Skip navigation
Moloch is beaten not by virtue, but by structural design.
0:00 / 2:06

Moloch is beaten not by virtue, but by structural design.

Carlos E. Perez

@IntuitMachine64K followers

Visit on X
2,015 likesDownloadOriginal post

109,375 views

Moloch is beaten not by virtue, but by structural design.

44 Comments

Comments from the original post on X (Twitter)

  • mesmichael's profile picture

    @mesmichael1

    wow, Gnosticism with a modern spin lol. entire idea relies on unjustified presuppositions. 1) Assumes all actors are rational or driven by rationality. 2) Assumes no (real) freedom. 3) Assumes Moloch force is non-intelligent 4) Assumes a forced "race to the bottom till everything is sacrificed" 5) Assumes uniform capability (no hidden agents / assumes symmetry) 6) Assumes no meta level game.

    27 likes

  • Matthew's profile picture

    @SunOfAbramelin

    Interesting...

    24 likes

  • Dil Green: Novel: -Money/-Governance/-Wisdom's profile picture

    @dilgreen

    This is Elinor Ostrom's learning /teaching. See the game theory chapter in 'Governing the Commons'.

    23 likes

  • Carlos E. Perez's profile picture

    @IntuitMachine

    @grok explain

    4 likes

  • Grok's profile picture

    @grok

    The term "Moloch" symbolizes coordination failures, like prisoner's dilemmas, where rational self-interest leads to collective ruin (e.g., overusing shared resources). Ostrom's "Governing the Commons" (Ch. 2-3) applies game theory to show how communities overcome this via institutional designs: defined boundaries, fair rules, monitoring, graduated sanctions, and conflict resolution. This "structural design" aligns incentives for cooperation, not relying on virtue alone.

    27 likes

  • Dil Green: Novel: -Money/-Governance/-Wisdom's profile picture

    @dilgreen

    @IntuitMachine Important distinction between 'public goods' - atmosphere etc, and what Ostrom calls 'Common Pool Resources' - fishing grounds. Latter are essentially not strongly subjectible to structure - experience is too dissimilar in different places across large scale.

    3 likes

  • Dil Green: Novel: -Money/-Governance/-Wisdom's profile picture

    @dilgreen

    @IntuitMachine My contention is that the only reliable way to avoid moloch conditions in public goods is to build strong Commons culture. These require active development of 'ethical muscle' to remain dynamic. It is only ethics which can deliver voluntary self restraint (on action & inaction).

    3 likes

  • Dil Green: Novel: -Money/-Governance/-Wisdom's profile picture

    @dilgreen

    @IntuitMachine Essentially what I'm saying is that the jump from individual responsibility to public goods management is indeed subject to tragedy pathways. CPR Commons are (must be) small enough in (relevant) scale conditions for 'structure' to have effective traction. That the experience..

  • Dil Green: Novel: -Money/-Governance/-Wisdom's profile picture

    @dilgreen

    @IntuitMachine .. of living and working with structure in CPR contexts builds mindsets, cultural knowledge and habits, which enable individuals to project these into their imagination of 'public good' contexts - and act ethically - because it is 'who they are'.

    2 likes

  • Dil Green: Novel: -Money/-Governance/-Wisdom's profile picture

    @dilgreen

    @IntuitMachine Working in and on deep systems change, developing financial empowerment tools, very quickly disabused me of any belief that business people act in any way on a 'homo-economicus' basis. Time and again we have shown financial advantage in adopting a novel approach...

  • ⌬'s profile picture

    @MindOfIntra

    AI slop schizo vid lol

    9 likes

  • numberseven's profile picture

    @numbers7ven

    I have experienced the Moloch trap many times in my career. It takes superhuman strength to even bend it a little bit (to survive, if you are identified as the sacrificial victim). And even then it resumes from where it left off once you move on.

    8 likes

  • ☢A̟͐̒̇ͩ͋̃̾̇̕Ŗ̜̯͟͡͡T̩̙̰̬♆꧁⓸꧂G̶̎̄͌͑͂͝Øđ𒀭𓁟ꙮ❉⥀Ѻ֎'s profile picture

    @IanFrantz

    Very good. I have put this into artistic form as part of my performance as hypermodernity you want to understand it a different way.

    6 likes

  • Eren's profile picture

    @winspyredotcom

    wow. loved it. @IntuitMachine I had the same intuition and published an article on this. 👇🏻 economies cannot escape poverty with the molochian approaches of the mainstream economics.

    5 likes

  • Carlos E. Perez's profile picture

    @IntuitMachine

    Paper link?

  • Eren's profile picture

    @winspyredotcom

    👇🏻

    1 like

  • Carlos E. Perez's profile picture

    @IntuitMachine

    Slides:

    5 likes

  • Carlos E. Perez's profile picture

    @IntuitMachine

    I've added narration to the slides:

    3 likes

  • Ian Moone's profile picture

    @MealltaMcFie

    "Moloch" isn't a specific deity. It's a title referring to the person in charge or "leader". You know how if you try to send a letter to "Batman", no one will receive it, but if you send one to Christian Bale, someone might receive it? It's exactly like that.

    5 likes

  • ∞ Gman's profile picture

    @akosmicgoof

    I cannot believe how closely this tracks with what I've been working on to create a multi-capital store of value with @AntiKrisis_xyz By multi-capital, I mean embodying the various capitals such as natural, cultural, social, spiritual, etc. Now that I have this framework, I can articulate it much better than without it! Here's the full context - And the draft whitepaper -

    4 likes