38 Comments
Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

@WillO_VT
The way I’ve seen people explain the discrepancies is that ‘The Wizard of Oz’ is the story as told by the wizard himself (full of lies) and the events of ‘Wicked’ are what actually happened.
2,378 likes

@iamnopilot
this works but i think it's less interesting than a character study connecting the two versions together, and it's totally doable.
742 likes

@jawsdivision
Ive actually always thought this was a fun implication, bc with the spell it's implied she made him invincible so this is just them like doing improv
898 likes

@judejon_
She was just goofing around
613 likes

@gloomara
The Wicked series isn't in the same canon as the 1939 series. They're just individual properties from the same source (the book from 1900).
529 likes

@iamnopilot
this just isn't true. one of the most fundamental plot points of Wicked [Elphaba being green] originates in the film *not* the book.
367 likes

@iamnopilot
everyone wants this to be a simple causation chain but it's just not that simple. There are multiple sources of material and they all contribute.
125 likes

@V_A_L
are people not allowed to flirt anymore
435 likes

@micahsmars
ihatemybf final boss what an icon
392 likes

@salensekai
maybe they’re just freaky like that i won’t judge
265 likes

@iamnopilot
commentor asked, "why would you want this"
251 likes

@geokonic
for the last time, THE WIZARD OF OZ IS NOT CONNECTED TO WICKED!!!!!!!! the wicked witch in the wizard of oz is not elphaba and the scarecrow is not fiyero!!!!!!!! none of this happens in wicked!!!!!!!!!!
160 likes

@PezunCityDJs
There's a version of Wicked Act 2 where Boq and Fiyero are tagging along with Dorothy because they want to pull Elphaba back to her senses but she's legitimately so angry with grief that she thinks they're betraying her, but the play as is has no interest in that
137 likes

@Lasshatry
“Let him never die, let him never dieeeeee.” She knew it wouldn’t kill him. 🤷🏻♀️
109 likes

@knate_thorne
Wait tho when she sings the spell she says he will never die… could be a fun kink they are both in on knowing the fire won’t hurt him
83 likes

@geelykx
ngl they need to remake this movie or smth like a wicked 3 would lowk hit…
62 likes

@gypsy_GA
They were just committed to the bit
56 likes

@abtdbbb
The spell she says from the grimmerie says that he’ll never die. So she knows she can attack him as a demonstration of her power and it won’t harm him. She keeps the wicked illusion and doesn’t cause more harm or irreversible spells.
52 likes

@manuOGR
Mmmmaybe she doesn’t recognize him until she sees him up close at the very end …
46 likes

@nalushipfeak
like i said Wicked is fanfiction. the 1939 is an adaption for the book. this is why the Wicked story doesn't make sense at all. why would Scarecrow be in love with the Witch of the West? makes no sense at all.
35 likes

















