"Nationalisation is the wrong answer. It's a political rather than a practical solution." Andy Bagnall from Rail Partners, which represents the parent companies of operators, tells #R4Today, as MPs are set to vote on a bill to take railways back into public ownership.

No way, the guy who represents the people making out like bandits from the current situation says that the situation shouldn't change? Knock me down with a feather

I'm begging the people who book guests on news programmes to familiarise themselves with the concept of "conflict of interest".

man whose job entirely depends on things being one way defends that way, largely because that's the job he's paid for. thanks lot bbc.

Next up, the spirits of Reggie and Ronnie who'll tell us about the disastrous effect money laundering and organised crime laws are having on London's nightlife

He claimed European train operators are looking to the UK as a great example of how to run railways. Yeah right !

they tell you these lobbyists are their to put their case to government but here they are along with our national broadcaster just shovelling propaganda out to the public.

Well, he would say that wouldn't he?

The nerve of the man! Public services should be owned by the public. His mates had a long time to fix the railways and it’s been a disaster.

Try starting with Rail company lobbyist says nationalising trains is bad......