Let’s see who is able to tell…

Pink is AI But also both could be and it's a trick question ;)

Best theory so far

Either way, I think both could pass as REAL to most people. Especially those who are not in the space.

@iamneubert Pink shirt based on audio only

@iamneubert So is audio the missing piece?

pink is AI the biggest tell is the film grain that is naturally present in real recordings. Green has it but it's not present in the pink one, it looks more like the background is freezeframed. Also, one of your pictures is reflecting a palm tree or something outside and there is not even the tiniest subtle movement in the leaves, it stays in the exact same position -whereas in green it moves a little because there's a little bit of wind outside. By all means, this would fool anyone not being asked to take a close look, it's almost unnoticable.

@IXITimmyIXI Pink shirt is AI?

Make it fight a dragon and I will be able to tell you what is real and not real.

very tricky one. Pink is AI for sure. -blinks from green were real, with 1 fake pink blink - @ 0:12 green right eye squints - tough for ai to do this expression - CLINCHER = reflections don't move in pink (arrow)

Pink…you can hear it in the voice easily

I heard Laurel

If 1 is 100% real, I would go with Green is real. Simply guessing on the fact Pink never blinks and had more of a death stare.

What video models are you using to achieve this?

In Runway using Seedance 2.5 but the prompting and references also do a lot of heavy lifting as well

None of them are AI or both of them are AI, Ship of Theseus situation right now.

Green is real.

@iamneubert It’s hard to tell but green is real

visually, I can't tell. But audibly, the pink shirt has far less tonal changes. It's a far smoother voice so I would suspect pink is the AI.

Im going to say both are real

I think it's the pink shirt but it's almost impossible to tell, you have to look very hard at it and be looking. Then again they could both be real and this is bait

Pink is AI. Looking at the green plant at the bottom right of this video, the green shirt has grain or visible noise and slight camera motion. The pink shirt removes it and actually reduces the clarity on the plant a good amount as well as the whole scene has reduced quality.

Head movement is the dead giveaway. Pink’s head barely moves. Green shirt has more natural movements

Green is real pink is fake, facial errors and inconsistancies that and foliage movement in back reflection

both are real

Both are real, nice try

All are reals :P

Pink is 🤖

Both look real

They're both real.

Pink doesn’t blink

pink shirt is real. there's a number of tiny ugly human details you can see with pink that appear to be more air brushed or glossed over in green.

@iamneubert Green shirt has weird cadence

Both of them are real. I don't think AI is at the level yet to replicate the backgrounds + reflections exactly. Matter of fact it looks like you took a while to film since the sun came down on green shirt. The only think that makes me think is AI is your hairline; it alters a bit

Very easy to tell pink shirt is the AI

Green Heavy breath at the start felt prompted. Pink is more enthusiastic which also done by AI. Green is less human reactions and more pauses. Green tongue is somewhat confusing so I think it's green.

its definitely the pink shirt, but not by much.

Green is easy

Green is AI