishes grace as the foundation of our salvation, and that for His glory. The bible clearly teaches that salvation, as established by God, precludes all boasting. If we choose God in any way, we can boast. Sinners don't choose Christ, they submit to the One who subdued their heart and saved them. Nowhere does Scripture teach that fallen sinners can choose Christ.

Well it is a mystery but Holy Spirit explained it in the epistles and said we have the mind of Christ. The Great Revelation is that we have become ONE with God, and He renews our mind to understand more and more each day what that actually means as we diligently seek Him. John 14:20 KJV At that day ye shall know that I am in my Father, and ye in me, and I in you.

Parallel truths that meet in eternity. We don't need to comprehend it.

Thatās just sooo good š¤š»

I thought he handled this in such a helpful way. I loved seeing how personable he was while teaching a smaller group.

That is a public confession that John does not follow instructions God gave when studying Gods word. Luke 24:44-45, 1Peter 1:10-12, John 5:39, John 17:3. He violates Gods creation Gen 1:26-27. Genesis 33:10, ROM 8:29, 1John 2:27. Thus he does not understand Romans 9.

When MacArthur stated: āOh, I canāt understand electionā, he really means HE canāt understand election. MacArthur later admitted that limited atonementā¢ļø invokes tension with the word of God creating a ātheological dilemmaā. He white knuckled that dogma to the end.

Thatās a cop out. No, you donāt have to live with that. There is an explanation but many are unwilling to hear and accept it.

Our problem isnāt that God is mysterious ā itās that we demand He fit inside our skull.

One of the greatest heretics of the modern times. What a false teacher. Calvinist and Dispensationalist. Two of the most unbiblical doctrines. I know this comment will offend some calvinolaters because I am speaking against their golden calf.

That's my position on the subject as well. Very well articulated.

Hand waving and appealing to mystery may work for some, but if you cant accept God designing contradictions, then consider that maybe the Calvinist understanding of sovereignty might just be wrong. The contradictions suddenly dissappear.

did the original authors believe the doctrine of election to be what John M believes it to be. Or, was there a first century Jewish understanding of the term chosen and elect that we need to think about? Letās not hold two contradictory beliefs in our head, thatās called a lie.

Preaching both is great, it just means he shouldnāt be a Calvinist
What it forces someone to do is reexplain yo everyone who gets saved that they were saved by divine selection before they believed. We donāt need to create the gymnastics. Hear. Believe. Confess. God saves. Thatās Ephesians 1. Believing has never been characterized as a work of a redeemed person. It is contorted to such because of the āover deadnessā of the T in tulip. Asking someone to blindly jump off a premise of choosing one side of God showing us both sides where we can at that point proclaim that we donāt logically get it in the place where God is worshipped and we are not proclaiming ourselves to have it figured out.

"Whosoever WILL" denotes FREE WILL - CHOICE. calvinism is a cult

I heard this on a radio broadcast once. Never forgot it. Thank you.

And look at that drip!

This was so good. One of the best clips of his Iāve seen. Thank you for sharing!

Youāre welcome. I loved seeing him interact with a smaller gathering and how warm and funny he was even while communicating such deep truths.

Absolutely! His demeanor came across very different in this setting. Loved it!
